A Post Net Neutrality World Order

Yesterday, as expected, the Federal Communications Commission repealed 2015’s Open Internet Rules, also known as ‘net neutrality’. Much ink has been spilled (or keys tapped) on this issue, including my own Techpinions piece two weeks ago, arguing about the paradoxy of repealing Network Neutrality, while at the same time blocking AT&T’s acquisition of Time Warner.

I see credence on both sides of the Network Neutrality argument, and I tend to agree with Jon Leibowitz’s Wall Street Journal op-ed yesterday that the sky didn’t fall when Title II was imposed in 2015, nor will it now that it has been repealed.

So, as this continues to be litigated over the coming months, it might be a good time to think about the best protections from anticompetitive practices, while recognizing the rapid changes occurring in content, digital media, and communications. In this “Post Net Neutrality World Order”, I urge the major actors in the game—service providers, content providers, regulators—to adopt the following Code of Conduct.

  1. Task 1: Read and adopt the words of AT&T’s Senior Vice President Bob Quinn, who pledged in a November blog post that “We Will not block websites, degrade internet traffic based on content, [or] unfairly discriminate in our treatment of Internet traffic”. This, in principle, is now in the remit of the Federal Trade Commission, which in the past has been fair and balanced on this issue.
  2. Positive Practices Are More Permissible Than Negative Practices. It’s not that big a deal if AT&T zero-rates content DTV content for its wireless subscribers, or offers some attractive bundles. It’s more concerning if engage in a practice to slow down services for subscribers that are competitive with DTV. Similarly, on the B2B side of the equation, there’s a good case for ‘fast lanes’ in some instances. ‘Slow lanes’ will be harder to justify.
  3. Refrain From Practices Clearly Impinge On the Idea of the Open Internet. Some of the biggest concerns have to do with the potential for service providers to take a “cable” approach to the Internet, such as charging for access to specific sites. It will take only one or two airline-esque practices like this to set us back.
  4. Recognize that Wireless Is different than Fixed. I’ve long argued that the FCC should look at wireless through a different lens, when compared to broadband. Wireless services will forever be capacity constrained, even in a 5G world. That’s why ‘unlimited’ plans always come with an asterisk. There have been practices such as throttling and zero rating, where regulators, even in a Title II world, treaded lightly. New services such as LAA, and the concept of network slicing will introduce more opportunities to offer tiers of service.
  5. There’s Nothing Wrong With Tiers of Service. It’s 2020, and Nintendo introduces a new, multi-player online virtual reality game requiring faster speeds and lower latencies. So they pay some sort of ‘fast lane’ surcharge to a service provider, some of which gets passed on to the consumer. I don’t see anything wrong with that. Even though more and more households might be able to get 1 GB services, they might not necessarily need Or need them all the time.
  6. DOJ meet FCC, FCC Meet DOJ. We have to work toward a broader policy framework. As I argued in an earlier column, repealing network neutrality and blocking AT&T-Time Warner don’t seem to be coming from the same thought process (yes, I recognize that these are handled by different agencies). That said, we’ve seen more practices in the content business that have been detrimental to consumers—DISH standoffs with networks, Amazon-Google—than any violations of Open Internet rules.
  7. Be Transparent. There are going to be situations where some of the practices that have been the focus of those in favor of greater regulation make sense, given business realities or this changed landscape. This is where the FTC could step in if the service providers are not more proactive themselves.

More broadly, the tectonic changes occurring in our communications, digital media, and content landscape beg for a broader strategic review of our policy framework. This is one of the reasons there’s been a call for Congress to legislate this, rather than have it be in the hands of the FCC, whose philosophy could change every four years.  The 1996 Telecom Act seems increasingly outmoded, as it fails to properly account or adjust for, the emergence of wireless broadband (LTE, 5G), smartphones, the rise of OTT and streaming, and consolidation in the content landscape (Comcast-NBC Universal, AT&T-Time Warner, Disney-Fox).  It seems like right now, we’re dealing with all of these changes on a deal-by-deal basis: impose NN and then repeal it; allow Comcast-NBC/Universal but block AT&T-Time Warner; allow Internet companies to do things that telecom companies can’t. In this giant Venn diagram of telecom and the Internet, you’ve got AT&T and Verizon owning important content assets, while Google and Facebook provide broadband services and OTT communications and messaging services.

