A Librarian Looks at the JSTOR Download Case

A Tweet by Nilay Patel (@reckless) of Verge called my attention to an intelligent post giving a librarian’s perspective on the charges against Demand Progress’ Aaron Swartz. Swartz faces federal felony charges for allegedly using unauthorized access to the MIT network and the JSTOR academic journal archive to download millions of articles.

Nancy Sims, copyright librarian at the University of Minnesota Libraries, dispels what have become some common misconceptions about the case. First, she points out, there are no copyright charges involved. And she notes that all databases such as JSTOR have restrictions on downloads and that the violations alleged in this case are pretty straightforward.

One place where I disagree with Sims is that she, like many others, compares the case to that of Lori Drew, a woman who was prosecuted for computer fraud for bullying a young teen in violation of MySpace terms of service. Drew was convicted, but an appeals court later threw out the case.

A key difference (besides that fact that no individuals suffered direct or indirect harm in the JSTOR case while Drew’s actions may have contributed to the target’s suicide) is that the actions laid out in the indictment show a pattern of willful assault on the MIT network and the JSTOR database. It is by no means a simple case, as Swartz’ defenders have claimed, of “downloading too many articles” or even violating MIT or JSTOR terms of service.

One other point: Sims, along with many others, questions the proportionality of the government charging multiple felonies carrying a theoretical prison term of up to 35 years. Prosecutors customarily throw everything they have into an indictment. I’d be very surprised if this case does not end in a plea bargain with no jail time.

Published by

Steve Wildstrom

Steve Wildstrom is veteran technology reporter, writer, and analyst based in the Washington, D.C. area. He created and wrote BusinessWeek’s Technology & You column for 15 years. Since leaving BusinessWeek in the fall of 2009, he has written his own blog, Wildstrom on Tech and has contributed to corporate blogs, including those of Cisco and AMD and also consults for major technology companies.

153 thoughts on “A Librarian Looks at the JSTOR Download Case”

  1. Freee gaay strap oon pornHbo s real seex schedule1950 jammes dean gay or notFremch mai thumbsNakwd blonde lessbians wiuth firm
    titsMature giving fuckingFree huge blpack cockk videoCarpet milf lesbianAnusbka porrn videosPorn srar tpgMature escoorts east
    angliaAsian dub foundation + pnkbRachesl weisz nuide videoaWide open pussy galleriesGayy dbz yaoiNaked
    fakee photos of hillary clintonAdult grtaways indianaXhawmster teenWork of
    liksa pantyhose runHot cofdfee aduult mmod 2.1Nursinghome seual abuseNaked biig breatsSeex position hardcore vdeosAsian teen pieScottsdale male breast reducion doctorFrree celeberty porn movieVery young ten gayy boysFrree piss iin miuth xPhilly bds partiesHadsome sezy guysSensual seex
    vudeo trailers forr womenFind repolacement paarts for vintage flourescet fixtureSex
    poses iin yogaNuude phots oof zoee kazanSex cartfoons simpsonsSwingging lanternSeexual harasssment resignationBeast surgery bottomihg
    outBlack bacxks pussyPollyanna sexTaiwan ttwins seex videoDiaqne kwen nakedSamantha gayYahooo porn groupsBigges natural tits contestFreee animated
    stgrip gamesLingerie chantal homass tarifHardcore movvie samplesColln coungy seex offender
    databaseHot bikini videosMapp of carbbean virgn islandsStory female
    dominationChristpher columbus redheadLesbian deathAmateurr poorn romanianHillbily
    teenStip pooker annn andd sueNudee hotos off natale dormerYounhg healthy couplews sex tapesSpetm bank tulsa oklahomaFreee full lenhgth milf tubesBresast milk moldNiky chhase nudeNuude japan thumbBig blackk ass anwl sexErotic wives pic galleryPojenon podn game0holds baredd peni https://xnxx2.pro Personal addd phoje
    seex srri lankaAmandfa overmeyer nakedS m ssex picsFanstasy ssport girrl jeasi nakedFtv big pussyTurned into a fat slutAdult cary jokeParis hilton videeo free dowsnload pornoPics of peeople
    having scissor sex10 dicks chickWhite wifes sluut storiesGoood
    sexy storyFemmale galldry mature nude thumbMouth exetcises
    forr blopw jobsFuckiing kaai teannaMture latina analDaily haandjob
    moviesMature inn pantuhose videos free archiveGiant massive titsFree anijmated porn mviesSwimsuits for women with big breastRoundworms iin adult catSexy young girl bigHfcs acne
    cause ggel faciual cloeanser wwhy dooes chocolate causeA man wth 2 cocksFuuny porn pixSllut hlme movieEvangaline ily nakedLebians mske me cumStaked oout nudeHairy paintersKatern nudeVintage
    tuscanJamin st claire fuckingPorn oldd wit youngTeens forr dollars realityShould yyou hae sex with yojr splouse wile
    being separatedVoyeuur camjp picsHow much money willl two
    adultsTeeen buud picsFucking in grouup orhy moviee video1970 catalog lingerieTeen online nudeUltimate puswy insertionCoolt studioo aall hairy araab
    manBaaby girls hentaiNude men hairySapphire’s boobsTaylorswift
    seex tapeLass vegaas stfrip club namesFlickr facialsI am so glamorous i piss glitter graphicLatoya jackson playboy nude
    picsVintage hhistorical newspaper clippingsMovie asianGiant
    girth dicksMasturbtion with a vacumeIaam agifl ican t pantyhowe videosVimtage dogWidee loadd
    escort pilot licxense pennsylvaniaKnot at base
    of penisBredast implanhts in nyVeenus vibratorSexx stpries libraryHustler
    hollywood stokre tacomaBra pantie pic teenShe want sexSex throw upSeex and thee
    ity movie hairAmanda peert seex scerne videoMilf cumsht samplesEroticca rachelColorado sex clubFreee haspsnic xxx clipsFlorida
    swingers videoGay twink picturess freeAdult online comkc
    booksFrree uncircumcised cock boack girlSexxy nue women with largee breastsAsioan irls in igh heelsCalendar phto sexyAmatgeur grls
    stripping nudeMichael madison’s lortd of tthe ass volAraab
    lessbian porn

  2. Greetings, I believe your website could be having
    browser compatibility problems. Whenever I look at your web site in Safari,
    it looks fine however, when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping issues.
    I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Apart from that, excellent blog!

  3. Heya just wanted to give you a brief heads up and let you know a few
    of the pictures aren’t loading correctly. I’m not sure why but I think its a linking issue.
    I’ve tried it in two different internet browsers and
    both show the same results.

  4. Wow, awesome blog layout! How long have you been running a
    blog for? you make running a blog look easy.
    The entire glance of your site is magnificent, let alone
    the content material!

  5. Definitely consider that which you said. Your favorite justification seemed
    to be on the net the simplest thing to take into accout of.
    I say to you, I certainly get annoyed whilst people consider
    issues that they plainly don’t realize about.
    You managed to hit the nail upon the top and defined out the entire thing with no need
    side effect , other folks could take a signal.
    Will probably be again to get more. Thank you

  6. Nice post. I was checking continuously this blog and I am impressed!
    Extremely useful information specifically the last part :
    ) I care for such information much. I was looking for this certain info for a long time.
    Thank you and best of luck.

  7. Someone necessarily help to make critically posts I might state.
    That is the very first time I frequented your web page and up to now?
    I surprised with the analysis you made to make this particular post extraordinary.
    Magnificent activity!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *