A Sneak Peek at a Super Secret Apple Product Plan!

Way back in 1994 when I was working for Motorola, I was fortunate enough to be invited to a breakfast meeting between the then CEO’s of Apple and Motorola, Michael Spindler and Gary Tooker. A lot of preparation goes into these meetings–just getting the people in the room saying the things you need them to say is the objective. Weeks of work went into a single two hour breakfast in a private hotel suite in Austin, Texas. Everything was supposed to go by the script–one that we had hammered out with our Apple counterparts the week before. I say “supposed to”, because at the meeting Gary let slip that we had a full set of Apple product roadmaps for everything Apple was planning to make. Mr. Spindler was not happy to find this out.

In the way only the Germans can do so well, he let his displeasure be known; his face became red and he began using giant compound teutonic words sprinkled liberally with what sounded like “scheisse”. Now, we came by those roadmaps through our own hard work: listening, comparing notes, guessing a bit, reconfirming… our salespeople did their jobs recreating something that Apple never shared with us explicitly. All Mr. Spindler did through his reaction at that meeting was tell us we were right. Which is why clever men like Gary say off-script things to men like Michael (much to the chagrin of lowly staffers like me). The general lesson was not lost on me though. If you are conscientious and careful you can reconstruct super-secret product roadmaps and plans even when your customer is trying valiantly to keep them from you. Even though times have changed at Apple and they have become even more secretive, it is still possible today.

To try and make a modern Apple product map you have to realize at least five things about their company:

1. Right angles are to be despised
2. The experience of a product is all that matters
3. Technology is always in service to an experience
4. When a product should be built is far more important than if a product should be built
5. Money can be made when something looks easy, because easy is very hard to do

So what does this all mean when taken together? First, a strong opinion about the central experience is absolutely required. Imagine hours upon hours of discussion on how a thing should feel from its heft, to an edge, to the way it must respond, before ever deciding the “how” of achieving that experience. Secondly, Descartes is not welcome in Cupertino. The one thing you will probably not find at the heart of the most secret design thinking at Apple is a nice X-Y grid with specifications rising up and to the right on to infinity. Cartesian thinking carries with it an implied dualism–MIPS per millimeter, or milliwatts per hour, for example, and human experiences tend not to fit that neatly on a grid. Experiences tend to overlap each other, as do the capabilities of a piece of technology, so the product plan must be capable of showing the overlaps in a way that encourages thinking about a requirement’s relationship to the whole, not a part. To be sure, Apple will happily show off specs and classic X-Y charts after the fact, but it is highly unlikely they design a product that way. Everything must point back to the experience, that is the guiding principle.

Imagine Steve Jobs and Jony Ive way back in 2002, out for a walk. Steve is out front Jony is a step or two behind listening respectfully. Steve reaches into his back pocket and pulls out his iPod. He says point blank that he wants the same experience he has with his music (namely all of it, right here, right now in the pocket of his blue jeans) for the entire internet. The thing he wants is the entire internet in a pocket. That discussion sets a boundary on an experience that becomes inviolate. Pockets have certain sizes because hands fit in them. Hands have certain ratios such as the distance a thumb can rationally travel while holding something. The internet to most users means a browser, so a no compromise handheld browser must be dreamed up. How do we navigate? Click wheel? And on and on… no one goes near a piece of technology until after the experience is fully defined and it fits inside that sacrosanct bubble that is the prime directive. We could imagine a development timeline at Apple being 80% debate about the experience and 20% mad dash to get the thing out the door.