The other thing this all points to is that we need more competition in broadband. Currently, only 50% of households have access to more than one decent broadband provider. A more competitive broadband market would more naturally prevent some of the practices we’re now trying to legislate our way out of. There’s the potential for some change here with the approach of 5G and fixed wireless.  A 2020 Telecom Act might, for example, revisit the rules around network resale, which has led to more robust broadband competition in other countries.

Published by

Mark Lowenstein

Mark Lowenstein is Managing Director of Mobile Ecosystem, an advisory services firm focused on mobile and digital media. He founded and led the Yankee Group's global wireless practices and was also VP, Market Strategy at Verizon Wireless. You can follow him on Twitter at @marklowenstein and sign up for his free Lens on Wireless newsletter here.

3 thoughts on “A Post Net Neutrality World Order”

  1. If you would like to meet an unimaginable Russian girl, have a tendency miss out on to be capable of finding true love. These ladies are very reactive, so it’s simple to find someone you’d like to attach with. There are a number of necessary issues to think about earlier than selecting a Russian woman seeing web site. There are lots of single Russian ladies with youngsters, but it surely does not prevent them from relationship men and making an attempt to attain private happiness. Russian women are introduced up in a totally completely different atmosphere. Fully free russian dating website. This courting scene isn’t for you if airfare is out of the price range. This isn’t to say that there will not be problems, however for essentially the most half, society accepts and encourages strict gender roles. But no matter a couple’s fixed communication over the internet, there’s nothing like hanging out together with your date in person. Therefore, it can be crucial to know that while your girlfriend may be completely happy up to now for a prolonged time period, her mother and father and grandparents can be asking her about marriage and youngsters consistently. Whereas their relentless opinions or hostility in the direction of you could possibly be annoying, it could also be the proper test of your relationship’s strength.

    Lots of the web sites supply English translation to help you navigate the platform simpler and many of the girls speak some English while others are fluent. It doesn’t help that many medical doctors in Russia also push ladies to have children as early as doable. This may increasingly come as a surprise, but Russian women are incredibly grateful for assist on this regard. They are beautiful. They consider that Russian women are the most stunning girls all over the world. Olga Mikhailova triumphed at the European Court of Human Rights in 2017, when it ruled that the Russian convictions of Navalny and his brother Oleg in the Yves Rocher case, for fraud and cash-laundering, were “arbitrary and unfair”. Now, human constructions hold very little curiosity for me, I desire to go nature. Russia is advanced in the fields of tradition, schooling, science and so forth, but their social constructions are still very outdated. Instead, you’ll be capable of view an entire host of beautiful Russian girls, both from Russia itself or living in Ukraine, who are hoping for eligible suitors like you. If you want to ship a be aware to a Russian woman, you’ll should be a premium affiliate.

    To get started messaging an japanese european woman, and so forth premium regular membership. Everyone is unique, so take time to get to know your date. Girls in Russia believe in equality and their proper to be treated with the same respect males get. You may even use the complete search capabilities to search out the best companions. This enables them to have an excellent time even with strangers. Most Russian households have a dacha or nation home where they like to spend time within the summer season months. They pass their knowledge and train them how to keep the house clear and impress their beloved ones with cooking expertise. That stated, Russian ladies will do anything to maintain their relationships robust and stunning. Dad and mom of the dead kids have pleaded to keep him behind bars for the rest of his life, fearing he will return to his sinister outdated behavior which saw him residing with some youngsters’s stays for up to 10 years. Educated, sturdy, and independent, they are all the time searching for a partner, next to whom they want to really feel like they are behind a stone wall, who will surround them with care, open the door for them, pay in eating places, and shower them with compliments.

    In fact, there are Russian women who will attempt to take advantage of the actual fact that you’re a foreigner in Russia. There are undoubtedly advantages when expectations are decrease for both parties to a relationship. Ladies in Russia are surprisingly loyal and faithful. This goes back to gender roles in Russia and the way they russian dating differ from the West. They’re loud, usually driven by gender stereotypes, and generally is a bit rude and dramatic. They are often the most heartwarming individual to their loved ones, however they wouldn’t settle for something less from anybody who mistreats them. Trips, particularly unplanned ones, could be costly and impractical. Taking good care of the little things for them will make a Russian lady fall madly in love. Grooming. You possibly can hardly find another nation filled with ladies who care about their appearance more than Russian girls. In pursuit of love, persons are find to go the additional mile. Fortunately, Russian-courting on-line helps the ladies discover their soul mate, first in the online format, but then in actual conferences as properly. The first name that we’d like to mention in the listing of cute Russian boy names then we would definitely point out considered one of our private favorite names which can be Adrik.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *