For most of my career as a PC analyst, I have followed and chronicled the evolution of the PC. My first project when I came to Creative Strategies was to work with a new group formed inside IBM that created the original IBM PC. By the time I was asked to be involved in some design strategies and retail projects, the IBM PC had just become a hit and was in the process of solidifying the role of a PC in business.
A short time after the IBM PC became successful, clones started hitting the market. The most successful one of its day was the Compaq computer. I was privileged to attend the first ever Compaq analyst event in which all (four) PC analysts at the time were invited. In the early days of the PC, there really weren’t any PC analysts per se and those who had the title had been covering mini-computers — PCs were added to our research roles.
During the visit we spent time with Compaq Chairman Ben Rosen and Compaq co-founder Rod Canion to learn about their new PC clone and why they thought they would be successful. IBM had become a force with their PCs and I found it curious an upstart like Compaq would even challenge them. In fact, I asked Rod Canion during that visit why he decided to put up his own money and go after funding to take on IBM. He told me when he was at Texas Instruments, he learned early on that whatever IBM did, it would become a standard. He saw the success of the IBM PC and understood it was created with off the shelf parts and placed what he called a “sure bet” to create a competitor, knowing full well that IBM’s PC would become the standard for business computing. Not long after, Dell and others brought out clones too.
However, the one constant for all of these computers was an OS created originally for IBM known as MS-DOS. Since it was not proprietary, it was also licensed to Compaq, Dell, Acer, and about a couple of dozen other PC vendors in the heyday of the PC. MS-DOS eventually became Windows and this OS has been dominant for PCs and laptops for over 30 years. Of course, Apple created a computer OS for the Mac but Apple’s OS is proprietary and, even though it has done and is still doing very well, PCs running Windows out sell Macs exponentially.
It is interesting to note that, for most of Windows’ life, it was a local PC and laptop OS but Microsoft had visions of this OS becoming a standard for use in tablets and smart mobile devices as early as 1990. However, due to a lot of infighting inside Microsoft and a huge emphasis on productivity, they were never able to really establish Windows as a dominant OS beyond the PC. This opened the door for Apple and Google to create new operating systems designed just for mobile computers and IoT.
While Apple’s iOS is a huge success in its own right, like OS X, it is proprietary and used only on Apple products. On the other hand, Android has a lot of the original characteristics of Windows in that it is a licensable OS that can be used by any PC, tablet, smartphone and IoT vendors in the world. Indeed, if you look at the number of mobile devices on the market today running Android, it makes up about 75% of all products shipped.
At Googles recent I/O developer conference, Google’s leadership clearly stated they want Android to be the dominant OS for connected devices and IoT. Like Windows, Android is hardware agnostic and can easily be applied to any mobile or IoT device. Even more important is that Android serves as Google’s OS/UI to their overall cloud vision and are building most of their worldwide ecosystem of products and services channeled through Android.
Almost from the beginning, Bill Gates and Microsoft wanted their OS, and especially Windows, to be dominant on devices around the world. I still see that as their goal but, due to various choices and infighting, they are far behind Google and Apple in this quest — I don’t see that Windows outside of the PC could ever become a dominant device OS worldwide. Apple, with their proprietary approach, has made major strides in their quest to dominate the device market and with the iPhone, iPad, HealthKit, HomeKit, Car Play, Apple Watch and Apple TV they have emerged as a serious powerhouse of their own in this space. However, while in the past their main competitor was Microsoft and Windows, this time it is Google and Android and Android has become the Windows of our generation.
The big difference between Microsoft and Google is Microsoft still has to protect their legacy devices as well as try and move everything to their One Microsoft strategy. That is not easy to do. When it comes to mobile devices, their Windows mobile phones are a very distant third in the overall market of smartphones. As for IoT, iOS and Android clearly have an edge and momentum over Microsoft. Market projections from most research houses see Android basically dominating the market for mobile and IoT because it is device agnostic and is a free license for anyone that wants it.
From where I sit, it really does seem Android is the Windows of our day and Google is in a place to broaden their lead in mobile and IoT barring any serious missteps. Apple will be a worthy competitor and I don’t expect Microsoft to rest on their laurels and let Google dominate this space without a fight. However, Android’s lead in these two markets is quite huge and, if Google keeps moving in this direction and keeps their customers happy, I suspect Android, at least from a numbers viewpoint, will continue to be the dominant mobile and IoT system for many years to come.
I think there are a lot of similarities:
– an OEM-based business model, which has both advantages (choice of supplier, lots of different models for different niches ie rugged, flashy, XXS, XXL,…, price/features competition) and issues (quality control, race to the bottom, intra-ecosystem competition…)
– market dominance.
There are a couple of huge differences though:
– Open-sourceness, which does have the issue that competitors can freeload on the work Google does (I’d argue that’s by design, to avoid MS-like complacency, plus it lets Google sell Android in China), but mostly lets OEMs innovate and differentiate whether through HW or SW or even Cloud (if they ever manage to innovate there, which they haven’t)
– Free as in beer, the cost to the user is in terms of ads and tracking, to the OEM it is in terms of lost app/content store and ad/tracking revenue. I think a side effect of that one is that since OS updates are free too, there are fewer of them. That puts the focus back on hardware sales, which seems to run counter to history.
What I kinda lament is the internal competition with ChromeOS. I think Android would make a better laptop/desktop OS from the user point of view (native apps, less dependent on a internet connexion, lots more apps), while ChromeOS’s management advantage has already largely been backported to Android (limits to what the user can do/install, central management).
If there is to be intra-ecosystem diversity, applications need to execute. This means, at minimum, a common kernel in the OS as a standard. That it took Windows until version 7 and Android until version 4 to be “good enough” is almost immaterial, and is a separate issue. If there is to be a modular system, someone has to be the common OS.
Though nothing prevents it from being a desktop OS, I think it’s more apt to say Android is “Windows for mobile devices”. It actually goes one step further, the code is published and licensed under GPL. Among other things, this permitted the Kindle OS as well as ASOK in China. What matters though, is that Android applications run within the hardware/software requirements of the application.
Being BSD based, OSX can serve as a modular OS as well, if not for the proprietary interface and permission components, especially drivers. iOS could have been too, things are controlled at the permissions level even more. Aside from non-licensing, this rules them out as a potential standard. The culprit though is business, not tech.
The only part of Android under GPL is the Linux kernel.
To be encyclopedic about it, AOSP’s preferred license is Apache, specifically 2.0. The given reason is that Apache doesn’t force OEMs to opensource their modifications to AOSP’s base.
https://source.android.com/source/licenses.html
Hi Tim –
How do you see ChromeOS fitting into the GoogleMicrosoft interplay you describe ?
thanks !
It seems clear that Chrome and Android are on a collision course in the same way the Mac OS and IOS is moving towards being one in the same. I don’t know how long it will take either to unify their code and UI’s but in Google case I have already seen an Android laptop in the works. to a degree this maps what Microsoft is doing too. Windows PC and Window mobile are unifying around a tiling metaphor even though the apps have very different code. But in the end all three players are trying to build a single UI/OS architecture that will work on all devices.
Several Android laptops have already been released, one by HP for example. There are plenty of desktops too, including by Xiaomi, Huawei and ZTE. The Playstore-compatible Android gaming consoles also make OK desktops, though they tend to be more expensive than basic desktops.
Android became the windows for mobile by default because none of the oem’s had anything that could remotely go head to head with IOS when iPhone launched. Android was the only viable solution available to all of them, so everyone jumped on board and the rest is history. Although, I do not think we will see a repeat of that in the IOT space. If there is anything those oem’s learned is that not controlling the os/platform leaves you at a big disadvantage for comodizations. That is what happened on the android side and look at all the casualties, even samsung is not immune.
If anything, the IOT space will be a mess for years to come. I anticipate every oem’s will want to own the platform as a way to deal with commoditization. Samsung is already pushing their ARTIK platform and I am sure others will follow suit. For that reason, I do not see google replicating their dominance in the IOT space like they did with android. I actually like what Apple is doing more with their homekit framework. At least those oem’s will not feel threatened by their approach, unlike google’s.
Exactly the same thing happened when MS had the ONLY “IBM compatible” OS. Everyone had no choice but to sign up. But it did allow you to run the same software at home that you used at work/school. This prompted tremendous unimpeded growth, if for no other reason than economies of scale.
Shouldn’t OEMs feel more threatened by Apple than by Google ? Hasn’t Apple been booting headsets makers from their stores since they bought Beats, and cutting Monster from MFI over a conflict with Beats too ?
Will that be standard practice for IoT too ? buy into a category, boot competitors out or decertify them ?
I see your bias completely blinded you from what my point was. Apple strategy so far is not looking to own the IOT platform from those oem’s, but instead are building frameworks where oem’s can just add support for their products. Google is looking to replicate in the IOT space what they did with android, where they own the platform and let the hardware oem’s kill each other on price and the rush down to zero.
How did that work for those oem’s with android. The last position those oem’s needs to be is to hand over the IOT platform to google where they have no control over their own destiny, and google again extract all the values. It worked out so great for those oem’s that even samsung with all their resources are struggling. This time samsung is pushing their own platform in ARTIK. Unlike google, they create and sell products they can control to push their platform.
You missed the parallel I was making: like Apple wasn’t into headsets early on, then they bought a headset company, and former headset partners found themselves kicked to the curb w/o notice. That could repeat in IoT.
With a layered approach like Google’s, OEMs aren’t competing with the ecosystem’s owner, so there not such a huge risk.
I don’t know that it was entirely Apple kicking out Bose (there are still plenty of well respected, competing headsets at Apple, B&O, B&W, Blue). I think at the very least it was mutual, and it may even be Bose feeling a bit insulted, ala Steve Jobs when he felt a supposed partner betrayed him, so they could just as easily have ditched Apple. Bose has some pretty crazy retail agreements (if you’ve ever worked music retail, they are all a bit crazy).
Joe
Sure, let’t leave some minor detail about a lawsuit shall we? It’s obvious what you are trying to do here. We all can pinpoint bad stuffs companies do, we just don’t need to leave out some parts to make out points.
From a ubiquity standpoint, Android is clearly the new Windows. But there are major technical hurdles to overcome before Android could move from small-screen, touch-based devices to say, laptop devices.
Anyone following the behind the scene progressions of Apple’s iOS would be familiar with the technologies they had to develop just to properly utilize all the current screen sizes within the iOS family of devices – let alone split screen views and the rumored “iPad Pro.” And those are just the display issues.
Since Android is not a subset of a desktop OS, Google can’t simply graft the mouse/cursor/menu features back into Android to adopt it to laptop/desktops. No current Android software would be of much use on a laptop form factor without massive reengineering of both the Android OS and all of the user interface elements and graphics/display resources within the applications.
Any merged Android/Chrome hybrid would be years behind iOS and Microsoft’s efforts, right out of the gate.
“Since Android is not a subset of a desktop OS, Google can’t simply graft the mouse/cursor/menu features back into Android to adopt it to laptop/desktops. No current Android software would be of much use on a laptop form factor without massive reengineering of both the Android OS and all of the user interface elements and graphics/display resources within the applications.”
I wonder may be we underestimate the modularity of Android OS and it is not such a big effort to make it work for Chrome. I think Microsoft is trying to merge Windows OS both for Mobile and Desktops, so it should not be that hard.
Android already supports mouse or touchpad. Most apps work fine w/o touch.
OK. Then would it be fair to say that even if Android user applications for laptops and phones are different due to UI differences they will share the same look and feel? I think as long as there is only a limited number of UI/Form factors combinations, applications differences should not be an issue to handle for the developers.
I’m not sure I understand the question.
The type of pointer input (ie, touch, mouse, trackpad, trackpoint…) is already transparent to the developer. AFAIK, no developer has ever done anything specific to support those input methods, they’re just supported directly by the OS.
I’ve yet to come across an app that doesn’t work with all of the input devices I listed. Except of course for the multi-touch dependent ones: mice can’t do multitouch, at best you can zoom in/out w/ the wheel.
I am talking about the user, not developer. You know how menus are different on iOS and Mac OSX? The way to finish and launch applications? Look and feel to the user not necessarily dependent on an input method either it is a touchpad or a touchscreen. This is what I mean. So there should be different applications for laptops and phones even if they merge Mac OSX and iOS eventually. Which is not going to happens anyways I think anytime soon. Since I am not familiar with Chromebox I ask if a look and feel of applications there is the same as on Android OS, so it is easier to merge the two.
OK, thanks for the clarifcation. The two are only partly converged. Google’s new Material Design is cross-platform (web ie ChromeOS and Android), on purpose to hasten the rapprochement. But quite a few details do differ:
– Android’s UI is built around 3 buttons (back, Home and menu/recent apps) that ChromeOS doesn’t require.
– Android’s UI is touch-first, ChromeOS’s is kb+ms first, though both support the other
– many apps are different-ish, think Feedly’s web app vs their native mobile app for example.
Going from one to the other is not seamless. I’m putting my tech-handicapped users on Android desktops and not ChomeBoxes so they don’t have to learn anything different from their phone and tablet.
There is more to software functionality on a laptop than support for mice and keyboards.
such as ?
Sure. With effort it can be done. But as I opined, to reach the maturity consumers expect, especially when mature platforms already exist, will be a major undertaking. Unless you love using software designed to display on a little screen on your high-def laptop.
The obvious questions are who would buy it?, who would develop for it?, and how can anyone make any money off it?
Android on laptop-class devices would be years behind its competitors.
the obvious answers are: people who want something cheaper, lighter, easier than Wintel stuff; all android devs already develop for it; same as in the Windows world: by offering a good product+service for the right price.
“Android on laptop-class devices would be years behind its competitors.” same as a tablet is years behind full-fledged laptops. Different people need different things.
There are already Android desktops and laptops. Most apps work perfectly well, even w/o touchscreen, because Android fully supports mouse/touchpad… Some Android devices have had split-screen and PiP multiwindows for years.
Also, ChromeOS and Android are already partly merged: ChromeOS can run validated Android apps officially, and unvalidated Android apps w/ a workaround. And Chrome browser on Android can run most Chrome apps.
“Most apps work perfectly well…” Is a far cry from ready for mass consumer acceptance.
Klugey, half-baked operability is a hobbiest’s choice, but not a viable choice for people who like premium, dependable devices.
So let’s not pretend Android on a laptop is in the same league, division or ballpark as a Surface or iMac.
It doesn’t try to be, features-wise.
Consumer-readiness wise, I’ve got a couple of seniors on Android desktops because Android is so much easier than Windows, they’re happy with it. I wouldn’t call it kludgy , and maybe 95% baked. I’ve used it. have you, to support your very strong opinion ?
Why would I want to use it?
To know what you’re talking about,for once. How can you call it “Kludgey, half-baked” if you don’t even know what it’s like ?
On this point, I much prefer to remain uninformed.
I prefer to own quality. I buy quality food, clothes, cars, musical instruments, and tech. I spend my money on things with value.
The second-rate junk you keep blathering on about is of absolutely no interest to me. I am well served with the choices I’ve made, so I’ll ask you the same question any sane consumer would ask: why the hell would I want to buy that crap, when I could buy something so much better?
So, you admit to passing judgment and having an opinion on something you don’t know.
What word describes those kind of people ?
Yes. I admit to my good judgement. I have no need to experiment with or evaluate a class of products that do not offer any compelling use case for me. Whether the Android laptop is 10% or 95% as useful as other systems is irrelevant. The devices you are discussing are cheap junk that no one would buy if given a choice.
Have fun with your Android laptops. They suit you.
I know right.
You don’t know it so it’s bad
You don’t have it so it’s for losers
It’s not expensive so it’s beneath you
We are our things, and our things are us.
Are you saying that the currently available Android laptops are NOT cheap, underpowered plastic junk? Are you saying that they will hold their value (ha!) and receive regular OS upgrades? Are you saying that they offer some unique capabilities or software titles? Are you saying that they are a viable upgrade (ha!) for what I –or any other Mac and/or PC laptop owner– may already own?