Put it all together and you get something that probably looks like this:

Screen Shot 2013-11-11 at 6.02.30 PM

1: Center: the experience
2: Next layer: Vital characteristics of the experience
3: Next layer: Enablers of those characteristics
4: Next layer: Technologies that are required
5: and so on…

This is obviously a simplistic view, but taken together you can see how Apple could decide to wait until 2007 to release the “internet in your pocket” iPhone. If the wedges aren’t in place to deliver the experience you wait, and that might take years. You can also bet that if such a plan existed, only a handful ever see a complete one. Each product area in the company focuses on its piece not necessarily seeing the whole, or only as much of it as required to get the job done. Plans like these can keep secrecy at a maximum. There is also a certain beauty in a product plan like this because it keeps everyone maniacally focussed on an experiential outcome.

These charts can and do get enormously complex but that is what is required to make an experience look easy.

And easy is the best way to make good money.

Published by

Carl Schlachte

Carl is a serial entrepreneur, having been Chairman and CEO of multiple public and private companies. He is currently CEO of Ventiva, a private thermal management company, as well as Chairman of Immersion (Nasdaq: IMMR ) and a director at Peregrine Semiconductor (Nasdaq: PSMI). You can follow Carl on Twitter at carlsuqupro.

958 thoughts on “A Sneak Peek at a Super Secret Apple Product Plan!”

  1. Wow, Carl, when I read the title of this article, I thought it was going to be a spoof or a way to chastise the rumor-mongers. But this was quite insightful.

    I really enjoyed this and I’m looking forward to reading more of your material in the future.

  2. Great. Hope you don’t mind my plopping an outline here. Apple makes oblique reference to this kind of logical view as “liberal education.” But it has nice hooks to your approach above. As you say, it’s doesn’t simplify the process of creation; robots need not apply.

    Apple and Aristotle:
    Poor criticism is unbalanced, incoherent.
    Even good criticism can struggle for balance and coherence.
    Balanced criticism must appeal to a definition of the whole.
    A wholistic definition of reality/causality is as old as Aristotle.
    Aristotle’s definition of any thing employs four causes for specificity and comparability.

    Causes:
    The four causes are material, formal, efficient, and final.
    Let’s apply these to the iPad to define just what it is Apple invented, to offer more coherence and balance.
    The what, the material cause, of the iPad is all the specced bits in it.
    The how, the formal cause, includes design choices as to what the iPad will look like and do.
    The who, the efficient cause, includes all the work on hard/software that make it do what it does.
    The why, the final cause, is the purpose for the iPad: computing, surfing, messaging, etc.

    Implications:
    Using four causes can generate descriptive definitions for devices and a kind of gamut chart for comparison.
    The material bits that make up the iPad are also defined by four causes themselves.
    The formal cause is the Jony Ives piece primarily.
    The efficient cause includes both engineers, developers, and manufacturers the Tim Cook piece.
    The final cause is decided by developers firstly and users ultimately.

  3. Nice work, Mr. Schlachte.

    I spend many of my working hours listening to my upper management wax on about how they understand Apple. Drawing on textbooks that never had any basis in fact, they claim to have complete understanding of everything Steve Jobs ever planned. I listen, give blank stares and let them continue their diatribes.

    It seems incomprehensible to them that Apple is a vision-first company. Building a great product matters; their secret is in NOT thinking about how much money they can save/make to meet a target market price point. Apple’s focus is on what should (or even must be); they design the future they’d like to create.

    As Steve Jobs would say, design is determining the size, shape and color of the dent you want to put in the universe. A background in liberal arts empowers you to make that dent stylish and desirable on levels that others may never understand; that’s how you make it look “easy” while they’re shaving costs and making compromises. Apple designs many products; they only begin building when all the pieces are present or it’s a stride that’s essential to making another product possible.

    I am thrilled, both with your article, and that you seem to speak from legitimate experience. I do hope to read more of your work.

