iBooks Author icon

Apple’s iBooks Author EULA Restriction is Dumb, Not Evil

Apple created a fair stir around the internet with a provision in the end-user license for its new iBooks Author software that requires that content created using the tool can only be sold through iTunes. ZDNet’s Ed Bott called the move “greedy and evil” while even the normally Apple-friendly John Gruber denounced it as “Apple at its worst.”

iBooks Author iconIn fact, that EULA language is merely stupid not evil. Apple is not asserting any sort of control over the contents of your book, just the formatted output of iBooks Author. That output can only be used to create an iBook and iBooks can only be sold through iTunes, so the language doesn’t actually create any restriction that isn’t already inherent in the software. Besides, no one has to use iBooks Author; there are other tools for creating iBooks.

But while the language of the Apple license may be ineffectual, it is not meaningless. In asserting this sort of control, Apple violated a longstanding principle of software: A program may not impose restrictions on the content it is used to create. Even the Free Software Foundation’s General Public License, in many ways one of the most restrictive licenses around,  doesn’t try to prevent conventional copyright terms on say, a book written using the GPL-licensed emacs editor. And certainly neither Microsoft nor Adobe has ever attempted any control on the output of Word or Photoshop. Tools should be just that; the uses of their output should be solely up to the creator (subject, as in the case of iBooks Author, to purely technical restrictions.)

Perhaps the best face you can put on this mess is Gruber’s interpretation: “Let’s hope this is just the work of an overzealous lawyer, and not [Apple’s] actual intention.”

Published by

Steve Wildstrom

Steve Wildstrom is veteran technology reporter, writer, and analyst based in the Washington, D.C. area. He created and wrote BusinessWeek’s Technology & You column for 15 years. Since leaving BusinessWeek in the fall of 2009, he has written his own blog, Wildstrom on Tech and has contributed to corporate blogs, including those of Cisco and AMD and also consults for major technology companies.

11 thoughts on “Apple’s iBooks Author EULA Restriction is Dumb, Not Evil”

  1. I agree it’s a dumb move by Apple – and hopefully they will address it quickly.

    For Apple to “revolutionize” the textbook industry it needs to address

    – textbooks in the cloud – these are often massive downloads 1/2GB – you don’t need to download the whole book – selective chapters are fine and will help manage storage on the iPad
    – subscription and rental models – the outright purchase model is problematic even at the reduce pricing , esp without resale being allowed. A well thought out rental model is needed. Likewise a subscription across content / publishers would be welcome – I’d like to be able to select content from multiple sources within a single subscription.

    However, the education market will not be revolutionized unless iPads and other tablets become affordable for the masses.

  2. This is an interesting topic. I think it brings up all kinds of important discussion points. Although I think Apple’s logic is somewhat similar to an SDK type mindset. If I use the Apple SDK for Mac or iOS then I am clearly developing software only for Macs or iOS. There is no point in me offering these for purchase for any other platform because the software won’t work.

    Perhaps this is the similar logic in that an iBook is only going to work with iBooks. This would of course be an entirely different story had Apple opened up their publishing platform as open source for anyone creating tablet or next gen e-reader to use. At that point, however, controlling the distribution method would be more difficult.

    Without certainty, I think this is how their logic is going. In that an iBook is a proprietary solution only available on iPad. Therefore it is being treated like an App from a purchasing and billing solution.

    What Amazon and others need to do is move quickly to release tool kits to do something similar. It will be a pain for authors to have to create two separate documents to publish, one on iPad and one Amazon or others. But that is how I see this playing out.

  3. From the wording used in the EULA and the fact that apple is a very litigious company with many lawyers it’s hard to imagine that they are just being “dumb.”

    It seems rather obvious that apple needs/wants a way to prevent people from putting ebooks on multiple platforms and therefore are making a grab at controlling the content–your “work.”

    Apple knows full well that within a short period there will be converters to convert the proprietary iBooks formatted ebook to any and every other ebook format, especially epub 3. So, that’s going to happen and apple can’t stop it however, they can stop the content from being uploaded/sold on another ebook store. Otherwise, this EULA makes no sense whatsoever.

    It seems clear to me that apple is attempting to ensure a complete locking of your “work” exclusive with them–not just the iBook formatted work but the entire “work.” They need a way to build iBooks ONLY and the only way to do that is to exert some control over the content–because you were stupid enough to upload to apple’s app store and used iBooks author they will have you–you agreed not to distribute to anyone else. Then when you do, they will simply send a letter to the other company and that company will pull your book–what are you going to do about it? Sue apple? yeah, sure you will. Worse yet, if they deem your book not acceptable it is doa–you can’t do anything with it because you were stupid enough to use iBooks Author and upload to the app store/iBooks and therefore giving apple “exclusive” rights to the “work.”


  4. To make CharmDate brides much more knowledgeable about that you actually are, compose a short self-description text. This will make your partner better. They will either have a condition that reveals their love for family pets or they will upload pictures with pet dogs, felines, rabbits, hedgehog, or any type of other animals they may have. Ultimately, if there are no public indications of animal love on the account of a certain CharmDate user, asking directly if they such as animals can likewise be a wonderful ice breaker! As a matter of fact, using CamShare to show their pet dogs as well as see the friends of other members is one more means to connect in a favorable spirit and have a wonderful time celebrating the existence of pets and also the pleasure of being honored with their company! Although girls must be commemorated on a daily basis, having an unique date to share themselves and receive additional support and great treatment is positive and also motivating! Does March 8th offer to present women, praise their appeal as well as take them out for dinner or is the purpose of this day deeper? Since 2006, Pet fans throughout the globe commemorate National Family pet Day on April 11. Animal proprietors utilize this holiday to commemorate the delight of having pet companions but its objective is additionally to bring awareness to countless dogs and pet cats that go into shelters every year.

    Some of the pets and also felines that go into shelters worldwide are strays, while others are abandoned by their owners or are confiscated in lawsuit. In some cases, they also obtain the pets of their pals to take them on strolls as well as obtain spotted or approached by numerous women who want to animal their dogs or ask concerns regarding them. Occasionally, pets can even assist companions solve concerns by being a subject they can discuss in all times or by snuggling with both of them. Later, they can speak to the chosen women and figure out which one is their ideal suit. Customers can additionally speak by means of email. It will surely lose several consumers if the business will certainly not function on it. That is why you will quickly browse it, even if you are not so tech-savvy. Participants can take advantage of enjoyable stickers, gifts, blossoms, and a series of functions that can make the celebration even much better. Thinking about that CharmDate mostly links Western men with women from Russia and also Ukraine, it is understandable that women from these nations will need a lot more assistance than common taking into consideration the susceptible time they are undergoing.

    It is believed that initially a group of females in Russia started a strike in 1917; they required bread, tranquility, and also the right to vote. March 8th was the date of the strike. Note that you can not change your name, date of birth, house country, and also international relationship status. Indicate your name, e-mail, sex, as well as date of birth. Just how much does Beauty Date Price? March 8th is a date noted under high value on the worldwide calendar of vacations! These additional questions on CharmDate are of fantastic relevance since these assistance the formula to locate the excellent match based on your tastes. For instance, if a guy is talking with a girl on a dating platform for the very first time on March 8th, he has a fantastic topic to start a conversation with. It has been running since 1998 and has established itself as a trustworthy platform for finding romantic matches. After completing the information above, click the locate me matches symbol to complete the registration procedure. The only information that can be altered is info that was submitted after registration.

    The registration on Charmdate recognize fairly quick. It’s efficient and also rapid to obtain and send mail from participants. CharmDate adopts numerous other fraud security steps to make certain that their women are real, such as binding terms and conditions on ladies’ carries out, a strict confirmation treatment before women accounts are uploaded on the site, close tracking of female profiles, regular tracking of document between members and also routine phone interviews with women directly. Surf countless top quality accounts and also pictures to find your compatible soul companion. You can select to ignore the subscription fee but that will deny you access to private pictures and also immediate customer assistance. Share your images and videos with others to confirm the reality of your words. It is possible to attach documents (photos, photos, video clips). CharmDate is suggesting its individuals to be gentlemen on this date; to make females feel special whatsoever feasible. On some events, your credit score card might be decreased for payment due to a number of possible factors: Void CCV – the CCV number is the last three numbers printed on the trademark strip on the back of the cardIncorrect expiry date.Card is overdrawn.There might be an abroad or Web block on the card – contact your releasing financial institution for more information.Single deal limit has been exceeded If you desire to use another credit rating card, please contact us.

  5. They are Scheduled Phone calls (make a visit with the individual you wish to call), Instantaneous Telephone calls (just speak to any kind of offered participant who selects up your phone call), and also the Call Me choice (helps you to identify your calls that can provide you a call). How to Disable the “Online” Alternative on AsiaMe? Is Asiame Safe to Utilize? Numerous members use AsiaMe; the bulk of men are from North and also South America, Europe, and Asia-Pacific. Females primarily come from Thailand, China, as well as Vietnam, while males – from Australia, the USA, as well as Canada. Its customers and customers cut all nationalities, but the ladies being an Eastern gives you a more details however vast overview for friendship. There is a Premium Membership attribute that unlocks all ladies’s images, offers you 20 minutes of complimentary conversation and five mails. Access to moderated online forums: This offers you accessibility to participate as well as check out in the regulated online forums.

    If another user got accessibility to your sensitive personal info or your photo, AsiaMe Disagreement Resolution Service will wait your side. The participants of the AsiaMe internet site can make use of filters to define their choices about a potential companion. Set up phone calls. To use this AsiaMe function, individuals need to make a consultation with the individual they agree to speak to. Male individuals can send blossoms and also gifts to AsiaMe ladies they like. Customers have to offer a legitimate contact number. There us a chat and a phone number. The website always displays the variety of members online. Call me. Thanks to this feature AsiaMe members can accredit who amongst the calls are able to call them. Like we discussed, most individuals who join this site are looking for long term dedication as well as marriage. We have actually located whole lots of positive endorsements from people who have actually located love by means of this platform. It is helpful for the brand-new website participants and also those who are new to online dating. Exactly how Does the AsiaMe Dating Website Job? The company began its job back in 1998. For the very first time, it was a small web site asiame review targeted at helping solitary males who intend to satisfy gorgeous women.

    They are incredibly preferred amongst western men as a result of their charming appearance as well as moderate nature. The ladies readjust search settings to view guys matching their tastes too. It means you can initiate a conversation with two individuals a day free of charge or send out passion to 2 girls. Today there are over a million registered individuals. Since there are no set regular monthly repayments, you have much better control over the quantity you invest on online dating. Furthermore, AsiaMe is concerned as a pioneer in the dating market. The accounts on AsiaMe are 100% real as well as come from Eastern ladies for dating and also their admirers. Likewise, you require to add a description of on your own and the women you desire to fulfill. Also, AsiaMe will supply you with extra login details. All these steps make sure that AsiaMe clients are real. Numerous customers leave favorable comments. Consumers need to supply utility bills, rental contracts, as well as various other documents. It is for security objectives and does not take way too much time. You can pick the wanted elevation, education and learning level, career, etc. These filters will certainly help you find your sweetie much faster. If you desire to locate an Eastern bride or partner, this is an ideal place to take off.

    This Eastern mail order bride-to-be service was established back in 1998. For greater than two decades, the dating platforms has actually been an incredible dating assistant to sine bachelors from Europe as well as the US. Besides the paid messaging solutions that can be bought with dating credits, the AsiaMe web site also provides premium membership with extra solutions. Yes, the Asiame internet site restores the costs membership of its individuals as soon as the repayment for subscriptions is made. You can begin using the website with no settlement. Press the Do It Currently button to start a survey on your dating assumptions, the sort of females you like one of the most, their age, routines, etc. The questionnaire contains 8 areas as well as begins with the kind of connection you seek. Afterwards, they are totally free to begin completing their account. To get even more sights and attract magnificent Asian ladies, you need to complete your profile. To verify your identity on the Asiame site, you need either a Passport or national identification card, or driver’s permit.