I’ve asked you twice why I (or anyone else) should consider buying an Android laptop. The only answer you’ve provided can be paraphrased as: “so you can say you did.”
That’s simply not good enough. As the old saying goes, you don’t have to stick your hand in the fire to know you’ll get burned.
I, like other sane people, don’t buy things simply because they’re expensive or inexpensive. I buy things because of their value to me, both now and in the future. If that makes me an elitist, then I’m a proud elitist.
Or I did answer, but then again, I’m not sure you can read.
“Consumer-readiness wise, I’ve got a couple of seniors on Android desktops because Android is so much easier than Windows, they’re happy with it.”
“the obvious answers are: people who want something cheaper, lighter, easier than Wintel stuff”
“I’m putting my tech-handicapped users on Android desktops and not ChomeBoxes so they don’t have to learn anything different from their phone and tablet.”
I did neither say nor imply anything off your crazy list. Especially not about them being an upgrade for current Windows/MacOS laptops owners. This is so ridiculous, only you could think of it.
Speaking of not answering question, I’m still waiting on that one:
informed > obarthelemy • 2 days ago
There is more to software functionality on a laptop than support for mice and keyboards.
obarthelemy > informed • 2 days ago
such as ?
An interface that takes full advantage of the screen resolution. Compatibility with and full use of the latest software APIs. Just off the top of my head.
– Laptops have similar resolutions as tablets, and very close sizes, so I fail to see how there’s a laptop-specific issue there ? Android has been handling a wide gamut of DPI and definition for years now.
– Plenty of people are using lap/desktops on older versions of OSes, so I fail to see how that’s a key requirement. Should we grad them and burn them (the PCs, or the users ?) Reciprocally, I don’t know any app that, for example requires Android 5.x, so I fail to see how “latest OS” can be a requirement except in very edge cases.
– “same level of functionality as the desktop” ? That only happens at the stratosphere of prices, if ever. I dare not think how much a laptop with a dual screen, SSD + HDD, high-perf GPU, 16GB RAM, hifi sound system, comfy keayboard… would cost, if it could be done. Indeed, Android cannot, just as Apple and Wintel can’t. And it would be mostly pointless.
Off the top of your head ? Are you sure your fanciful list of requirements wasn’t pulled out of somewhere else ?
Again, total B.S. My list of “fanciful” requirements are the requirements I have for anything I would buy. What isn’t a “key requirement” for you, is for me.
My laptop is not in the “stratosphere of prices.” I run the full Adobe Creative Suite. No loss of functionality. I’ve run Digital Performer & Logic on my laptop. No loss of functionality. I know people who run ProTools on a laptop. Again, no loss of functionality. These are not “edge cases.” My laptop is a serious, full-featured tool. It supports an external monitor if I want to go dual screen.
You keep confusing the capabilities of the Android OS (what it supports) with the capabilities of Android software (what the software actually implements). The two are not in sync. Most Android software is designed for phones. It’s actually a shame there are no apps requiring the latest Android. It shows how developers in the land of Android are held back by the fragmented ecosystem. That fragmentation will prevent any Android laptop from taking the world by storm. Which is why Android is NOT the new Windows.
“What isn’t a “key requirement” for you, is for me.”. Good first step. Now reciprocate it: what is a requirement for you, isn’t for everyone. Most people don’t run Adobe CS, so *you* need a laptop able to run it, *most people* (by far) don’t, and don’t want / can’t pay for an expensive capability they won’t use. But they want/need a laptop or desktop for some other reason, sometimes just force of habit, ergonomics, storage space, larger keyboard…. That’s what cheap PCs are about.
Now I see what the problem is. You keep confusing ‘laptop’ with ‘tablet’. You’re defining them by their FORM rather than their FUNCTION. A ‘laptop’ needs to run desk-top class software to be a ‘laptop.’
A ‘tablet’ with an attached keyboard is still just a tablet. It still runs a tablet OS and tablet apps. That is why I said there is more to software functionality on a laptop than support for a keyboard and mouse. We’re talking about two different things.
There is a world of difference between what an iOS device can be expected to do, verses what a laptop running OSX can do. There is NO real difference between what an Android ‘tablet’ and an Android ‘laptop’ can do. For the purposes of discussion we should observe that distinction.
Laptop *is* a form factor (Merriam-Webster: a portable microcomputer having its main components (as processor, keyboard, and display screen) integrated into a single unit capable of battery-powered operation).
The OS/ecosystem is relatively unimportant as long as the hardware is supported and the apps available. Today’s Chromebooks and Android laptops can do a lot more than the DOS laptops of yore.
Hybrids are indeed an interesting edge case, be it the dockable tablets, or the foldable laptops. I think the frontier between categories is blurring, with Mobile ecosystem enough for 80+% of users, and form factors bastardized.
They may be blurring, but they are still different. My examples prove that. Comparing today’s Android tablet capabilities to laptops of yore doesn’t change the fact that Android is a phone/tablet OS. Words have meaning, misunderstandings can be avoided when words are used properly.
Indeed. You should contact everyone, including HP, zdnet, every reviewer and user of an Android laptop ever, basically everyone on earth aware of the topic, and tell them they’ve got it wrong.
Or maybe you did ?
I don’t have to. The world figured it out on their own. That’s why you are the only person in your Android laptop user group.
I’ll make it easy for you, it’s even in the URL, most of the time.
http://www.zdnet.com/article/where-are-all-the-android-laptops/
http://www.amazon.com/HP-Slatebook-14-Inch-Touchscreen-Android/dp/B00KB3K6G4
http://www.laptopmag.com/reviews/laptops/hp-slatebook-14
http://www.expertreviews.co.uk/laptops/1401805/hp-slatebook-2014-review
Bonus question: if I install Android on my x86 Windows laptop or netbook, does it become a tablet ?
Let me quote some guy named obarthelemy from a June 24, 2015 reply to Kizedek:
“I don’t have the same faith as you in articles, hearsay, anecdotes rumors and news.”
That some idiot reviewer can’t see the difference between a REAL laptop and a plastic glorified piece-of-crap tablet doesn’t sway me. I can’t be bothered reading your links.
I linked a definition too. Both the theory and the practice disagree with you.
Fine. You win. Android is in the same league as OSX and Windows. You are so persuasive. Bonus question: If I install a terminal on my PC, does it become a mainframe?
That’s not what I’m saying, I’m saying Laptop is a physical form factor. The OS has nothing to do with any of it.
And you’re wrong.
I am a bit concerned that Android is open source. Although it appears that its availability in a source form and free model helped its high adoption for mobile devices.
We see though that proprietary platforms and open platforms differ in terms of security. As far as I know there are no known viruses on Mac, but from the security standpoint Windows when it comes to hardware is quite a mess. For example Stuxnet was able to infect Windows computers and cause a massive damage through a third party hw support software. I wonder if Android is in the same state of affairs, since it is “hardware agnostic” as you say.
Although sub par security is acceptable for consumer grade devices, but for mission critical applications that we will start to see with wider IOT deployment, it may be not enough. So I wonder if Google Chrome effort, although it seems at a conflict with Android at first is an attempt to move Android to closed source and control the platform.
Something like Stuxnet would happen on any platform because it was almost certainly created by a government and specifically targeted. Open/Closed source had nothing to do with it.
Security is a process. No software created by humans is ever going to be perfectly secure. All the big vendors (Apple, Google, and Microsoft) spend huge amounts of resources locking down their platforms. Again, open vs. closed source is mostly irrelevant. Software has bugs and many times those bugs manifest as security issues.
Even if the OS for IoT was 100% open source, had 1 million independent security researchers testing it for vulnerabilities, and was perfectly secure, IoT would still have security issues because the applications sitting on top of the IoT OS couldn’t possibly have the same level of scrutiny. Security bugs are going to happen. The important thing is that vendors take them seriously and have a timely way of fixing them.
Yes and No.
No, you do not want a software developer for the airplane engine SW to announce on Internet: “Oh, guys, by the way, I left some things unchecked in ChangeElevation method. Would any of you be so kind to check it?”
Yes, bugs are going to happen but I would assume you do not normally want to expose your source code to the outsiders if you know there are some critical bugs. This is a difference between white box and black box.
Yes, app security is an issue. This is why you have to design all security related services outside of apps, and give developers only tools that they basically cannot create security vulnerabilities.
For example, a sandboxing that’s proven to not let any virus in the app damage other apps or the OS. or programming languages and special cpu’s that prevents most(if not all) viruses , even if your software has bugs.
That’s a good theory but the reality tends to be a bit messier. People who are good at finding security holes tend to be able to work around things like sandboxes. Witness the current XARA attacks on the OS X and iOS sandbox. Like I said, security is a process. As attacks reveal vulnerabilities, vendors need to push fixes. The process is never ending.
Sure , but that’s a problem with the OS. In your comment you talked about “a perfectly secure” OS.
Personally , after reading research on the best security possible, i think a perfectly secure OS(or at the very least, a very secure one) might be achievable.
But as consumers ,all we get is crap. Partly because it’s cheaper , and maybe because there’s no real interest in providing bulletproof security for users.
“As far as I know there are no known viruses on Mac”. Erm. http://www.kaspersky.com/internet-security-center/threats/mac . There was even a 700,000 Mac botnet at one time…
FOSS and proprietary software are not intrisically different in terms of security architecture and features. The BIG difference is that Open Source software can be audited, proprietary software can’t. Most security experts argue that Open Source is thus safer, whether from bugs, hacks, or intentional developer backdoors (such as, ,say, iOS’s http://www.forbes.com/sites/gordonkelly/2014/07/22/every-iphone-has-a-security-backdoor/ , which was a big surprise to eveyron. Read the “counter argument” towards the end). http://www.dwheeler.com/secure-class/Secure-Programs-HOWTO/open-source-security.html is a good primer for that point of view.
And your example is not a virus. It was a Trojan.
Fake Flash installers from untrustworthy sources are not viruses. So there are no known viruses on Macs.
http://www.thesafemac.com/there-are-no-mac-viruses/
there are proof of concept viruses, ie viruses can be made for the Mac. Hackers just find it more rewarding to cous on Wintel PCs and their luch larger installed base. It’s not a technical reason, it’s a.. “marketing” one ^^
Total B.S.
It is difficult for me to equate Android with Windows/MS-DOS. The only real similarity is number of vendors relying on Android and Google for their mobile OS. The difference is that Windows and Intel were a profit machine for years. There is not an equivalent for that on Android. Google does not make much revenue from Android directly as Microsoft did during the heyday of Wintel.
Without the sustaining profits that Windows generates, what is the long term outcome of Android dominance? We already see the race to the bottom from Android hardware vendors. I don’t know what that means for Android but it is a very distinct difference from what Microsoft had when the PC market started a similar race to the bottom.
The other major difference is that Android as a platform is not particularly dominant. It shares developer attention with iOS. That was never the case for Windows vs. Mac where developing for the Mac OS was and still is a secondary consideration for most companies. But a significant portion (majority still?) of the developer community develops for iOS first because the ability to make money on iOS is still superior to Android for many purposes. This does not seem to be changing any time soon. What does this mean for the idea that Android is the dominant platform for hardware vendors but not software vendors?
I wonder what useful predictions we can make with Android is the new Windows given these facts.
The race to the bottom is not that clear, Samsung for example are steadily raising the price of their flagships, and specs on those flagships are raising even faster than prices. The market is moving more to the middle though.
The dev revenue situation is evolving extremely fast. From 7% of iOS apps revenue in 2011 (??? I find it hard to believe, but here it is http://www.businessinsider.com/apple-app-store-revenue-share-2011-11?IR=T ), to more than Apple’s appstore in 2014 (http://uk.businessinsider.com/android-apple-revenue-digi-capital-china-ios-google-app-store-2015-4?r=US ). Anecdotically, my search also pulled up that guy’s numbers: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2929612 from 1,400 days ago which is a lot ^^
What I’m actually wondering is if Android apps are becoming a sort of .mp3 of apps: a basic format that can run anywhere. Pretty much any OS can run then (even MacOS in a VM, though not iOS, also Windows soon, RIM, Linux in a VM…) and there are compatibility libraries for desktop OSes if you don’t want a VM… I know I’m running it on my desktop, because some apps are simply better than Windows’.
Hmm, if Apple allowed an Android VM into the App Store, would that be a good thing or bad? In the near term they wouldn’t want to do that because it would undermine their App Store business but if Android did start eclipsing iOS for development, would it benefit Apple to allow Android apps in their store?
Also called WinPhone’s Dilemma ^^
Why, on Earth, would you need an Android VM on iPad? How, on Earth, would it undermine Apple’s App Store business? When, in the cloudy, distant future, are we hypothesizing that Android development will eclipse iOS?
Shouldn’t we be more concerned about Black Holes? Or the ongoing battles of Mothra and Godzilla?
It was in context of iOS losing significant developer mind-share to Android. While I agree that iOS losing out to Android isn’t particularly likely, it certainly isn’t impossible either. If that did occur, would Apple be better off allowing Android VM apps in the App Store or would standing firm on only iOS native be more beneficial?
I don’t know the answer and as you say, we aren’t likely to find out. I just thought it was an interesting question.
The consumer market is so large that it is normal for many companies to do well, selling to various segments. In absolute numbers Apple’s base is so large it can’t be ignored. At this point both Apple and Android have already won. There’s little danger of developers not paying attention to iOS/Apple. And there’s little danger of Android not getting enough developer attention either. As development environments become more abstracted the danger on both sides decreases even more. It will become easier and easier to develop for multiple platforms. At least that’s my guess.
I’ll address the question head-on.
Running a virtual machine uses a great deal of RAM and processor cycles. There would have to be a compelling reason to do it. I cannot think any reason why someone would tank their iPhone/iPad’s performance to run some arcane app. It’s not “impossible.” But it would be stupid. If there WERE something exclusive to Android so compelling, it would make more sense to buy an Android phone.
“The race to the bottom is not that clear, Samsung for example are steadily raising the price of their flagships, and specs on those flagships are raising even faster than prices.”
It’s interesting when you say things like this; because it seems like somewhat a denial of reality.
Let’s be clear: “a race to the bottom” is not something that a company engages in out of choice. It’s not an event in the World Mobile Olympics. It’s a statement of a reality, and companies need to deal with it.
What you have shown is that Samsung is trying to put the brakes on. They are trying to stop a headlong slide into an abyss. That’s what raising prices and throwing features onto devices is.
It’s not clear that there is a race to the bottom?
When you talk about Samsung raising prices on some devices, how about you also look at their ASP. Is that also going up? No.
Are Samsung’s profits going up? No. Are the profits of any Android OEM going up? No.
Is Android really helping Samsung and other Android OEMs differentiate themselves on anything other than price? No.
Are anyone’s mobile device profits going up? Just Apple’s. Are anyone’s ASP going up? Just Apple’s. Whose price points are pretty rock solid over multiple years, while delivering additional value to 100’s of millions of new customers year after year? Apple’s.
These questions (among others), and their answers are pretty clear indicators that Android OEMs are engaged in a race to the bottom. Just as Windows OEMs are.
Your post is so crazy and false it’s actually funny.
Adding features and raising prices is “sliding into an abyss” ?
No Android OEMs are seeing raising profits ?
I’d be curious if you have any sources ? I’m not even sure about the ASP.
Big answer: Android is helping OEMs not die, ask Nokia, RIM, … Second big answer: Android isn’t preventing big OEMs from differentiating, they’re free to do whatever they want in hardware, software, or cloud. They just suck at it, especially on the cloud & software side; on the hardware side, there’s plenty innovation/differentiation even Apple seems to like: touch ID, pen, larger formats, smaller formats… even on the software side, split-screen and PiP multitasking were Samsung innovations on tablets. At least, having the Android baseline frees them to focus on really innovative stuff, whenever they do get a good idea.
Most mobile innovation happening on Android is the best sign that the race to the bottom isn’t terminal yet. most of Apple’s “new features” are heavily Android-inspired.
It certainly is a life-line to some. Which is why I called it table-stakes. You need something at least comparable to Android, and Rimm and Nokia didn’t. But it’s only helping in the short-term. All the optimism hasn’t quite worked out for it as it was supposed to over the last 5 or 6 years.
And I didn’t say an OEM using Android couldn’t differentiate; I said they would have to differentiate in spite of Android. You use Blackberry and Nokia as examples. How about all the big name OEMs that collectively are losing money as new (cheaper) alternatives from new Chinese companies come available?
Likewise, what about big Windows OEMs who have greatly reduced their presence in hardware, or gotten out of PC hardware altogether, in order to do services or something else instead?
It’s very difficult to add value to an open, generic OS designed to run on just about anything — as just about any example, including your own, will show you. And yes, the OEMs collectively pretty much suck at it because they never had to do software. Sony is a great example of this — once on top with great hardware, but largely gone now.
As the quote goes: “if you care about software, do your own hardware.” The opposite is true, too.
In the commercial sense, I don’t think Android is the new Windows. Windows decimated the competition including Apple, Android isn’t decimating Apple.
In the conceptual sense, the open-source aspect and permissive gapps licensing does free OEMs to do whatever (as long as they don’t break compatibility and include Google’s stuff). Windows was technically more flexible than current Mobile OSes, but the actual OS experience was much more uniform in the end, I’d argue even the hardware experience was more uniform (the feature set at each price points, even the HW design)
In the business sense it is Windows, because it provides the baseline features, apps & services, and network effects that most users want… and there’s nothing else they want on top of that.
The quote about hardware:software is weird, I’m not quite sure what to do with it. First it is dated, the action is in services (cloud) now mostly. Second it seems OEM-centric, or old-paradigm-app centric: Facebook, Twitter, Uber… are mostly software (less so Uber), they didn’t need hardware to blossom. They did need ubiquity, from which being device-dependent would have cut them off. So yes, arcade console Raiden is more fun than its Android port (that’s what I played hooky for, way back when… who needs Latin ?). Not sure arcade-console Facebook would be it though.
Samsung today announced a t/o decline of 8%. This is the 7th sequential quarter of decline in the smartphone division. How’s life in your “alt-reality”?
Indeed DesPDizzy, Canaccord Genuity reports that Apple in 2014 had a colossal 93% profits share of the Entire mobile phone industry with Samsung plunging down to a pitiful 9% down from over 40% just a year earlier. Those two figures are greater than 100% because all other Android manufacturers combined add up to a -2% share of the profits.
What was that about “Android helping OEMs not die” again obarthelemy?
http://www.businessinsider.com.au/apple-is-taking-93-of-the-profits-in-the-smartphone-industry-now-2015-2
One huge assumption that is being overlooked is that in consumer electronics, the Windows model (separation of hardware and software) is very much the exception. A lot of consumer hardware now comes with some form of computing and hence software, be it microwave ovens, televisions, set-top boxes, VCRs or automobiles. However, the vast majority use proprietary platforms. This is an observation that Steve Jobs made, I recall, at All Things D, and I think Horace Dediu has also reiterated this.
If the separation of hardware and software as in the Wintel platform is the exception, and the norm is hardware and software integration on a proprietary operating system, then this whole discussion breaks down. That is, Android may be the new Windows, but that is irrelevant because the market does not want a new Windows anyway.
Hence in order to make a sensible argument, we need to first think whether the modular approach makes sense on IoT and whether hardware manufacturers will adopt it. Although the modular approach has seen success on smartphones and shows some similarity to the Windows platform, in the wearables market, we are still seeing the integrated and proprietary platforms (Apple Watch, Fitbit, and even Samsung Tizen) being much more successful.
What I personally expect is that IoT hardware manufacturers may adopt Android, but only as an operating system and maybe as a communication standard, but definitely not as an ecosystem. They will use Android as a Linux replacement on the merits of the abundance of hardware drivers and maybe communication interfaces (which will inevitably include HealthKit interfaces in the near future), but otherwise, I expect hardware manufacturers to keep their platforms closed. This will hardly be like the Windows model that we see on PCs.
Yes, the future is integrated.
It’s very unusual even now to be modular in the same way as Windows was. Of course components may be modular, but that is rarely exposed to the end user. For example, the Xbox may use IBM processors, or Japanese imode feature phones may use Symbian OS, but the end users don’t have to know.
Steve Jobs believed that Windows style modularity was an anomaly, and I agree. It’s interesting to note that the two anomalies, Windows and Android, were both direct responses to products from Apple which were years ahead of the competition when launched. This seems to be what creates these anomalies.
Interesting idea, although I think Android was more of a response, at least at first, to Microsoft. But you’re right, Android changed direction dramatically once the original iPhone launched.
I think there was a certain time period where modular or open systems could thrive in tech, and that was when tech was not truly a consumer product. Windows was never consumer-facing, the basis of competition was not consumer-driven. Consumer markets favor more closed and more integrated systems. Of course nothing is 100 percent closed or 100 percent open, but the trend is clear. The more closed and integrated (typically, I’m sure there must be exceptions, but I can’t think of any at this moment) the better the user experience. Since in consumer markets the end user is also the buyer, products that deliver a better experience to the user tend to do better.
In practical terms OEMs that create Android devices are learning this lesson, Android is becoming more integrated and more closed. You may be right about how Android gets used for the Internet of Things. OEMs may build their own systems using Android, but those systems will effectively be closed and integrated.
Of course this doesn’t mean standards can’t happen. Apple products, while closed, work perfectly well with the real world because of standards.
You are speaking of Windows/Android being modular and Apple products being integrated/closed overall… but an interesting discussion is the one raised last year, I think, by Horace Dediu or Ben Thompson or someone (can’t remember where): different parts of the stack can be open/closed or modular/integrated. In fact, alternating layers within one business model seems to work well.
Apple seems to have excelled at this all the way up the stack, from manufacturing to sales and support. In fact, Apple seems to be able to switch from one to the other approach (eg, outsourcing GPUs or creating its own) at any given point as it adds new pieces or products to the puzzle. But overall it retains end-to-end control of user experience.
It seems MS and Google don’t properly understand this and they are actually too integrated at some points in their stacks or business models. And their ability to switch back and forth or adjust is poor, as evidenced by their forays into hardware.
Good point about alignment. In a consumer market your business needs to be aligned with the customer. Alignment with the customer, who is the end user AND the buyer, seems to cause more integration naturally, as a consequence of the alignment.
Xboxes are a once-every-six years purchase, that
– are used independently from other devices around the house,
– have no remote features and are fully self-contained,
– have no real-life security impact,
– require no investement in infrastructure (no wiring, installation, central command center) nor skills to operate (the games do, not the console itself).
– are in a market of 3 incompatible competitors, and 6 devices total (current+previous-gen console for each).
Quite the opposite of an IoT scenario ?
Even so, MS chose to equip them with a Windows variant, because it cut down on dev costs for them as OEMs, for games makers, and for tools makers.
Windows’ “anomaly” was a direct continuation of MS-DOS’s preexisting business model. The products might be a reaction to Apple’s, the business model isn’t.
That’s exactly the issue. Is it, or isn’t it?
What is IoT and what do people expect of it? Will IoT require new skills to operate? What will be the security issues and will people buy IoT before security is a non-issue?
This changes the whole discussion.
If IoT is only convenience, then customers won’t put up with the hassle of learning how to use it and setting it up. They wouldn’t be willing to sacrifice security. In this scenario, IoT will have to be even easier to use and longer lasting than Xbox. This demands an integrated approach.
On the other hand, if there are concrete benefits to IoT, like there was with VCRs in the 1980s for example, then customers will take the time to learn how to wire it up and how to program it. It can be closer to PCs. A Wintel-like approach will be tolerated.
I think it is intrinsically both.
Some devices will be lifesavers, others will just be gimmicks. Maybe the important stuff will take off first, but maybe not (early adopters can lean “gimmicky” a lot !). Probably early products or lines of products will require bespoke apps, but there’ll be a backlash against having 10+ of those ? An isolated IoT gizmo is not really IoT, more remote-controlled over the ‘net.
So there’s probably need of a unifying architecture able to accommodate both types of devices (it’s more of a continuum, really, and user-dependent: I don’t care I have to press a button to get coffee 2 mins later, some people would die if their cuppa wasn’t ready when they wander into the kitchen). There was wild excitement about the semantic web a while back. I think semantic something will be needed for IoT, so gizmos can expose their capabilities and a controller can know how to present+handle them.
Edit: I think a key point is that value rises exponentially when devices can interact among themselves, and/or actions can be linked+programmed ?
“may adopt Android, but only as an operating system and maybe as a communication standard”
That may be enough…
As in any ecosystem, applications must run. In the case of IoT, they must talk to each other. If they don’t, innovation will suffer because then each vendor must do it all, and the user gets locked in. Gee I bought this device, but their camera software is not quite as good as xyz…
Are you say it may be enough for Google?
The way I see it, if you’re only using Android for the device drivers and communication standards implementations, there is a good chance that AOSP will be sufficient. If this is the case, I’m not sure how it will benefit Google.
Also regarding apps, it’s unclear if you need them on IoT devices. Do you need an app to install on your smoke detector?
No, not Google. Google is not my concern. By apps, I mean software, including embedded software in this case.
Without standards we will have an incompatible mess.
Using Android on IoT will never happen, Android is top-heavy, with a lot of UI, multiasking, interoperability features that are not pertinent for devices but create huge HW requirements.
Google has launched another platform for IoT, dubbing it “Android-based” which sounds mostly like PR, though the programming paradigm is probably similar. http://www.engadget.com/2015/05/28/project-brillo-internet-of-things/
Plus there are really 2 things that shouldn’t be confused: the features and API of the IoT network, and the underlying ecosystem+apps used to implement those features. Hopefully both will be independent so we don’t get locked in.
Thanks for the link. That’s basically what I expected.
What I don’t understand yet is how important this Brillo/Weave component will be in terms of branding and ecosystem lock-in. Without these two, Brillo/Weave will not become as strong as Wintel but merely the majority platform (much like Linux is the majority platform for web servers, but Linus Torvalds does not have extraordinary market steering powers).
My understanding is that under the pretense of supplying free infrastructure, cloud services, and standards/APIs, various suppliers (Apple, Google, Qualcom, Huawei, Samsung…) are jockeying for position in supplying the hardware and software and cloud IoT devices will run on, and the dev toolchain.
Once things crystallize around a handful of standards (hopefully not more than 2 or 3), the winners will probably start to try and extract rent.
I’d expect the ecosystem branding the become as important for IoT as for Mobile and Desktop: very. You don’t want to end up with a device that’s incompatible with all your other stuff, and that’s different from everyone around you.
If I understand correctly, there are two ways IoT devices can communicate with each other. One is peer-to-peer where each IoT device directly talks to other IoT devices. This requires both devices to speak a common language. The other scheme is where your smartphone serves as the hub. Each IoT device talks to the hub using its own language and app (on the smartphone). Devices talk to each other only on the hub (smartphone) using frameworks like HomeKit. With the hub-based scheme, you don’t need standards for the communication between the hub and the IoT device.
If peer-to-peer becomes dominant, then all IoT devices have to conform to a standard. However if the hub-model wins out, then IoT devices will be given much more freedom in how they work. They won’t have to conform to a standard communication protocol. They don’t need to directly connect to the cloud (their apps residing on the hub can provide that). With a hub approach, the IoT devices themselves can be much dumber because the intelligence will be in the smartphone app.
If peer-to-peer communications becomes important for IoT, then it makes sense to consolidate around a single standard. This favours the Wintel model. On the other hand, if the hub-scheme is preferred, then standards are much less important. In this case, standardising on the OS is less important. The hardware itself, or the app residing on the smartphone will remain the key purchase drivers.
I think the technical hub is separate from the UI hub: there’ll probably be a box somewhere checking the devices status, setting parameters, distributing tasks, applying firmware updates etc… Humans will access that box via an app (whether mobile, web or legacy is immaterial; if routers are anything to go by… all 3… each with their specific idiosyncrasies and bugs… damn you Netgear ! :-p) . I don’t think a smartphone can be the technical hub, because… things would stop when you board a plane ?
IoT has in its very name the notion of internetwork, ie everything on it can talk to everything else on it. I don’t think it’s about simply using the internet as the transport layer for 1-to-1 remote control. It’s one-to-many (a single controller handling many devices), many to one (a single device controlled by many controllers, say yours and your wife’s phones, plus a programmed server that holds scripts with various triggers), and in the end many-to-many (combination of the previous 2).
Whether it ends up peer-to-peer is I think up in the air: reporting one’s status and executing predetermined commands is a lot easier than requesting and handling inputs from something else. I doubt a water sprinkler with a $0.5 anemic chip on a miserly power budget can handle turning itself off if there’s kid noises in the garden OR the gate opens OR the front door opens OR the garage door opens etc… Maybe for a handful of specific cases, not for open-ended situations with devices added/removed regularly. On the other hand, a lot of devices can have power (in both meanings) to spare: anything mains-connected and not too space-constrained can host a 1990s supercomputer in a few cubic centimeters, if that. We might end up with a centralized system (but with several centers if that doesn’t create unmanageable conflicts), a single center… full peer-to-peer will probably never happen, some devices will be the equivalent of dumb terminals.
I do think the ecosystem is important regardless. The development, control, communication, security, updates, interoperability… problematics exist whatever the communication/control paradigm ?
about the water sprinkler: OR it’s raining, OR it’s forecast to rain before the night is over and there’s enough time left to switch on if it doesn’t, etc…
What you’re describing is so complex, I fail to follow you.
I’ve seen reports that the Apple TV might serve as a hub instead of your iPhone when you are away. Wouldn’t that be a better idea?
I’m failing to find a nice explainer about IoT and its different layers (in-device hardware, physical & logical network -often P2P for power reasons-, command and control structure…).
Unless they go for a fully P2P command and control structure (which would make things very resilient, but would be complicated), I do think a central always-on “dispatcher” makes a lot of sense. For convenience’s sake, it can be anything always-on, so yes, Apple TV, or router, cable box, or a dedicated box.
That also makes it easier to handle disparate infrastructures and interoperability: a more powerful box can handle different protocols on behalf of the barely-smart lesser IoT devices.
The complex interactions I was describing earlier are a second step though. For now the “sprinkler” scenario is just turn it on/off from my phone, maybe set its timer. No fancy presence /weather/… checks ^^
I think you are making it all a lot more complicated than it needs to be.
The “remote” aspect may be all we really need:
Phase 1) Philips and others make it possible for their lightbulbs or whatever to be controlled by an app, as they have. Android apps can do this, and iOS apps can do this. Done.
Phase 2) To mitigate against your nightmare scenario of having 20 IoT apps to open and manage, Homekit allows the apps to interact without compromising device security.
Phase 3) Someone creates an awesome iOS app with an awesome interface that you give authority over all your homekit apps or appliances (kind of like how I can integrate all my cloud service subscriptions into other services, so that I can use the one of my choice but still have access to my Dropbox, Evernote, Google Drive, etc. through that one service). Let’s call this a “hub app”.
We already use location-based notifications, so why not address all this complexity you are worried about the same way? In your chosen “hub app” set up a rule, or choose from common “recipes”: “tell the sprinkler to turn off when I walk out the door”. Enable.
Phase 4) Apple sells a gazillion devices and apps because everyone appreciates how they took the complexity right out of IoT and built a platform and tools that developers could use to do awesome stuff that we never thought possible.
Let’s not make this about Apple vs others, this is totally cross-platform.
The issue with your examples are simple:
– if I have several light-bulbs and devices I want switched on, I need some kind of meta-command to do that, I’m not pushing 5-10 switches even on my phone.
– if it’s not me going out the door but someone else, I still need the sprinkler to turn off. So the motion detector and the sprinkler need to communicate.
– it’s fairly certain already this is not going to be a one-horse race, so there needs to be interoperability. Nest et al. are not going away, and different OEMs will chose different ecosystems.
1) yes, it is cross-platform, because Philips allows both an Android app and an iOS app to talk to its device.
2) you do have a “meta-command”, because I am envisioning a situation in which homekit apps allow authority to be ceded by one app to another app (one app to rule them all) or one homekit interface.
It’s about Apple if homekit provides some special ingredient that allows a developer to create a great interface for all your appliances, including multiple lightbulbs from diff manufacturers.
Besides a great and intuitive interface, I envision some form of customizable “recipes”, a la the IFTTT app. These would set up all sorts of sophisticated interactions in a way that is “simple” to manage.
I think the separation of hardware and software came about for a number of reasons:
– software is hard (and expensive) to do right, Cloud even more so. If you look at that most computer-like appliances, the router, there are an unconscionable number of software issues even from well-established, high-end vendors. Translate that over to newly-minted app makers for up-to-now less techie devices… A pre-existing ecosytem does away with a lot of the work, and, hopefully, provides helpful tools.
– HW and SW are rather different skillsets. Even big buck car makers seem happy to hand user-facing apps to Apple/Google. Oven makers…
– network effects. Apps/features/user skills that aren’t limited to a single manufacturer products are a lot more valuable. People don’t want their smart bulb choice to dictate which phone they have to buy.
– interoperability. Unless all manufacturers start making all possible devices, at some point there needs to be a standard for our IoTs to talk to each other, to the centralized command, and to us. A baseline OS/ecosystem with baseline features ensures a minimum of interoperability.
I think today’s integrated software survives mainly because it’s so early in the process of software-izing things, so it’s still relatively simple, and the above issues haven’t struck full force yet.
Your arguments make sense and I agree that we might see IoT move to the Wintel/Android smartphone model. However, there are also arguments that favour the opposite and what we see right now seems to favour an integrated approach with some exceptions such as the car entertainment systems that you describe (previously from Alpine, Panasonic, Pioneer, etc. in Japan, now possibly coming from Apple/Google).
You mention things like HW and SW being different skill sets, and I totally agree. However, looking back to the i-mode days in Japan, it was a bit more complex. DoCoMo, the carrier, developed the OS for the i-mode phones, but the hardware was build by various electronics makers. The OSs were based on either Linux or Symbian OS, with DoCoMo providing middleware which interfaced with the Applications. Device drivers came from the electronics makers. Application software that ran on top of the OS would often come from 3rd parties. From the customer perspective, the phones were almost exclusively branded as DoCoMo products with manufacturers often getting no mention at all. This was great for customers because DoCoMo was fully responsible for supporting the device, unlike the situation with Windows where depending on your issue, you might have to consult the HW manufacturer, Microsoft, or the application vendor.
https://www.nttdocomo.co.jp/binary/pdf/corporate/technology/rd/technical_journal/bn/vol13_1/vol13_1_055jp.pdf
What I’m saying here is that the HW manufacturer doesn’t need to provide the SW, even in an integrated model. The important thing is that one company tends to takes responsibility for the whole widget in consumer markets. In the case of cars, automobile makers will be responsible from the engine to the suspension to even the entertainment system, if you buy the whole widget from the car company.
Looking back at the complex DoCoMo model, the question is what role will Google play inside the whole product? Google rarely plays the role of the integrator, and will likely only provide software and services. Then how big of a role will Google’s software be? More importantly, what 3rd parties will supply the applications that sit upon the OS? If integration is important in consumer markets, then the customer facing company will be able to make the choices, and might relegate the role of Google to the basic OS (the Linux and Symbian behind i-mode).
Summing up, to understand whether the Wintel model will apply to IoT, we need to discuss the points that you brought up. I consider it to be a precursor to arguing over whether Android will become the Windows of IoT. Additionally, we have to understand how modularity works behind the scenes in the construction of products that seem integrated to end users. The peculiarity of the Wintel model is that the components defined the product whereas normally, the components are hidden from the end user. Will hardware vendors be able to hide the OS in IoT? More fundamentally, what is the role of an OS in (mostly) single purpose IoT devices?
It’s quite true that we always see OEMs making commoditized hardware to run high-value-added apps and services, but never see the contrary.
It does exist, quite a few companies make a living from real-time OSes and licensing IP/apps + consulting (QNX before being taken over by RIM for example). But by definition, software that gets subsumed into a product becomes invisible.
the IoT game will probably be about visibility and interoperability: nobody’s ready to have 20 apps for 20 device types (early on, for a handful of devices, maybe, but not if IoT takes off I think), and those devices will sometimes/often need to coordinate, or at least coordination will add value. The power balance might be closer to parity than the OEM/MS and OEM/Google ones though, plus there could be an independent standards body instead of a private corp driving things. What standard bodies failed to do for documents formats, they might achieve for IoT APIs, as they did for ECMA script, POSIX, …
The first mistake many of you commit when talking about the internet of things is to focus on the consumer or the smart homes sides, when in fact the real use and value of the Internet thing will come from the enterprise, government and city therefore being integrated into a single type of device a la Apple Homekit is a non-starter.
What’s the basis for that supposition? I pay attention to things and enterprise and governments are not a major topic. Retailers are embracing IoT for things like beacons but the scope seems to me to be very limited.
Do you have references that say governments and enterprises are getting into IoT in a big way? I’d be very interested.
I suspect IoT for enterprise and government is a very different market with very different jobs-to-be-done. I think it makes sense to keep these discussions separate.
Tim, I’m a bit disappointed you haven’t gone deeper with your comparison and analysis.
Android may be the new Windows when it comes to raw unit market share and malware (97% share in 2014 according to Pulse Secure), but Apple’s iOS is the new Windows when it comes to the metrics that actually matter.
In all of the *important* metrics that the WinTel duopoly and ecosystem used to dominate, it is Apple’s platform and ecosystem that dominates Android:
– Software. Developers target iOS first for software development while Android takes second place. Because Google doesn’t curate apps on the Play Store, 30% of Android apps are spamware.
– Developer revenue. Apple generated 70% more revenue for third party developers than Android in 2014, up from 60% the previous year according to the WSJ and AppAnnie.
– Peripherals and accessories. Because of Apple’s huge sales and limited number of form factors, there are far more peripherals and accessories available for iOS devices than for any model of Android device.
– Business Market share. iOS has 64% share of mobile business up from 54% YoY according to Citrix and 72% share according to Good Technology in 2015.
– Education Market Share. Apple’s iPad dominates the Education tablet market with 90% market share.
– Mobile Phone Industry profit share. Apple now captures a gargantuan 93% share of the profits of the entire Mobile industry in 2014 while Samsung has plummeted to 9% and other Android manufacturers continue to haemorrhage cash in the negative according to Canaccord Genuity.
– e-commerce revenue. IBM and Adobe both report that iOS users again generated 500% greater e-commerce revenue than Android users for providers in 2014.
– Advertising ROI. iOS users generate an eye-watering 1,790% greater advertising ROI than Android users – the latter of whom actually cost more money than they generate according to Nanigans.
I really like reading through a post that can make men and women think. Also thank you for allowing me to comment!
click here
click here
https://withoutprescription.guru/# non prescription erection pills
clomid without prescription: buy cheap clomid without dr prescription – where can i buy generic clomid pills
https://withoutprescription.guru/# buy prescription drugs online legally
india pharmacy mail order: п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india – pharmacy website india
viagra without a doctor prescription: buy prescription drugs online without – viagra without a prescription
http://canadapharm.top/# canadian online pharmacy
cialis without doctor prescription: best ed pills non prescription – legal to buy prescription drugs without prescription
http://tadalafil.trade/# tadalafil – generic
pharmacy online tadalafil tadalafil 20 where to buy tadalafil 20mg
Cheap Levitra online: Vardenafil price – Levitra generic best price
http://tadalafil.trade/# tadalafil online price
cost of sildenafil in india generic sildenafil in usa how to get sildenafil online
Kamagra 100mg price: super kamagra – Kamagra 100mg
https://tadalafil.trade/# tadalafil price
sildenafil pills 50 mg: buy sildenafil 100mg – sildenafil 25 mg buy
https://kamagra.team/# super kamagra
ed drugs list ed pills comparison ed treatment pills
http://sildenafil.win/# 200 mg sildenafil
best price generic sildenafil 20 mg: sildenafil buy cheap – sildenafil 100 mg generic price
http://sildenafil.win/# sildenafil canada over the counter
https://sildenafil.win/# buy sildenafil in canada
tadalafil 5mg tablets in india discount tadalafil 20mg tadalafil online price
zithromax 500 tablet zithromax antibiotic where can i purchase zithromax online
zithromax 500 mg lowest price drugstore online: buy zithromax – where can you buy zithromax
cost of lisinopril 2.5 mg lisinopril prinivil 5mg tablet
п»їcipro generic: buy ciprofloxacin over the counter – buy cipro
where can i get doxycycline uk: Buy doxycycline hyclate – doxycycline discount
doxycycline australia cost Buy doxycycline 100mg doxycycline minocycline
where to buy doxycycline 100mg: doxycycline buy online – cost doxycycline tablets
https://doxycycline.forum/# doxycycline cost india
doxycycline 163: Buy doxycycline for chlamydia – doxycycline online purchase
zithromax buy online buy zithromax canada zithromax without prescription
ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price: Buy ciprofloxacin 500 mg online – ciprofloxacin generic price
amoxicillin 500mg capsules antibiotic: buy amoxil – over the counter amoxicillin canada
doxycycline price canada doxycycline buy online buy doxycycline pills online
where to buy doxycycline online: Doxycycline 100mg buy online – doxycycline canada price
zithromax 600 mg tablets: zithromax antibiotic without prescription – zithromax 500
where can i buy cipro online ciprofloxacin without insurance ciprofloxacin
mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexican online pharmacy – mexican mail order pharmacies
canadian pharmacy review: canada pharmacy online – northwest pharmacy canada
https://buydrugsonline.top/# buy prescription drugs canada
prescription drugs canada: Mail order pharmacy – pharmacy drug store online no rx
online drugstore coupon buy medication online pharmacy price comparison
buy medicines online in india: online pharmacy india – online pharmacy india
cleck here to learn more
where can i get generic clomid: clomid best price – can i order cheap clomid tablets
http://clomid.club/# buy cheap clomid prices
buy paxlovid online: Paxlovid price without insurance – Paxlovid buy online
http://clomid.club/# can i order generic clomid tablets
cheap wellbutrin online: Buy Wellbutrin XL 300 mg online – how to get brand name wellbutrin cheap
paxlovid india http://paxlovid.club/# paxlovid cost without insurance
how to get brand name wellbutrin cheap: Buy Wellbutrin XL 300 mg online – generic wellbutrin us
https://clomid.club/# clomid tablet
http://wellbutrin.rest/# buy cheap wellbutrin
medication neurontin 300 mg: cheap gabapentin – neurontin 300 mg price in india
le migliori pillole per l’erezione: viagra prezzo farmacia – viagra 50 mg prezzo in farmacia
farmacia online migliore: farmacia online miglior prezzo – farmacia online
viagra generico prezzo più basso: alternativa al viagra senza ricetta in farmacia – viagra naturale in farmacia senza ricetta
https://kamagrait.club/# farmacie online sicure
migliori farmacie online 2023 kamagra gel prezzo farmacie on line spedizione gratuita
pillole per erezione immediata: viagra online siti sicuri – pillole per erezioni fortissime
farmacie online affidabili: avanafil generico – farmacia online miglior prezzo
farmacie online affidabili: farmacia online spedizione gratuita – farmacia online senza ricetta
pillole per erezione in farmacia senza ricetta: viagra prezzo – viagra 100 mg prezzo in farmacia
http://sildenafilit.bid/# viagra generico sandoz
п»їfarmacia online migliore kamagra gel comprare farmaci online all’estero
farmacia online miglior prezzo: Tadalafil prezzo – farmacia online migliore
farmacia online più conveniente: farmacia online – farmacia online miglior prezzo
farmacie online autorizzate elenco: farmacia online più conveniente – farmacia online
viagra acquisto in contrassegno in italia: viagra consegna in 24 ore pagamento alla consegna – viagra originale in 24 ore contrassegno
farmacia online più conveniente: dove acquistare cialis online sicuro – farmacia online
http://sildenafilit.bid/# viagra originale in 24 ore contrassegno
п»їfarmacia online migliore cialis prezzo farmacie on line spedizione gratuita
comprare farmaci online con ricetta: dove acquistare cialis online sicuro – farmacie online affidabili
farmaci senza ricetta elenco: avanafil – farmacia online miglior prezzo
farmaci senza ricetta elenco: kamagra gel prezzo – farmacie online affidabili
migliori farmacie online 2023: Tadalafil generico – farmacia online
viagra 50 mg prezzo in farmacia: alternativa al viagra senza ricetta in farmacia – viagra cosa serve
acquistare farmaci senza ricetta: Avanafil farmaco – farmacie online affidabili
farmacie online affidabili farmacia online migliore farmaci senza ricetta elenco
migliori farmacie online 2023: Avanafil farmaco – farmacie online affidabili
https://kamagrait.club/# farmacie online affidabili
viagra ordine telefonico: viagra senza ricetta – farmacia senza ricetta recensioni
comprare farmaci online all’estero: Farmacie a milano che vendono cialis senza ricetta – migliori farmacie online 2023
dove acquistare viagra in modo sicuro viagra generico pillole per erezione in farmacia senza ricetta
migliori farmacie online 2023: avanafil spedra – farmacia online miglior prezzo
farmacia online miglior prezzo: farmacia online – farmacie on line spedizione gratuita
https://farmaciait.pro/# farmacie online sicure
farmacia online: farmacia online miglior prezzo – farmacia online miglior prezzo
farmacie online affidabili: farmacia online migliore – acquistare farmaci senza ricetta
farmacia online senza ricetta: kamagra gel prezzo – farmacia online miglior prezzo
viagra online in 2 giorni: viagra prezzo farmacia – alternativa al viagra senza ricetta in farmacia
farmacie online affidabili: farmacia online miglior prezzo – farmacia online migliore
pillole per erezione immediata: viagra generico – viagra generico sandoz
http://sildenafilit.bid/# viagra online spedizione gratuita
farmacia online internacional cialis en Espana sin receta contrareembolso farmacia envГos internacionales
http://kamagraes.site/# farmacias baratas online envÃo gratis
http://farmacia.best/# farmacia online madrid
https://farmacia.best/# farmacias online baratas
https://tadalafilo.pro/# farmacia online envÃo gratis
http://kamagraes.site/# farmacia barata
http://farmacia.best/# farmacia online barata
farmacia online internacional cialis en Espana sin receta contrareembolso п»їfarmacia online
https://vardenafilo.icu/# farmacia envÃos internacionales
https://kamagraes.site/# farmacias online baratas
http://sildenafilo.store/# sildenafilo cinfa 100 mg precio farmacia
http://tadalafilo.pro/# farmacia online internacional
https://farmacia.best/# farmacias online seguras
https://kamagraes.site/# farmacia online
sildenafilo cinfa precio comprar viagra en espana comprar viagra online en andorra
https://kamagraes.site/# farmacia online barata
http://vardenafilo.icu/# farmacia online madrid
http://tadalafilo.pro/# farmacia online 24 horas
http://farmacia.best/# farmacia envÃos internacionales
farmacia online internacional: Comprar Levitra Sin Receta En Espana – п»їfarmacia online
http://tadalafilo.pro/# farmacias baratas online envÃo gratis
http://vardenafilo.icu/# farmacia online
http://vardenafilo.icu/# farmacia envÃos internacionales
https://farmacia.best/# farmacias online baratas
https://tadalafilo.pro/# farmacia online 24 horas
http://kamagraes.site/# farmacia barata
comprar sildenafilo cinfa 100 mg espaГ±a sildenafilo precio viagra online cerca de bilbao
https://vardenafilo.icu/# farmacia online madrid
https://kamagraes.site/# farmacia barata
https://kamagraes.site/# farmacia online internacional
http://tadalafilo.pro/# farmacia barata
farmacia online envГo gratis vardenafilo farmacia online madrid
https://farmacia.best/# farmacia online barata
https://tadalafilo.pro/# farmacia online madrid
http://vardenafilo.icu/# farmacia barata
farmacias online baratas: mejores farmacias online – farmacia envГos internacionales
http://vardenafilo.icu/# farmacias online seguras
https://tadalafilo.pro/# farmacia online barata
https://vardenafilo.icu/# farmacias baratas online envГo gratis
http://tadalafilo.pro/# farmacias baratas online envÃo gratis
http://sildenafilo.store/# sildenafilo sandoz 100 mg precio
http://kamagraes.site/# farmacia online barata
https://kamagraes.site/# farmacias baratas online envÃo gratis
https://sildenafilo.store/# viagra online cerca de zaragoza
http://vardenafilo.icu/# farmacia online
https://vardenafilo.icu/# farmacia online madrid
farmacias baratas online envГo gratis Levitra Bayer farmacia 24h
Learn more
http://tadalafilo.pro/# farmacia barata
Viagra sans ordonnance pharmacie France Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance Viagra gГ©nГ©rique pas cher livraison rapide
http://kamagrafr.icu/# Acheter médicaments sans ordonnance sur internet
http://cialissansordonnance.pro/# pharmacie en ligne
Viagra homme prix en pharmacie sans ordonnance: Viagra sans ordonnance 24h – Viagra homme sans ordonnance belgique
farmacias online seguras en espaГ±a: farmacia online envio gratis valencia – farmacias online baratas
https://levitrafr.life/# pharmacie ouverte 24/24
Pharmacie en ligne pas cher Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher pharmacie ouverte 24/24
https://pharmacieenligne.guru/# Pharmacie en ligne France
acheter mГ©dicaments Г l’Г©tranger: Levitra acheter – Pharmacie en ligne pas cher
https://kamagrafr.icu/# pharmacie en ligne
farmacia 24h: comprar kamagra en espana – farmacia online envГo gratis
http://pharmacieenligne.guru/# Pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance
http://pharmacieenligne.guru/# Pharmacies en ligne certifiées
https://pharmacieenligne.guru/# Pharmacies en ligne certifiées
acheter medicament a l etranger sans ordonnance Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h acheter mГ©dicaments Г l’Г©tranger
https://pharmacieenligne.guru/# Pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance
Pharmacie en ligne livraison 24h: pharmacie en ligne pas cher – п»їpharmacie en ligne
http://pharmacieenligne.guru/# Pharmacie en ligne livraison 24h
https://kamagrafr.icu/# Pharmacie en ligne fiable
https://kamagrafr.icu/# pharmacie ouverte
https://levitrafr.life/# acheter médicaments à l’étranger
pharmacie ouverte 24/24 pharmacie ouverte п»їpharmacie en ligne
http://kamagrafr.icu/# acheter médicaments à l’étranger
https://kamagrafr.icu/# acheter médicaments à l’étranger
acheter mГ©dicaments Г l’Г©tranger: Levitra sans ordonnance 24h – Pharmacie en ligne livraison gratuite
https://cialissansordonnance.pro/# acheter medicament a l etranger sans ordonnance
http://kamagrafr.icu/# Pharmacies en ligne certifiées
http://levitrafr.life/# Pharmacie en ligne France
http://pharmacieenligne.guru/# acheter medicament a l etranger sans ordonnance
https://cialiskaufen.pro/# online apotheke versandkostenfrei
http://kamagrakaufen.top/# п»їonline apotheke
Viagra Generika Schweiz rezeptfrei viagra generika Sildenafil Schweiz rezeptfrei kaufen
How to get a startup business loan with no money in 2024?
https://potenzmittel.men/# online apotheke deutschland
gГјnstige online apotheke kamagra oral jelly versandapotheke deutschland
https://cialiskaufen.pro/# online apotheke gГјnstig
versandapotheke: online apotheke rezeptfrei – online apotheke deutschland
https://cialiskaufen.pro/# internet apotheke
https://apotheke.company/# online apotheke deutschland
https://apotheke.company/# online apotheke gГјnstig
Viagra kaufen Apotheke Preis: viagra generika – Wo kann man Viagra kaufen rezeptfrei
https://mexicanpharmacy.cheap/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs buying from online mexican pharmacy mexican drugstore online
https://mexicanpharmacy.cheap/# pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs buying from online mexican pharmacy mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
buying prescription drugs in mexico online medicine in mexico pharmacies mexico drug stores pharmacies
buying prescription drugs in mexico mexico pharmacies prescription drugs mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
best online pharmacies in mexico best online pharmacies in mexico mexico pharmacy
https://mexicanpharmacy.cheap/# mexican rx online
mexican drugstore online mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs buying prescription drugs in mexico online
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa mexican pharmaceuticals online mexico drug stores pharmacies
reputable mexican pharmacies online buying prescription drugs in mexico mexico pharmacy
medicine in mexico pharmacies mexican drugstore online reputable mexican pharmacies online
http://mexicanpharmacy.cheap/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
https://mexicanpharmacy.cheap/# reputable mexican pharmacies online
mexican pharmaceuticals online п»їbest mexican online pharmacies buying prescription drugs in mexico online
buying prescription drugs in mexico mexico drug stores pharmacies mexican pharmaceuticals online
best mexican online pharmacies mexican drugstore online mexican pharmaceuticals online
mexico drug stores pharmacies mexico drug stores pharmacies mexican pharmacy
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa mexican mail order pharmacies mexican drugstore online
http://mexicanpharmacy.cheap/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican pharmaceuticals online pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa mexican mail order pharmacies
mexican pharmaceuticals online best mexican online pharmacies purple pharmacy mexico price list
buying prescription drugs in mexico online purple pharmacy mexico price list best online pharmacies in mexico
http://mexicanpharmacy.cheap/# medication from mexico pharmacy
medication from mexico pharmacy mexico pharmacies prescription drugs mexican mail order pharmacies
mexico pharmacy buying prescription drugs in mexico best online pharmacies in mexico
buy medicines online in india indianpharmacy com – п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india indiapharmacy.guru
http://indiapharmacy.pro/# india online pharmacy indiapharmacy.pro
pills erectile dysfunction ed drug prices – ed pills comparison edpills.tech
https://canadiandrugs.tech/# canadian neighbor pharmacy canadiandrugs.tech
legitimate canadian pharmacies is canadian pharmacy legit – canadian pharmacy 24 canadiandrugs.tech
ed meds erection pills viagra online ed pill edpills.tech
canadian pharmacy review northern pharmacy canada – canadian pharmacy online ship to usa canadiandrugs.tech
indian pharmacy online best india pharmacy – indian pharmacy paypal indiapharmacy.guru
http://indiapharmacy.guru/# top 10 online pharmacy in india indiapharmacy.guru
https://indiapharmacy.pro/# pharmacy website india indiapharmacy.pro
https://indiapharmacy.guru/# reputable indian pharmacies indiapharmacy.guru
top online pharmacy india india online pharmacy – indianpharmacy com indiapharmacy.guru
https://indiapharmacy.guru/# buy prescription drugs from india indiapharmacy.guru
best online pharmacy india buy medicines online in india – best online pharmacy india indiapharmacy.guru
https://indiapharmacy.guru/# Online medicine home delivery indiapharmacy.guru
Online medicine order india pharmacy – Online medicine home delivery indiapharmacy.guru
erectile dysfunction medicines ed drugs natural ed remedies edpills.tech
https://indiapharmacy.pro/# indian pharmacy online indiapharmacy.pro
pills for ed best male enhancement pills what are ed drugs edpills.tech
best online canadian pharmacy legit canadian pharmacy – pharmacy canadian superstore canadiandrugs.tech
http://indiapharmacy.pro/# indian pharmacies safe indiapharmacy.pro
top ed pills best male enhancement pills – ed remedies edpills.tech
http://amoxil.icu/# where to buy amoxicillin 500mg without prescription
cost of generic clomid without prescription can i order cheap clomid no prescription how can i get cheap clomid
https://clomid.site/# clomid brand name
http://prednisone.bid/# where can i get prednisone
can i buy amoxicillin over the counter: amoxicillin online pharmacy – antibiotic amoxicillin
amoxicillin 500mg no prescription: amoxicillin price without insurance – amoxicillin in india
http://prednisone.bid/# how to buy prednisone
http://ciprofloxacin.life/# ciprofloxacin
buy ciprofloxacin: antibiotics cipro – cipro
can i buy amoxicillin online amoxicillin cephalexin amoxicillin 500mg for sale uk
https://amoxil.icu/# purchase amoxicillin 500 mg
Paxlovid over the counter Paxlovid buy online п»їpaxlovid
where can i buy prednisone online without a prescription: prednisone 10mg buy online – how to buy prednisone online
how can i order prednisone: prednisone 20mg online without prescription – prednisone 20mg buy online
https://prednisone.bid/# 54 prednisone
paxlovid pill paxlovid generic paxlovid pharmacy
https://paxlovid.win/# paxlovid covid
amoxicillin 500 mg online: where to get amoxicillin over the counter – amoxicillin 500 coupon
http://clomid.site/# can you get generic clomid pills
order amoxicillin online uk: amoxicillin 500mg price – amoxicillin canada price
antibiotics cipro: ciprofloxacin order online – ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online
prescription for amoxicillin generic amoxil 500 mg cost of amoxicillin 30 capsules
https://amoxil.icu/# amoxicillin 500mg
prednisone 10mg cost: prednisone 0.5 mg – cost of prednisone tablets
generic clomid without a prescription can i order cheap clomid – how to get cheap clomid without insurance
generic clomid price: can you buy generic clomid tablets – get cheap clomid
http://amoxil.icu/# buy amoxil
https://ciprofloxacin.life/# ciprofloxacin generic price
https://cytotec.icu/# buy misoprostol over the counter
https://zithromaxbestprice.icu/# zithromax 250 mg australia
zithromax tablets for sale: zithromax purchase online – buy zithromax online fast shipping
buy misoprostol over the counter: buy cytotec over the counter – cytotec pills buy online
https://cytotec.icu/# buy cytotec over the counter
price of doxycycline: buy doxycycline online – doxycycline mono
http://nolvadex.fun/# tamoxifen for breast cancer prevention
Abortion pills online: cytotec pills buy online – buy cytotec online
https://cytotec.icu/# buy cytotec pills
http://zithromaxbestprice.icu/# zithromax 250mg
doxycycline 100mg capsules: online doxycycline – generic doxycycline
buy doxycycline monohydrate: doxycycline 50mg – doxycycline tetracycline
doxycycline 200 mg: buy doxycycline without prescription uk – doxycycline 50mg
zithromax drug where to get zithromax over the counter zithromax over the counter
https://cytotec.icu/# Cytotec 200mcg price
average cost of generic zithromax: zithromax 250mg – zithromax price south africa
http://cytotec.icu/# cytotec online
tamoxifen reviews: alternative to tamoxifen – tamoxifen depression
http://cytotec.icu/# buy cytotec over the counter
doxycycline vibramycin: doxycycline 100mg online – buy doxycycline online uk
https://doxycyclinebestprice.pro/# doxycycline order online
doxycycline 100mg capsules: doxycycline hyclate 100 mg cap – doxycycline vibramycin
where can you buy zithromax: zithromax 500mg price – how to get zithromax online
http://doxycyclinebestprice.pro/# generic doxycycline
https://mexicopharm.com/# mexican drugstore online mexicopharm.com
best canadian pharmacy to buy from: Canada pharmacy online – pet meds without vet prescription canada canadapharm.life
best online pharmacies in mexico: mexican pharmacy – buying from online mexican pharmacy mexicopharm.com
http://canadapharm.life/# canadian pharmacy checker canadapharm.life
real canadian pharmacy: Canada Drugs Direct – canadian compounding pharmacy canadapharm.life
https://canadapharm.life/# cheap canadian pharmacy canadapharm.life
buy prescription drugs from india indian pharmacy to usa india pharmacy indiapharm.llc
trustworthy canadian pharmacy: Cheapest drug prices Canada – buy canadian drugs canadapharm.life
canadian online pharmacy: Canadian online pharmacy – canadian drug canadapharm.life
http://canadapharm.life/# best online canadian pharmacy canadapharm.life
canadian online drugs: Canada Drugs Direct – canadian family pharmacy canadapharm.life
http://mexicopharm.com/# п»їbest mexican online pharmacies mexicopharm.com
https://mexicopharm.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexicopharm.com
top 10 pharmacies in india: indian pharmacy – india pharmacy mail order indiapharm.llc
canadapharmacyonline com: Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US – canadian neighbor pharmacy canadapharm.life
pharmacy canadian superstore: Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US – pharmacies in canada that ship to the us canadapharm.life
online canadian pharmacy review Canadian pharmacy best prices canadian pharmacy 365 canadapharm.life
http://indiapharm.llc/# buy medicines online in india indiapharm.llc
legitimate canadian pharmacy: Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US – onlinecanadianpharmacy 24 canadapharm.life
canadian pharmacy 24h com safe: Canadian online pharmacy – reputable canadian pharmacy canadapharm.life
http://mexicopharm.com/# mexico drug stores pharmacies mexicopharm.com
http://canadapharm.life/# best canadian online pharmacy canadapharm.life
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: Medicines Mexico – mexican drugstore online mexicopharm.com
top 10 online pharmacy in india: indian pharmacy to usa – india pharmacy indiapharm.llc
http://indiapharm.llc/# best india pharmacy indiapharm.llc
vipps approved canadian online pharmacy: Canada pharmacy online – canadian discount pharmacy canadapharm.life
https://tadalafildelivery.pro/# generic cialis tadalafil uk
buy tadalafil 20mg price in india: buy tadalafil 20 – canada tadalafil generic
http://levitradelivery.pro/# Levitra tablet price
https://levitradelivery.pro/# Buy Levitra 20mg online
tadalafil 20mg no prescription: tadalafil without a doctor prescription – generic tadalafil 10mg
http://kamagradelivery.pro/# Kamagra 100mg price
buy tadalafil 20mg price canada cheap tadalafil canada tadalafil – generic
Vardenafil buy online: Buy Levitra 20mg online – Buy Vardenafil 20mg
http://sildenafildelivery.pro/# where to buy sildenafil uk
tadalafil tablets 20 mg india: Tadalafil 20mg price in Canada – tadalafil generic price
https://sildenafildelivery.pro/# sildenafil prescription australia
http://kamagradelivery.pro/# Kamagra tablets
buy sildenafil india: Cheapest Sildenafil online – sildenafil 20 mg lowest price
http://edpillsdelivery.pro/# ed dysfunction treatment
pills for erection erection pills over the counter herbal ed treatment
the best ed pill: ed pills online – cheap erectile dysfunction pills online
sildenafil 100 mg best price: cheap sildenafil – sildenafil 25 mg online
tadalafil online united states: Buy tadalafil online – buy tadalafil online without a prescription
http://levitradelivery.pro/# Buy Levitra 20mg online
https://levitradelivery.pro/# Buy Vardenafil online
tadalafil united states: Tadalafil 20mg price in Canada – tadalafil 20 mg over the counter
https://sildenafildelivery.pro/# sildenafil brand name in canada
paxlovid covid: Paxlovid buy online – buy paxlovid online
paxlovid pharmacy buy paxlovid online paxlovid cost without insurance
http://paxlovid.guru/# paxlovid india
http://stromectol.guru/# ivermectin usa price
https://paxlovid.guru/# paxlovid cost without insurance
can you purchase amoxicillin online: buy amoxicillin 500mg online – over the counter amoxicillin canada
п»їpaxlovid paxlovid best price paxlovid generic
http://clomid.auction/# get generic clomid price
http://amoxil.guru/# where can i buy amoxicillin over the counter uk
buy clomid no prescription: how to get generic clomid pill – where to buy clomid online
http://clomid.auction/# generic clomid pills
http://amoxil.guru/# can i buy amoxicillin online
paxlovid for sale paxlovid price without insurance buy paxlovid online
https://amoxil.guru/# amoxacillian without a percription
can i get clomid price: clomid generic – clomid prices
http://clomid.auction/# cost of clomid pill
https://lisinopril.fun/# url lisinopril hctz prescription
where can i buy zithromax in canada: buy zithromax over the counter – zithromax 500
http://lisinopril.fun/# lisinopril 5 mg tablet price in india
https://azithromycin.store/# zithromax buy online
generic zithromax online paypal: zithromax best price – azithromycin zithromax
lasix Buy Lasix No Prescription furosemide 100mg
https://misoprostol.shop/# Abortion pills online
lasix generic: Buy Furosemide – lasix
https://azithromycin.store/# zithromax online
https://azithromycin.store/# zithromax 600 mg tablets
lisinopril 19 mg: cheapest lisinopril – cost of lisinopril
http://azithromycin.store/# zithromax for sale online
https://finasteride.men/# cheap propecia prices
buy cytotec in usa Buy Abortion Pills Online buy misoprostol over the counter
cheap propecia tablets: Finasteride buy online – order propecia without dr prescription
buy generic propecia without prescription: Finasteride buy online – cost of propecia price
https://misoprostol.shop/# cytotec pills buy online
https://azithromycin.store/# zithromax z-pak price without insurance
lasix generic name: Buy Lasix – buy lasix online
lisinopril price without insurance over the counter lisinopril lisinopril 20 mg purchase
http://azithromycin.store/# zithromax azithromycin
where can i get zithromax: buy zithromax z-pak online – zithromax 250 price
https://misoprostol.shop/# Misoprostol 200 mg buy online
cost of cheap propecia now: Cheapest finasteride online – cheap propecia without insurance
http://lisinopril.fun/# lisinopril brand name australia
zestril discount: buy lisinopril canada – lisinopril brand
buying generic propecia without rx: Buy finasteride 1mg – order propecia without insurance
lasix 100mg Buy Furosemide lasix pills
http://finasteride.men/# get generic propecia without dr prescription
cytotec online: buy misoprostol – order cytotec online
http://lisinopril.fun/# buy 40 mg lisinopril
http://lisinopril.fun/# lisinopril 2.15 mg
cytotec abortion pill: buy cytotec online – buy cytotec over the counter
buy propecia for sale Buy Finasteride 5mg generic propecia without dr prescription
http://finasteride.men/# cost propecia for sale
buy cytotec pills: cheap cytotec – cytotec pills buy online
http://azithromycin.store/# zithromax 500 without prescription
http://misoprostol.shop/# cytotec pills online
lisinopril price comparison: cheapest lisinopril – lisinopril 12.5 mg price
farmacia online senza ricetta cialis generico consegna 48 ore farmacia online migliore
farmacie online affidabili: Tadalafil prezzo – top farmacia online
https://farmaciaitalia.store/# farmacie online affidabili
cerco viagra a buon prezzo: viagra senza ricetta – cialis farmacia senza ricetta
https://kamagraitalia.shop/# farmaci senza ricetta elenco
cialis farmacia senza ricetta: viagra senza ricetta – alternativa al viagra senza ricetta in farmacia
https://kamagraitalia.shop/# farmacia online senza ricetta
migliori farmacie online 2023: farmacia online miglior prezzo – farmacia online senza ricetta
farmacia online miglior prezzo farmacia online migliore comprare farmaci online all’estero
http://avanafilitalia.online/# farmacia online senza ricetta
https://tadalafilitalia.pro/# migliori farmacie online 2023
comprare farmaci online con ricetta: avanafil generico prezzo – acquisto farmaci con ricetta
farmacia online piГ№ conveniente: farmacia online – comprare farmaci online con ricetta
https://farmaciaitalia.store/# farmacia online migliore
farmacie on line spedizione gratuita kamagra oral jelly consegna 24 ore farmacia online senza ricetta
farmacia online piГ№ conveniente: farmacia online miglior prezzo – farmacie online autorizzate elenco
farmaci senza ricetta elenco: kamagra gel prezzo – farmacie online affidabili
https://sildenafilitalia.men/# viagra generico recensioni
https://farmaciaitalia.store/# farmacia online senza ricetta
viagra generico in farmacia costo: viagra online siti sicuri – viagra originale in 24 ore contrassegno
http://farmaciaitalia.store/# comprare farmaci online all’estero
migliori farmacie online 2023: comprare avanafil senza ricetta – acquistare farmaci senza ricetta
farmacia online miglior prezzo: kamagra – п»їfarmacia online migliore
https://mexicanpharm.store/# mexican pharmacy
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: mexico pharmacy – mexico drug stores pharmacies
safe reliable canadian pharmacy: best canadian online pharmacy – canada cloud pharmacy
canadian pharmacy mall canadian world pharmacy pharmacy com canada
https://mexicanpharm.store/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
www canadianonlinepharmacy: canadian drugs online – best online canadian pharmacy
indian pharmacies safe: п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india – reputable indian pharmacies
http://mexicanpharm.store/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
Online medicine home delivery: mail order pharmacy india – online pharmacy india
http://mexicanpharm.store/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
mexican pharmaceuticals online: best online pharmacies in mexico – buying prescription drugs in mexico
mexico drug stores pharmacies: best online pharmacies in mexico – п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
india pharmacy mail order: best india pharmacy – indian pharmacy
canadian pharmacy no rx needed: canadian medications – canadian online pharmacy
http://indiapharm.life/# online shopping pharmacy india
canadian pharmacy store: reputable canadian online pharmacy – canadian drugstore online
http://indiapharm.life/# cheapest online pharmacy india
online shopping pharmacy india: Online medicine order – india pharmacy mail order
indianpharmacy com: п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india – buy prescription drugs from india
cheap canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy prices my canadian pharmacy
http://indiapharm.life/# pharmacy website india
canadian pharmacy ltd: canadian pharmacy ratings – canadian pharmacy online store
https://mexicanpharm.store/# mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian pharmacy tampa: canadian pharmacy meds reviews – canadian pharmacy 24h com
http://indiapharm.life/# Online medicine order
mexico pharmacy: mexican rx online – purple pharmacy mexico price list
canadian pharmacy 24h com safe: best online canadian pharmacy – northwest canadian pharmacy
purple pharmacy mexico price list: best online pharmacies in mexico – medicine in mexico pharmacies
https://mexicanpharm.store/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
canadianpharmacymeds com: canada cloud pharmacy – canadadrugpharmacy com
http://canadapharm.shop/# canada rx pharmacy world
best online canadian pharmacy trustworthy canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy near me
onlinecanadianpharmacy: canadian pharmacy prices – 77 canadian pharmacy
https://indiapharm.life/# Online medicine home delivery
top 10 pharmacies in india: top online pharmacy india – world pharmacy india
medicine in mexico pharmacies: medication from mexico pharmacy – mexican pharmacy
https://mexicanpharm.store/# mexican drugstore online
Their cross-border services are unmatched https://zithromaxpharm.online/# buy zithromax without prescription online
https://cytotec.directory/# buy cytotec over the counter
http://clomidpharm.shop/# generic clomid pill
prednisone buy cheap: buy prednisone without rx – prednisone canada
A trusted name in international pharmacy circles http://prednisonepharm.store/# generic prednisone otc
https://zithromaxpharm.online/# zithromax capsules
cytotec buy online usa: buy cytotec in usa – Misoprostol 200 mg buy online
Their medication reminders are such a thoughtful touch https://zithromaxpharm.online/# zithromax price canada
https://nolvadex.pro/# tamoxifen reviews
can i order cheap clomid without rx: can i purchase clomid no prescription – where can i get generic clomid without insurance
https://cytotec.directory/# Abortion pills online
https://prednisonepharm.store/# where can i get prednisone over the counter
Speedy service with a smile http://cytotec.directory/# buy cytotec online fast delivery
tamoxifen chemo: tamoxifen side effects forum – nolvadex for sale
https://nolvadex.pro/# benefits of tamoxifen
Their vaccination services are quick and easy http://zithromaxpharm.online/# zithromax 250 price
nolvadex steroids: tamoxifen headache – tamoxifen skin changes
https://cytotec.directory/# cytotec abortion pill
They’re at the forefront of international pharmaceutical innovations https://zithromaxpharm.online/# where can i buy zithromax in canada
buy cytotec online: buy cytotec in usa – Misoprostol 200 mg buy online
https://cytotec.directory/# Abortion pills online
They offer the best prices on international brands http://clomidpharm.shop/# where buy clomid pills
https://cytotec.directory/# cytotec online
https://prednisonepharm.store/# prednisone 10 tablet
cost of cheap clomid pill: where to buy cheap clomid no prescription – how to buy cheap clomid without prescription
http://edwithoutdoctorprescription.store/# buy prescription drugs online
best non prescription ed pills: best non prescription ed pills – viagra without a doctor prescription
online prescription for ed meds buy prescription drugs online without п»їprescription drugs
https://edpills.bid/# how to cure ed
non prescription ed pills: buy ed pills – best drug for ed
https://edwithoutdoctorprescription.store/# viagra without a doctor prescription
canadian pharmacy for sildenafil https://edpills.bid/# treatment of ed
ed meds online without doctor prescription
viagra without doctor prescription amazon non prescription erection pills buy prescription drugs
canada drug stores: top rated online canadian pharmacies – pain meds online without doctor prescription
http://reputablepharmacies.online/# family discount pharmacy
buy prescription drugs without doctor: non prescription ed pills – viagra without doctor prescription
canadian online pharmacy for viagra certified online canadian pharmacies canada pharmacy online no script
http://reputablepharmacies.online/# mail order canadian drugs
best online mexican pharmacy most reliable canadian pharmacies pharmacy drug store
canadian drug pharmacy http://reputablepharmacies.online/# safe online pharmacy
canadian drug store cialis
canadian pharmaceuticals online: online drugstore reviews – canadian wholesale pharmacy
http://edpills.bid/# best ed pills non prescription
viagra without a doctor prescription walmart viagra without a doctor prescription walmart legal to buy prescription drugs from canada
cialis without doctor prescription: viagra without doctor prescription amazon – generic viagra without a doctor prescription
https://reputablepharmacies.online/# viagra no prescription canadian pharmacy
prescription drugs without doctor approval how to get prescription drugs without doctor 100mg viagra without a doctor prescription
https://edpills.bid/# best ed pill
buy prescription drugs without doctor: prescription drugs without doctor approval – prescription drugs without doctor approval
certified canadian pharmacy Canadian pharmacy online my canadian pharmacy canadianpharmacy.pro
https://mexicanpharmacy.win/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexicanpharmacy.win
online shopping pharmacy india: indian pharmacy – reputable indian pharmacies indianpharmacy.shop
mexican pharmaceuticals online mexican pharmacy online mexico drug stores pharmacies mexicanpharmacy.win
https://mexicanpharmacy.win/# purple pharmacy mexico price list mexicanpharmacy.win
best rated canadian pharmacy: Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US – cross border pharmacy canada canadianpharmacy.pro
canadian pharmacies online Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US vipps approved canadian online pharmacy canadianpharmacy.pro
http://indianpharmacy.shop/# best online pharmacy india indianpharmacy.shop
international pharmacies that ship to the usa
canada pharmacy online: Canadian pharmacy online – online canadian pharmacy reviews canadianpharmacy.pro
https://mexicanpharmacy.win/# buying from online mexican pharmacy mexicanpharmacy.win
purple pharmacy mexico price list online mexican pharmacy mexico pharmacy mexicanpharmacy.win
https://indianpharmacy.shop/# reputable indian pharmacies indianpharmacy.shop
indian pharmacies safe Order medicine from India to USA best online pharmacy india indianpharmacy.shop
http://indianpharmacy.shop/# buy medicines online in india indianpharmacy.shop
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: online mexican pharmacy – medication from mexico pharmacy
https://mexicanpharmacy.win/# mexico drug stores pharmacies mexicanpharmacy.win
india pharmacy
http://canadianpharmacy.pro/# canadian pharmacy in canada canadianpharmacy.pro
buy mexican drugs online
https://canadianpharmacy.pro/# online canadian pharmacy review canadianpharmacy.pro
http://mexicanpharmacy.win/# buying from online mexican pharmacy mexicanpharmacy.win
indianpharmacy com
Online medicine order international medicine delivery from india Online medicine order indianpharmacy.shop
http://indianpharmacy.shop/# reputable indian online pharmacy indianpharmacy.shop
https://mexicanpharmacy.win/# mexico drug stores pharmacies mexicanpharmacy.win
reputable indian online pharmacy
https://mexicanpharmacy.win/# best online pharmacies in mexico mexicanpharmacy.win
http://indianpharmacy.shop/# india pharmacy mail order indianpharmacy.shop
top 10 pharmacies in india
https://mexicanpharmacy.win/# pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa mexicanpharmacy.win
prescription drugs online without
best canadian online pharmacy Cheapest drug prices Canada canadian pharmacy store canadianpharmacy.pro
https://mexicanpharmacy.win/# mexican rx online mexicanpharmacy.win
http://indianpharmacy.shop/# reputable indian pharmacies indianpharmacy.shop
mail order pharmacy india
indian pharmacy online indian pharmacy best online pharmacy india indianpharmacy.shop
http://canadianpharmacy.pro/# canadian pharmacies comparison canadianpharmacy.pro
https://canadianpharmacy.pro/# canada drugs online reviews canadianpharmacy.pro
india pharmacy
canadian pharmacy in canada Canada Pharmacy canadianpharmacyworld com canadianpharmacy.pro
http://indianpharmacy.shop/# indian pharmacy online indianpharmacy.shop
https://canadianpharmacy.pro/# canadian medications canadianpharmacy.pro
indianpharmacy com
https://indianpharmacy.shop/# online shopping pharmacy india indianpharmacy.shop
Pharmacie en ligne livraison 24h: pharmacie en ligne pas cher – pharmacie ouverte
Acheter mГ©dicaments sans ordonnance sur internet kamagra pas cher Pharmacie en ligne pas cher
http://pharmadoc.pro/# Pharmacie en ligne livraison gratuite
Viagra homme sans ordonnance belgique: viagrasansordonnance.pro – Viagra pas cher livraison rapide france
acheter mГ©dicaments Г l’Г©tranger levitra generique prix en pharmacie pharmacie ouverte
http://levitrasansordonnance.pro/# Pharmacie en ligne livraison rapide
п»їpharmacie en ligne
http://viagrasansordonnance.pro/# Viagra sans ordonnance pharmacie France
Pharmacie en ligne fiable: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – pharmacie ouverte
acheter medicament a l etranger sans ordonnance PharmaDoc Pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es
http://pharmadoc.pro/# Pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance
Pharmacie en ligne livraison gratuite: pharmacie en ligne – Pharmacie en ligne livraison 24h
Pharmacie en ligne pas cher Pharmacies en ligne certifiees Pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance
http://acheterkamagra.pro/# Pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance
Pharmacie en ligne livraison 24h: kamagra livraison 24h – Pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es
Pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es: kamagra oral jelly – Acheter mГ©dicaments sans ordonnance sur internet
Pharmacie en ligne livraison rapide kamagra 100mg prix п»їpharmacie en ligne
Mainfluencer.com, an international talent management company
https://acheterkamagra.pro/# Acheter médicaments sans ordonnance sur internet
pharmacie ouverte: Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h – Pharmacie en ligne livraison rapide
Pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance cialis generique pharmacie ouverte
Pharmacie en ligne livraison gratuite: achat kamagra – п»їpharmacie en ligne
amoxicillin 500 mg online: can you buy amoxicillin uk – buy amoxicillin 500mg capsules uk
cost of clomid no prescription cost clomid pills how can i get cheap clomid without dr prescription
http://azithromycin.bid/# zithromax 500mg over the counter
buy generic zithromax online: zithromax for sale usa – zithromax online no prescription
prednisone 10mg buy online buying prednisone prednisone 2.5 mg daily
https://azithromycin.bid/# how much is zithromax 250 mg
where to buy cheap clomid no prescription: buying generic clomid without dr prescription – where to get clomid no prescription
can i order cheap clomid pill: how to get generic clomid without dr prescription – where to buy generic clomid prices
where can i buy amoxicillin online amoxicillin 500mg capsules buy amoxicillin online with paypal
https://prednisonetablets.shop/# buy prednisone without a prescription best price
amoxicillin 500 mg capsule: cost of amoxicillin 30 capsules – can you purchase amoxicillin online
http://ivermectin.store/# ivermectin cream 1
buy zithromax zithromax without prescription buy cheap generic zithromax
zithromax online: can you buy zithromax over the counter in canada – where can i get zithromax over the counter
can i order cheap clomid prices: can you get generic clomid pills – where buy generic clomid prices
https://azithromycin.bid/# zithromax 250 mg australia
zithromax online: zithromax 500 mg lowest price pharmacy online – where can i buy zithromax medicine
where can i get clomid tablets where to buy generic clomid without rx can you get generic clomid prices
http://prednisonetablets.shop/# prednisone online for sale
ivermectin cost canada: ivermectin 3 mg – stromectol pills
can you buy prednisone over the counter in mexico prednisone in canada prednisone canada prices
prednisone otc price: buy prednisone 10 mg – buy prednisone online australia
http://prednisonetablets.shop/# over the counter prednisone pills
where to buy prednisone without prescription: prednisone price south africa – india buy prednisone online
amoxicillin 500mg for sale uk can i purchase amoxicillin online amoxicillin buy online canada
zithromax 1000 mg online: average cost of generic zithromax – zithromax buy
https://amoxicillin.bid/# amoxicillin 250 mg
canadian pharmacy prices: Canada Pharmacy online – canadian pharmacy antibiotics canadianpharm.store
reputable indian pharmacies world pharmacy india reputable indian online pharmacy indianpharm.store
https://indianpharm.store/# top 10 pharmacies in india indianpharm.store
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: Certified Pharmacy from Mexico – п»їbest mexican online pharmacies mexicanpharm.shop
canadian pharmacy tampa: Canadian International Pharmacy – best canadian pharmacy to order from canadianpharm.store
top online pharmacy india order medicine from india to usa indian pharmacy online indianpharm.store
https://indianpharm.store/# best india pharmacy indianpharm.store
mexican mail order pharmacies: Online Pharmacies in Mexico – buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexicanpharm.shop
online canadian pharmacy: Canada Pharmacy online – pharmacy in canada canadianpharm.store
https://indianpharm.store/# top 10 pharmacies in india indianpharm.store
trusted canadian pharmacy: Certified Online Pharmacy Canada – canada drugs reviews canadianpharm.store
https://indianpharm.store/# best india pharmacy indianpharm.store
india pharmacy Indian pharmacy to USA indian pharmacy paypal indianpharm.store
mail order pharmacy india: Indian pharmacy to USA – india pharmacy mail order indianpharm.store
indianpharmacy com: international medicine delivery from india – top online pharmacy india indianpharm.store
https://indianpharm.store/# indianpharmacy com indianpharm.store
mexico pharmacy: Certified Pharmacy from Mexico – mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa mexicanpharm.shop
canadian pharmacy 365 Licensed Online Pharmacy canadian pharmacy checker canadianpharm.store
http://canadianpharm.store/# onlinecanadianpharmacy canadianpharm.store
mexican mail order pharmacies: Online Pharmacies in Mexico – buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexicanpharm.shop
https://mexicanpharm.shop/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs mexicanpharm.shop
best online pharmacies in mexico: Online Mexican pharmacy – buying from online mexican pharmacy mexicanpharm.shop
reputable indian pharmacies international medicine delivery from india buy prescription drugs from india indianpharm.store
http://canadianpharm.store/# best canadian pharmacy canadianpharm.store
Online medicine home delivery: international medicine delivery from india – buy medicines online in india indianpharm.store
top online pharmacy india: Indian pharmacy to USA – Online medicine home delivery indianpharm.store
mail order pharmacy india: Indian pharmacy to USA – india online pharmacy indianpharm.store
https://mexicanpharm.shop/# mexican pharmacy mexicanpharm.shop
indianpharmacy com order medicine from india to usa indian pharmacies safe indianpharm.store
online canadian pharmacy review: Canadian International Pharmacy – canadian online pharmacy canadianpharm.store
top 10 online pharmacy in india: international medicine delivery from india – buy prescription drugs from india indianpharm.store
http://canadianpharm.store/# canadian pharmacy online canadianpharm.store
п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india international medicine delivery from india buy medicines online in india indianpharm.store
buy prescription drugs from canada cheap: Canadian Pharmacy – canadian pharmacy online reviews canadianpharm.store
https://indianpharm.store/# reputable indian online pharmacy indianpharm.store
india pharmacy mail order: Indian pharmacy to USA – reputable indian online pharmacy indianpharm.store
buying prescription drugs in mexico mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs buying prescription drugs in mexico mexicanpharm.shop
mexico pharmacy: Online Mexican pharmacy – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs mexicanpharm.shop
https://canadianpharm.store/# northwest pharmacy canada canadianpharm.store
top online pharmacy india: order medicine from india to usa – top 10 pharmacies in india indianpharm.store
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa Online Pharmacies in Mexico buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexicanpharm.shop
canadian family pharmacy: Canadian International Pharmacy – 77 canadian pharmacy canadianpharm.store
https://mexicanpharm.shop/# reputable mexican pharmacies online mexicanpharm.shop
reputable indian online pharmacy order medicine from india to usa indian pharmacy indianpharm.store
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: Certified Pharmacy from Mexico – medication from mexico pharmacy mexicanpharm.shop
legal online pharmacies: legitimate canadian pharmacies – canadian trust pharmacy
medicine prices canadian pharmacy prescription buying drugs canada
https://canadadrugs.pro/# reputable mexican pharmacies online
top online pharmacies: most reputable canadian pharmacy – prescription drug price check
best canadian mail order pharmacies: canadian prescription drugs online – internet pharmacy no prior prescription
canada prescription drugs india online pharmacy canadian drugstore pharmacy
http://canadadrugs.pro/# universal canadian pharmacy
canadian pharmacies selling viagra: canadian pharmacy pain meds – top mail order pharmacies
canadian prescription drugs online canadian drug store viagra canadian pharmaceutical ordering
https://canadadrugs.pro/# canadian drug company
canada pharmacy online orders: prescriptions from canada without – canadian pharmacies that deliver to the us
canadian drug stores: canadian pharmacy selling viagra – northwest canadian pharmacy
http://canadadrugs.pro/# aarp recommended canadian pharmacies
certified canadian pharmacies cheap pharmacy online prescriptions without a doctor
drugstore online: best canadian pharmacy no prescription – discount drugs online pharmacy
https://canadadrugs.pro/# best online pharmacy without prescriptions
rx online no prior prescription: order drugs online – online prescription drugs
top rated canadian pharmacies online canada prescriptions online canadian pharmacy no rx needed
safe reliable canadian pharmacy: tadalafil canadian pharmacy – online prescription drugs
canadian prescriptions: international pharmacies – us pharmacy no prior prescription
http://canadadrugs.pro/# prescription without a doctor’s prescription
online pharmacy no peescription: aarp canadian pharmacies – top mexican pharmacies
canadian pharmacy reviews: canadian pharmacy price checker – canadian pharmacy 365
http://canadadrugs.pro/# list of canadian pharmacies online
mail order pharmacy: online canadian pharmaceutical companies – overseas pharmacy
http://canadadrugs.pro/# canadian discount pharmacy
canadian pharmacies recommended: trusted online pharmacy – levitra from canadian pharmacy
best canadian pharmacy: drugs without prescription – canadian pharmacies top best
https://canadadrugs.pro/# prescription drugs online
https://canadadrugs.pro/# my canadian pharmacy online
canadian pharmacy antiobotics without prescription: canadain pharmacy no prescription – best rated canadian online pharmacy
best canadian pharmacy prescription drugs prices express pharmacy
viagra without a prescription: cialis without a doctor prescription canada – prescription drugs online without
medication from mexico pharmacy п»їbest mexican online pharmacies mexican mail order pharmacies
http://edwithoutdoctorprescription.pro/# buy prescription drugs online without
discount prescription drugs: ed pills without doctor prescription – best ed pills non prescription
cheapest online pharmacy india online pharmacy india indian pharmacies safe
https://edwithoutdoctorprescription.pro/# legal to buy prescription drugs without prescription
viagra without a doctor prescription: cialis without a doctor prescription canada – buy prescription drugs online without
reputable indian pharmacies: Online medicine home delivery – buy prescription drugs from india
mexican rx online mexican pharmacy medicine in mexico pharmacies
http://certifiedpharmacymexico.pro/# best online pharmacies in mexico
п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india best india pharmacy top 10 online pharmacy in india
https://edwithoutdoctorprescription.pro/# tadalafil without a doctor’s prescription
mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexican mail order pharmacies – buying prescription drugs in mexico
http://edpill.cheap/# top erection pills
mexican mail order pharmacies mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india: pharmacy website india – indian pharmacy paypal
https://certifiedpharmacymexico.pro/# mexican drugstore online
buy prescription drugs from canada cheap cheap cialis cialis without a doctor’s prescription
https://certifiedpharmacymexico.pro/# mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
best online pharmacy india: indian pharmacies safe – indianpharmacy com
adderall canadian pharmacy canadian medications canadian pharmacies comparison
http://medicinefromindia.store/# india pharmacy
canada pharmacy online legit: reliable canadian pharmacy reviews – canadian 24 hour pharmacy
canada rx pharmacy world cross border pharmacy canada canadian compounding pharmacy
http://canadianinternationalpharmacy.pro/# canadian pharmacy tampa
http://canadianinternationalpharmacy.pro/# pharmacy com canada
safe canadian pharmacies canadian pharmacy india is canadian pharmacy legit
http://canadianinternationalpharmacy.pro/# canadian drug
reliable canadian pharmacy reviews: pet meds without vet prescription canada – canadian pharmacy 24h com
https://canadianinternationalpharmacy.pro/# canadian 24 hour pharmacy
ed pills comparison best non prescription ed pills erectile dysfunction pills
https://edwithoutdoctorprescription.pro/# non prescription erection pills
best ed pills online best pill for ed mens ed pills
https://canadianinternationalpharmacy.pro/# canadian pharmacy 24 com
pills for erection: best ed treatment – ed meds online
http://edwithoutdoctorprescription.pro/# buy prescription drugs online without
online shopping pharmacy india india pharmacy mail order india pharmacy
http://medicinefromindia.store/# top 10 pharmacies in india
ed prescription drugs cialis without a doctor prescription canada ed prescription drugs
http://certifiedpharmacymexico.pro/# mexican rx online
https://medicinefromindia.store/# top 10 online pharmacy in india
canadian pharmacy review online canadian drugstore canadian pharmacy scam
https://medicinefromindia.store/# online shopping pharmacy india
world pharmacy india
River Belle is among the oldest and most established online casinos in the world, having first gone live in 1997. Our sophisticated look, games, service and standards have been honed and polished over the years, to create the ultimate casino experience. Welcome to a lifetime of wonderful game play, huge bonuses and big jackpot wins! The more players play, the more loyalty points they will earn. There are a total of 6 levels to the loyalty program at River Belle casino. You are even given 2,500 points from the moment you make your first deposit at the casino. Some popular slots at the time of this River Belle casino review include the Bush Telegraph slot, Amazing Aztecs, Bar Bar Black Sheep, Golden Era and Dolphin Coast. River Belle holds a reputable licence and has been awarded the eCOGRA Seal of Approval for fair and safe play. Every player can enjoy their favourite casino games with confidence, and if you choose to play for real money you can make a deposit or cash out via a trusted payment service provider.
https://emilianoopmj174689.ampedpages.com/freeslots-juego-47433239
There are very few negatives when it comes to Party Casino. While you do need an account to fully navigate the site, you’ll discover an attractive interface that is easy to navigate. The welcome offer at Party Casino is not onerous to achieve compared to other online casinos, checking in at an 8x wagering requirement, but the amount that is available and the unique distribution is interesting. As with most online casinos, it does come down to the games. Jackpot slots offer the best cashback rates of 0.5%, but the 0.25% cashback on regular slots and instant win games is a touch lower than rival NJ casinos. Roulette (0.10%) and blackjack video poker (0.05%) bring up the rear. Be wary, though; if you don’t play on the PartyNJ site for 90 days consecutively, your cashback will be forfeited.
http://medicinefromindia.store/# top 10 pharmacies in india
pharmacy website india: india pharmacy mail order – cheapest online pharmacy india
viagra without a prescription ed pills without doctor prescription levitra without a doctor prescription
https://edwithoutdoctorprescription.pro/# online prescription for ed meds
buy medicines online in india best online pharmacy india india pharmacy mail order
http://edpill.cheap/# new ed treatments
п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india india pharmacy п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
http://medicinefromindia.store/# indian pharmacy online
ed meds online without doctor prescription: generic cialis without a doctor prescription – prescription drugs
mexican rx online buying from online mexican pharmacy buying prescription drugs in mexico
buying prescription drugs in mexico best mexican online pharmacies medication from mexico pharmacy
mexican pharmacy п»їbest mexican online pharmacies medication from mexico pharmacy
mexican drugstore online buying from online mexican pharmacy mexican drugstore online
https://mexicanph.shop/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
mexico pharmacy mexican mail order pharmacies mexico drug stores pharmacies
buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexican pharmaceuticals online mexican rx online
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa mexican pharmaceuticals online reputable mexican pharmacies online
https://mexicanph.shop/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
mexican drugstore online buying prescription drugs in mexico mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican drugstore online purple pharmacy mexico price list mexican pharmaceuticals online
mexico pharmacy mexican pharmacy mexico drug stores pharmacies
http://mexicanph.com/# mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
mexico drug stores pharmacies
mexican pharmaceuticals online buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexican mail order pharmacies
mexican rx online buying prescription drugs in mexico mexican mail order pharmacies
http://mexicanph.shop/# best online pharmacies in mexico
buying from online mexican pharmacy
https://mexicanph.com/# mexican mail order pharmacies
medication from mexico pharmacy
reputable mexican pharmacies online п»їbest mexican online pharmacies medicine in mexico pharmacies
http://mexicanph.shop/# medication from mexico pharmacy
buying prescription drugs in mexico online
mexico pharmacy п»їbest mexican online pharmacies buying prescription drugs in mexico online
I’m So Glad I Stumbled Upon This Article. It Was Exactly What I Needed To Read!
buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs best online pharmacies in mexico
reputable mexican pharmacies online mexican rx online buying from online mexican pharmacy
https://mexicanph.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online
mexican drugstore online
medication from mexico pharmacy mexican pharmacy mexican rx online
buying from online mexican pharmacy medication from mexico pharmacy mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
http://mexicanph.com/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
buying from online mexican pharmacy
mexico pharmacy buying prescription drugs in mexico mexico drug stores pharmacies
http://furosemide.guru/# lasix uses
https://lisinopril.top/# generic for prinivil
http://amoxil.cheap/# buy amoxicillin online uk
lisinopril 20 mg 12.5 mg how much is lisinopril zestril 20 mg price canadian pharmacy
http://amoxil.cheap/# amoxicillin 500 mg cost
https://stromectol.fun/# stromectol 3 mg tablet price
https://buyprednisone.store/# prednisone uk over the counter
https://furosemide.guru/# lasix generic
iv prednisone: prednisone 40 mg daily – prednisone nz
https://stromectol.fun/# ivermectin for humans
http://lisinopril.top/# zestril tab 10mg
https://stromectol.fun/# buy ivermectin nz
https://furosemide.guru/# lasix 100 mg tablet
http://indianph.com/# Online medicine home delivery
http://indianph.xyz/# indian pharmacy online
http://diflucan.pro/# diflucan 150
http://cytotec24.shop/# cytotec abortion pill
http://diflucan.pro/# can i buy diflucan online
buy generic diflucan diflucan uk online diflucan order online uk
http://doxycycline.auction/# doxycycline pills
http://abelladanger.online/# abella danger video
http://abelladanger.online/# abella danger izle
http://angelawhite.pro/# Angela White izle
https://abelladanger.online/# abella danger izle
http://abelladanger.online/# Abella Danger
https://angelawhite.pro/# Angela White
https://angelawhite.pro/# Angela White izle
https://evaelfie.pro/# eva elfie filmleri
https://sweetiefox.online/# Sweetie Fox izle
http://lanarhoades.fun/# lana rhoades izle
https://angelawhite.pro/# Angela White izle
https://lanarhoades.fun/# lana rhodes
eva elfie new video: eva elfie full videos – eva elfie hd
lana rhoades pics: lana rhoades hot – lana rhoades unleashed
datng websites: https://evaelfie.site/# eva elfie new videos
sweetie fox new: fox sweetie – ph sweetie fox
eva elfie: eva elfie – eva elfie new video
sweetie fox new: fox sweetie – fox sweetie
american singles: https://evaelfie.site/# eva elfie full video
fox sweetie: sweetie fox – sweetie fox cosplay
http://lanarhoades.pro/# lana rhoades pics
sweetie fox: sweetie fox video – sweetie fox video
mia malkova movie: mia malkova girl – mia malkova full video
https://miamalkova.life/# mia malkova photos
free online chat: http://evaelfie.site/# eva elfie full videos
mia malkova hd: mia malkova – mia malkova
http://lanarhoades.pro/# lana rhoades solo
lana rhoades unleashed: lana rhoades full video – lana rhoades pics
Yazarın samimi ve içten üslubu gerçekten dikkat çekiciydi. İçeriğin derinlikleri beni düşündürdü ve yeni perspektifler kazanmama yardımcı oldu. | Cumhuriyet, Dilovası Köşe Takımı Yıkama
http://miamalkova.life/# mia malkova photos
ph sweetie fox: ph sweetie fox – sweetie fox cosplay
sweetie fox cosplay: sweetie fox full video – sweetie fox
mia malkova girl: mia malkova only fans – mia malkova only fans
http://sweetiefox.pro/# sweetie fox full
lana rhoades pics: lana rhoades pics – lana rhoades hot
https://evaelfie.site/# eva elfie new videos
lana rhoades boyfriend: lana rhoades boyfriend – lana rhoades
eva elfie hot: eva elfie photo – eva elfie hd
single dating sites free: http://evaelfie.site/# eva elfie full videos
eva elfie full videos: eva elfie – eva elfie new video
aviator: aviator – aviator bet
Snaptube Nedir? | I just wanted to drop a quick note to say how much I appreciate the effort that goes into creating such informative and engaging blog posts.
ganhar dinheiro jogando: jogo de aposta – site de apostas
aviator oyna: aviator sinyal hilesi – aviator oyna
aviator jogo de aposta: ganhar dinheiro jogando – ganhar dinheiro jogando
Bundle Ürün Nedir? | MAFA’s expertise in web design and development is evident in the depth and breadth of their content. Thank you for sharing your knowledge with us.
http://aviatormocambique.site/# aviator online
aviator betting game: aviator bet malawi – aviator bet malawi login
https://pinupcassino.pro/# aviator pin up casino
aviator moçambique: jogar aviator – jogar aviator
aviator sinyal hilesi: aviator oyunu – aviator
play aviator: aviator game – aviator betting game
aviator bet malawi login: aviator game online – aviator bet malawi
order zithromax over the counter: zithromax warnings buy cheap zithromax online
aviator moçambique: aviator mz – aviator
What is Cat.Ex | I appreciate the effort you put into crafting each post. It truly shows in the quality of your content.
where can i buy zithromax uk – https://azithromycin.pro/zithromax-medication.html buy zithromax online
aviator jogar: aviator bet – pin up aviator
jogos que dao dinheiro: melhor jogo de aposta para ganhar dinheiro – jogo de aposta online
buy cheap zithromax online: zithromax antibiotic – zithromax 600 mg tablets
Blonde Hair Color Ideas and Blonde Hairstyles for 2024 | Your authenticity is what makes your blog so relatable. Keep up the great work!
canadian world pharmacy My Canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy sarasota canadianpharm.store
mexican mail order pharmacies: Medicines Mexico – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa mexicanpharm.shop
buy medicines online in india Pharmacies in India that ship to USA buy medicines online in india indianpharm.store
https://mexicanpharm24.com/# medication from mexico pharmacy mexicanpharm.shop
https://indianpharm24.com/# pharmacy website india indianpharm.store
https://indianpharm24.com/# online pharmacy india indianpharm.store
https://canadianpharmlk.com/# reliable canadian pharmacy canadianpharm.store
https://canadianpharmlk.com/# canadian drug canadianpharm.store
http://canadianpharmlk.shop/# reputable canadian online pharmacy canadianpharm.store
mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexican drugstore online – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs mexicanpharm.shop
mexican drugstore online: order online from a Mexican pharmacy – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs mexicanpharm.shop
https://canadianpharmlk.com/# maple leaf pharmacy in canada canadianpharm.store
http://mexicanpharm24.com/# mexican pharmacy mexicanpharm.shop
https://mexicanpharm24.com/# mexican rx online mexicanpharm.shop
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa Mexico pharmacy online mexican rx online mexicanpharm.shop
Bandırma / Balıkesir | We were highly satisfied with the service provided. They meet expectations both in terms of product quality and customer service.
can i order cheap clomid without rx: buy generic clomid prices – can you get clomid price
http://clomidst.pro/# can you get clomid online
over the counter amoxicillin canada: buy amoxicillin online no prescription – where to buy amoxicillin pharmacy
ampicillin amoxicillin amoxicillin 50 mg tablets amoxil pharmacy
http://amoxilst.pro/# can i purchase amoxicillin online
prednisone sale: prednisone 10mg – prednisone 40 mg price
http://prednisonest.pro/# pharmacy cost of prednisone
http://prednisonest.pro/# purchase prednisone from india
prednisone canada pharmacy prednisone 5 mg tablet prednisone 30 mg tablet
cost generic clomid without insurance: can you buy clomid – can i purchase cheap clomid without insurance
where to buy amoxicillin: amoxicillin canada price – order amoxicillin online uk
amoxicillin no prescription: amoxicillin 875 – where can you get amoxicillin
https://clomidst.pro/# can i purchase clomid without prescription
online pharmacy prescription pharmacy online canadian pharmacies not requiring prescription
international pharmacy no prescription: canada pharmacy online – canadian pharmacy without prescription
https://onlinepharmacy.cheap/# cheapest pharmacy for prescription drugs
no prescription needed pharmacy: Best online pharmacy – online pharmacy prescription
prescription canada: buy medication online with prescription – how to buy prescriptions from canada safely
https://onlinepharmacy.cheap/# online pharmacy no prescription needed
buy prescription drugs without a prescription no prescription needed buy medications without prescriptions
http://edpills.guru/# order ed pills
https://pharmnoprescription.pro/# ordering prescription drugs from canada
ed online pharmacy: top rated ed pills – buy erectile dysfunction pills online
http://onlinepharmacy.cheap/# canada pharmacy not requiring prescription
canada drugs no prescription buying drugs online no prescription mail order prescriptions from canada
ed meds by mail: buy erectile dysfunction medication – ed medications online
https://mexicanpharm.online/# mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
https://pharmacynoprescription.pro/# online medication no prescription
http://mexicanpharm.online/# mexican drugstore online
https://mexicanpharm.online/# best online pharmacies in mexico
https://mexicanpharm.online/# mexican drugstore online
mexican rx online mexican mail order pharmacies mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
canadian prescription: no prescription on line pharmacies – online pharmacy without a prescription
https://pharmacynoprescription.pro/# canadian pharmacy no prescription required
https://indianpharm.shop/# buy medicines online in india
https://canadianpharm.guru/# legit canadian pharmacy online
http://mexicanpharm.online/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
https://pharmacynoprescription.pro/# canada prescription online
https://mexicanpharm.online/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
http://canadianpharm.guru/# canadian pharmacy victoza
http://indianpharm.shop/# online shopping pharmacy india
canadian pharmacy meds review canadian neighbor pharmacy canadianpharmacymeds
https://indianpharm.shop/# pharmacy website india
http://canadianpharm.guru/# the canadian pharmacy
india online pharmacy: online pharmacy india – best online pharmacy india
https://pharmacynoprescription.pro/# best online pharmacy without prescription
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa mexican drugstore online best online pharmacies in mexico
https://mexicanpharm.online/# medicine in mexico pharmacies
http://pharmacynoprescription.pro/# mexico online pharmacy prescription drugs
http://pharmacynoprescription.pro/# best online pharmacy that does not require a prescription in india
prescription from canada: buying drugs online no prescription – pharmacy with no prescription
https://mexicanpharm.online/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
http://pharmacynoprescription.pro/# online pharmacy canada no prescription
https://mexicanpharm.online/# medicine in mexico pharmacies
pin-up casino indir: pin up casino giris – pin-up casino
https://aviatoroyna.bid/# aviator oyunu 100 tl
yasal slot siteleri: slot oyunlar? siteleri – yasal slot siteleri
gates of olympus max win: gates of olympus guncel – gates of olympus taktik
aviator sinyal hilesi: ucak oyunu bahis aviator – aviator nas?l oynan?r
http://pinupgiris.fun/# pin up casino indir
pin up casino: pin-up casino – pin up indir
oyun siteleri slot: bonus veren casino slot siteleri – en guvenilir slot siteleri
aviator casino oyunu: aviator oyunu 100 tl – aviator nas?l oynan?r
http://slotsiteleri.guru/# canli slot siteleri
http://slotsiteleri.guru/# slot siteleri 2024
pin-up casino indir: pin up guncel giris – pin up casino guncel giris
gates of olympus: gates of olympus oyna – gates of olympus
sweet bonanza slot demo: slot oyunlari – sweet bonanza demo turkce
aviator sinyal hilesi: aviator oyna – ucak oyunu bahis aviator
https://pinupgiris.fun/# pin-up bonanza
pin up 7/24 giris: pin-up online – pin-up casino giris
http://aviatoroyna.bid/# aviator
pin up guncel giris: pin up bet – pin up indir
deneme bonusu veren slot siteleri: slot siteleri – oyun siteleri slot
pharmacy website india: indian pharmacy delivery – india pharmacy mail order
http://mexicanpharmacy.shop/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
mexican mail order pharmacies: buying prescription drugs in mexico – buying prescription drugs in mexico online
canadian pharmacy 24h com safe pharmacies in canada that ship to the us canada rx pharmacy
https://canadianpharmacy24.store/# canadian online pharmacy reviews
canadian drug pharmacy: Large Selection of Medications – canadian pharmacy 24h com
http://mexicanpharmacy.shop/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
buy prescription drugs from canada cheap: pills now even cheaper – canadian pharmacy meds review
zithromax capsules 250mg: zithromax 500 tablet – zithromax cost uk
can i get clomid price: can i get clomid without dr prescription – where buy cheap clomid now
can i order cheap clomid without a prescription where can i buy clomid clomid medication
http://clomidall.shop/# how to buy generic clomid without prescription
zithromax 500mg price: buy zithromax online australia – generic zithromax 500mg india
clomid medication can you get cheap clomid without rx can i order generic clomid no prescription
zithromax tablets: zithromax z-pak – zithromax capsules 250mg
http://zithromaxall.shop/# zithromax 500 mg lowest price drugstore online
http://sildenafiliq.xyz/# Sildenafil 100mg price
Cheap Viagra 100mg: sildenafil iq – Generic Viagra for sale
https://kamagraiq.shop/# Kamagra Oral Jelly
Cialis 20mg price: Buy Cialis online – cheapest cialis
https://sildenafiliq.xyz/# Order Viagra 50 mg online
http://tadalafiliq.com/# Generic Cialis price
http://sildenafiliq.xyz/# buy Viagra over the counter
Cialis over the counter cheapest cialis buy cialis pill
http://tadalafiliq.com/# Buy Tadalafil 20mg
Kamagra Oral Jelly: Kamagra Oral Jelly Price – buy Kamagra
http://kamagraiq.com/# super kamagra
sildenafil online: buy viagra online – over the counter sildenafil
http://kamagraiq.shop/# super kamagra
https://tadalafiliq.shop/# Buy Tadalafil 5mg
Cheapest Sildenafil online: sildenafil iq – Viagra without a doctor prescription Canada
http://kamagraiq.shop/# buy Kamagra
Viagra tablet online: sildenafil iq – Generic Viagra for sale
http://tadalafiliq.com/# Buy Tadalafil 20mg
super kamagra: kamagra best price – buy kamagra online usa
india pharmacy: Healthcare and medicines from India – Online medicine home delivery
canada discount pharmacy: CIPA approved pharmacies – canadian pharmacy checker
http://mexicanpharmgrx.shop/# mexican mail order pharmacies
https://indianpharmgrx.shop/# indianpharmacy com
indianpharmacy com: indian pharmacy delivery – indian pharmacies safe
best online pharmacies in mexico: mexican pharmacy – reputable mexican pharmacies online
buy prescription drugs from india indian pharmacy top online pharmacy india
canadian pharmacy 365: Cheapest drug prices Canada – canadian pharmacy prices
mexican mail order pharmacies mexican pharmacy reputable mexican pharmacies online
indian pharmacy: indian pharmacy delivery – world pharmacy india
https://canadianpharmgrx.com/# canadapharmacyonline
diflucan tablets buy online no script: cost of diflucan prescription in mexico – over the counter diflucan 150
purchase cytotec: cytotec pills buy online – buy cytotec in usa
buy cytotec online п»їcytotec pills online Misoprostol 200 mg buy online
where can i get doxycycline: buy doxycycline for dogs – doxycycline 500mg
can i buy diflucan without a prescription: diflucan 200 – diflucan medicine
https://doxycyclinest.pro/# buy doxycycline without prescription uk
diflucan: buy diflucan online usa – buy diflucan online
ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price: buy cipro cheap – ciprofloxacin over the counter
https://misoprostol.top/# purchase cytotec
cipro 500mg best prices: buy ciprofloxacin – cipro for sale
ciprofloxacin over the counter buy ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin order online
buy cytotec over the counter: buy cytotec – cytotec online
ciprofloxacin generic price: where can i buy cipro online – cipro
https://ciprofloxacin.guru/# ciprofloxacin over the counter
where to buy diflucan 1: how much is over the counter diflucan – diflucan men
buy diflucan prescription med diflucan cream diflucan 150 mg buy online
https://amoxicillina.top/# amoxicillin order online no prescription
where can i buy zithromax medicine: zithromax 500 mg lowest price pharmacy online – where can i purchase zithromax online
where buy generic clomid pill: how to buy cheap clomid without prescription – can i purchase cheap clomid no prescription
http://stromectola.top/# generic ivermectin cream
https://stromectola.top/# stromectol xr
https://stromectola.top/# ivermectin
https://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
https://medicationnoprescription.pro/# best website to buy prescription drugs
buying ed pills online: ed drugs online – generic ed meds online
best no prescription online pharmacies: ordering prescription drugs from canada – buy medications without prescriptions
canadian pharmacy coupon: canadian pharmacy without prescription – cheapest pharmacy to fill prescriptions without insurance
canadian pharmacy without prescription: legal online pharmacy coupon code – prescription drugs online
http://medicationnoprescription.pro/# online pharmacy that does not require a prescription
cheap ed medication cheapest online ed treatment erectile dysfunction pills for sale
http://onlinepharmacyworld.shop/# promo code for canadian pharmacy meds
edmeds: cheap ed medication – where to buy ed pills
ed doctor online: best online ed medication – cost of ed meds
http://casinvietnam.com/# casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam
http://casinvietnam.shop/# casino tr?c tuy?n
https://casinvietnam.com/# casino online uy tin
danh bai tr?c tuy?n web c? b?c online uy tin casino online uy tin
http://casinvietnam.shop/# danh bai tr?c tuy?n
indianpharmacy com https://indiaph24.store/# online pharmacy india
Online medicine home delivery
Hello, your customer service is very fast and solution-oriented. Thank you for resolving the issue I experienced quickly.