  4. Great article. Bad title. I’m not sure if the columnist wrote the title so I’ll give him a pass on the incongruence.

  5. generic tadalafil from canada [url=http://tadalafil.trade/#]tadalafil online paypal[/url] tadalafil mexico price

  6. how to buy zithromax online [url=http://azithromycin.bar/#]buy zithromax[/url] buy zithromax online australia

  7. amoxicillin 500 mg price [url=https://amoxicillin.best/#]amoxicillin 500mg buy online uk[/url] amoxicillin 500 mg tablet price

  8. lisinopril 20 mg brand name [url=https://lisinopril.auction/#]prescription for lisinopril[/url] lisinopril 20 mg tablets

  9. doxycycline price compare [url=http://doxycycline.forum/#]buy doxycycline without prescription[/url] online doxycycline prescription

  10. medication from mexico pharmacy [url=https://mexicopharmacy.store/#]best online pharmacy[/url] medicine in mexico pharmacies

  11. buy drugs canada [url=https://ordermedicationonline.pro/#]Top mail order pharmacies[/url] safe canadian pharmacy

  12. miglior sito dove acquistare viagra [url=http://sildenafilit.bid/#]alternativa al viagra senza ricetta in farmacia[/url] viagra online consegna rapida

  13. pillole per erezioni fortissime [url=http://sildenafilit.bid/#]viagra online siti sicuri[/url] viagra pfizer 25mg prezzo

  14. comprare farmaci online con ricetta [url=http://kamagrait.club/#]kamagra oral jelly[/url] п»їfarmacia online migliore

  15. viagra originale in 24 ore contrassegno [url=http://sildenafilit.bid/#]sildenafil prezzo[/url] viagra ordine telefonico

  16. farmacias online seguras en espaГ±a [url=http://tadalafilo.pro/#]comprar cialis original[/url] farmacias baratas online envГ­o gratis

  17. farmacias online seguras [url=https://kamagraes.site/#]se puede comprar kamagra en farmacias[/url] farmacia barata

  18. Acheter mГ©dicaments sans ordonnance sur internet [url=https://cialissansordonnance.pro/#]cialis[/url] Acheter mГ©dicaments sans ordonnance sur internet

  19. Pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance [url=https://levitrafr.life/#]levitra generique prix en pharmacie[/url] Pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance

  20. versandapotheke deutschland [url=http://cialiskaufen.pro/#]online-apotheken[/url] gГјnstige online apotheke

  21. gГјnstige online apotheke [url=https://kamagrakaufen.top/#]kamagra oral jelly[/url] gГјnstige online apotheke

  22. п»їViagra kaufen [url=http://viagrakaufen.store/#]viagra kaufen ohne rezept legal[/url] Sildenafil 100mg online bestellen

  23. online apotheke gГјnstig [url=https://kamagrakaufen.top/#]kamagra oral jelly kaufen[/url] internet apotheke

  24. mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://mexicanpharmacy.cheap/#]reputable mexican pharmacies online[/url] mexican mail order pharmacies

  25. best online pharmacies in mexico [url=http://mexicanpharmacy.cheap/#]medicine in mexico pharmacies[/url] mexican drugstore online

  26. mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa [url=http://mexicanpharmacy.cheap/#]purple pharmacy mexico price list[/url] mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa

  27. best online pharmacy india [url=http://indiapharmacy.guru/#]reputable indian pharmacies[/url] Online medicine home delivery indiapharmacy.guru

  28. my canadian pharmacy rx [url=https://canadiandrugs.tech/#]pharmacy canadian[/url] best canadian online pharmacy canadiandrugs.tech

  29. canada pharmacy reviews [url=https://canadiandrugs.tech/#]the canadian pharmacy[/url] canadian pharmacy ltd canadiandrugs.tech

  30. pharmacy rx world canada [url=https://canadiandrugs.tech/#]onlinepharmaciescanada com[/url] canadian pharmacy price checker canadiandrugs.tech

  31. is canadian pharmacy legit [url=http://canadiandrugs.tech/#]reddit canadian pharmacy[/url] canadian pharmacy 24 canadiandrugs.tech

  32. cipro pharmacy [url=https://ciprofloxacin.life/#]ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online[/url] ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online

  33. prednisone 5 tablets [url=https://prednisone.bid/#]canada pharmacy prednisone[/url] buy prednisone without a prescription best price

  34. how to buy clomid [url=http://clomid.site/#]where to buy clomid tablets[/url] where to buy cheap clomid prices

  35. ciprofloxacin [url=http://ciprofloxacin.life/#]cipro online no prescription in the usa[/url] ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price

  36. can i buy amoxicillin online [url=https://amoxil.icu/#]amoxicillin tablets in india[/url] where can i buy amoxocillin

  37. world pharmacy india [url=http://indiapharm.llc/#]pharmacy website india[/url] buy medicines online in india indiapharm.llc

  38. п»їerectile dysfunction medication [url=https://edpillsdelivery.pro/#]cheapest ed pills[/url] cures for ed

  39. generic cialis tadalafil uk [url=http://tadalafildelivery.pro/#]cheap tadalafil canada[/url] tadalafil tablets

  40. mexico drug stores pharmacies [url=http://mexicanpharm.store/#]mexico drug stores pharmacies[/url] best online pharmacies in mexico

  41. buying drugs from canada [url=https://canadapharm.shop/#]trustworthy canadian pharmacy[/url] canadianpharmacymeds com

  42. buy prednisone online no script [url=http://prednisonepharm.store/#]prednisone online for sale[/url] prednisone 20

  43. ed meds online without doctor prescription [url=http://edwithoutdoctorprescription.store/#]cialis without doctor prescription[/url] best non prescription ed pills

  44. canadian pharmacy online without prescription [url=https://reputablepharmacies.online/#]legitimate canadian pharmacy[/url] cheapest drug prices

  45. canadian pharmacies selling viagra [url=https://reputablepharmacies.online/#]foreign online pharmacy[/url] global pharmacy plus canada

  46. canadian online pharmacy no prescription [url=https://reputablepharmacies.online/#]azithromycin canadian pharmacy[/url] canada pharmacy world

  47. buy prescription drugs from india [url=http://indianpharmacy.shop/#]Order medicine from India to USA[/url] cheapest online pharmacy india indianpharmacy.shop

  48. mexican drugstore online [url=http://mexicanpharmacy.win/#]best online pharmacies in mexico[/url] mexican drugstore online mexicanpharmacy.win

  49. top 10 pharmacies in india [url=https://indianpharmacy.shop/#]Cheapest online pharmacy[/url] india pharmacy indianpharmacy.shop

  50. top 10 pharmacies in india [url=https://indianpharmacy.shop/#]indian pharmacy[/url] indian pharmacy indianpharmacy.shop

  51. canadian pharmacies [url=http://canadianpharmacy.pro/#]Canadian pharmacy online[/url] canadianpharmacyworld canadianpharmacy.pro

  52. mexican pharmaceuticals online [url=http://mexicanpharmacy.win/#]Mexico pharmacy[/url] mexican pharmaceuticals online mexicanpharmacy.win

  53. mexican pharmaceuticals online [url=https://mexicanpharmacy.win/#]Medicines Mexico[/url] buying from online mexican pharmacy mexicanpharmacy.win

  54. Viagra pas cher livraison rapide france [url=http://viagrasansordonnance.pro/#]Viagra generique en pharmacie[/url] SildГ©nafil 100mg pharmacie en ligne

  55. Le gГ©nГ©rique de Viagra [url=http://viagrasansordonnance.pro/#]viagra sans ordonnance[/url] Viagra pas cher livraison rapide france

  56. Pharmacie en ligne France [url=https://acheterkamagra.pro/#]kamagra 100mg prix[/url] Pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance

  57. acheter mГ©dicaments Г  l’Г©tranger [url=https://cialissansordonnance.shop/#]cialis prix[/url] acheter medicament a l etranger sans ordonnance

  58. п»їpharmacie en ligne [url=http://levitrasansordonnance.pro/#]Levitra acheter[/url] Pharmacie en ligne fiable

  59. Prix du Viagra 100mg en France [url=https://viagrasansordonnance.pro/#]viagrasansordonnance.pro[/url] Viagra vente libre pays

  60. how to get zithromax over the counter [url=https://azithromycin.bid/#]how to get zithromax[/url] buy zithromax online with mastercard

  61. prednisone price australia [url=https://prednisonetablets.shop/#]50 mg prednisone tablet[/url] prednisone pill 10 mg

  62. 2.5 mg prednisone daily [url=https://prednisonetablets.shop/#]prednisone brand name india[/url] prednisone 20 mg tablets coupon

  63. cost of clomid for sale [url=http://clomiphene.icu/#]can i get cheap clomid no prescription[/url] can i purchase generic clomid without prescription

  64. canadian pharmacy meds reviews [url=https://canadianpharm.store/#]Canadian Pharmacy[/url] prescription drugs canada buy online canadianpharm.store

  65. mexican rx online [url=http://mexicanpharm.shop/#]Online Mexican pharmacy[/url] mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs mexicanpharm.shop

  66. canadian pharmacy 24 [url=http://canadianpharm.store/#]Canadian International Pharmacy[/url] canadian pharmacy reviews canadianpharm.store

  67. canadian pharmacy prices [url=https://canadianpharm.store/#]Canadian International Pharmacy[/url] canadian pharmacy meds review canadianpharm.store

  68. top 10 pharmacies in india [url=http://indianpharm.store/#]Indian pharmacy to USA[/url] indian pharmacy indianpharm.store

  69. canadian drugs [url=http://canadianpharm.store/#]Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US[/url] is canadian pharmacy legit canadianpharm.store

  70. reputable indian pharmacies [url=https://indianpharm.store/#]Indian pharmacy to USA[/url] buy medicines online in india indianpharm.store

  71. mexican mail order pharmacies [url=https://mexicanpharm.shop/#]Certified Pharmacy from Mexico[/url] buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexicanpharm.shop

  72. reputable indian online pharmacy [url=https://indianpharm.store/#]Indian pharmacy to USA[/url] reputable indian pharmacies indianpharm.store

  73. canadian pharmacies online reviews [url=http://canadadrugs.pro/#]buying prescription drugs canada[/url] canada pharmacy online no script

  74. canadian pharmaceuticals online [url=https://canadadrugs.pro/#]most reliable online pharmacies[/url] drugs without a prescription

  75. canadian online pharmacies legitimate by aarp [url=http://canadadrugs.pro/#]canadian pharmacy tadalafil[/url] great canadian pharmacy

  76. drugs from canada without prescription [url=http://canadadrugs.pro/#]canadian trust pharmacy[/url] pharmacy world

  77. legitimate canadian pharmacy online [url=https://canadianinternationalpharmacy.pro/#]canadian pharmacy king[/url] canadian pharmacy 24 com

  78. mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://certifiedpharmacymexico.pro/#]mexican rx online[/url] mexico pharmacy

  79. pharmacy wholesalers canada [url=https://canadianinternationalpharmacy.pro/#]my canadian pharmacy rx[/url] ed drugs online from canada

  80. india pharmacy mail order [url=http://medicinefromindia.store/#]best online pharmacy india[/url] buy medicines online in india

  81. online shopping pharmacy india [url=http://medicinefromindia.store/#]reputable indian pharmacies[/url] mail order pharmacy india

  82. ed meds online without doctor prescription [url=https://edwithoutdoctorprescription.pro/#]cialis without a doctor prescription canada[/url] viagra without a doctor prescription

  83. canadian neighbor pharmacy [url=http://canadianinternationalpharmacy.pro/#]canadianpharmacy com[/url] canadian pharmacy world

  84. reputable indian pharmacies [url=https://medicinefromindia.store/#]pharmacy website india[/url] best online pharmacy india