  6. How Doctors Can Care for Better

    27, 2023 When Ilene Kaplan felt a hard mass in her belly about 4 long ago, She feared the worst. A sonogram made a decision the lump was a cluster ofuterine fibroids, And Kaplan was relieved when her doctor assured her through shrink when she went into menopause, Without treatment.

    also Kaplan, A health coach on long island, ny, Soon had unbearable symptoms. the caretaker of three, who will be now 55, Felt like she was conceive a baby, With pelvic pushing pushing up into her ribs, And a swelling stomach that hindered her high high intensity workouts. Her monthly period flow volleyed between trickle and gush. She began peeing blood, Signaling aurinary tract issues.

    “i did not trust my body anymore, she says.

    the verification after seeing a urologist: Kaplan’s fibroids were shoving into her bladder, Making her unable to fully empty it and putting her susceptible to further UTIs. Not only was expecting menopause not feasible, But Kaplan also found that thereshuffling of hormones during perimenopause could enlarge her fibroids before shrinking them.

    When the same doctor who had prescribed inaction eventually suggested against a hysterectomy, Kaplan to be able to seek a second opinion from another OB/GYN. But the management of her became a years long ordeal, Much of which she spent in painful sensation.

    Whether selecting the best treatment for a female patient with a common condition, Or figuring out her with a serious condition, Doctors may benefit from actually talking to a women’s health center, states that Orli Etingin, m. d., Founder and medical director of theIris Cantor Women’s Health Center at NewYork Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell the hospital in New York City.

    “We consider ourselves part of a relatively recent movement. Most of us would gladly to get on the phone with somebody and discuss cases, she says. “We’re all happy to share speedily because we realize that promoting this helps us all not just as women, But as physicians and caregivers,

    Even for patients such as Kaplan which have a gynecologic issue, A holistic ways to latamdate scam treatment should be practiced, Etingin promises. Doctors should consider the patient’s pain levels, signs and symptoms, And male fertility goals, And how these things affect their health and fitness.

    “I think you should try for well trained, Multidisciplinary specialists to have chats together about patients, Because everyone’s case is going to be a little different, states.

    noisy. 1990s, Etingin moved forward from laboratory research in vascular biology at Weill Cornell Medical College to clinical practice, And ventured to a bit of women’s health meetings.

    “I was just struck with how primitive this field was, And how the assumption was that females are just miniature versions of men, states, jotting that “There was really no chance for what I would call very proactive prevention,

    gaining knowledge through Women’s Health Centers

    In Etingin’s time, A gynecologist would double as a doctor for a woman of childbearing age a woman may not see a proper primary care doctor until she was much older or had already developed a serious condition such as heart disease or cancer,All these different specialties together have enabled us to teach the next generation of doctors about this kind of comprehensive care, states. “We can provide one location for the bulk of a woman’s health needs,

    now a days, Women’s health centers inside are common, From independent clinics to those linked to academic companies and major hospital systems.

    Juliette your current, m. d., Is a analysis radiologist at theChristine E. Lynn Women’s Health Wellness company, Part of Boca Raton local Hospital, In fl. Although she centers on breast imaging, The says the institute’s collaborative soul helps her treat “all of the woman,

    “We can help each other out on difficult cases, Or just routine cases, she says. for example, She meets weekly with members of a breast cancers patient’s care team, From oncologist to chicago plastic surgeon.

    “We discuss what the best treatment for her is, And sometimes it’s not relatively easy, But we always have a really good discussion on what would be a great way, she says.

    Successes of women’s health centers include increased access to care for a more diverse patient population and expanded research business opportunities for providers, to be able to a 2022 review in theJournal of Women’s Health. Groups such as theSociety for Women’s Health Research say the continuing adoption of this bird’s eye view of a woman’s health hinges on doctors’ universal grasp of something far smaller:Sex differences at your bodies cells.

    eliminating Bias With Biology

    The historical exclusion of women from clinical research has led to gaps in how much doctors know about how a condition affects women, as mentioned in toIrene Aninye, phd, Chief science officer of the Society for Women’s Health Research in new york, dc. And the less doctors be aware of regarding how sex influences a disease, the extra likely that condition is to be underdiagnosed or mistreated.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *