BlackBerry Implosion: A Postmortem

In the past few days, the true extent of BlackBerry’s perilous position in the market has become clear, but the future for the company is cloudier than ever. The company plans to lay off another 40% of its staff, consumer device sales are being halted (or not – “prosumer” sales will continue), and the board of directors said it would consider offers for all or portions of the company. When BlackBerry’s stock cratered at the news, Fairfax Financial Holdings, its largest shareholder – and controlled by a former BlackBerry board member – put in a bid to stop the price from cratering further. We’ll see if other bids are forthcoming or if Fairfax actually buys BlackBerry (it can walk away any time during the next month of due diligence).

I’ve been tracking BlackBerry closely for over a decade as an analyst, and while everyone agrees that BlackBerry didn’t react quickly enough to Apple, there were three main reasons why it reacted so slowly. RIM, Nokia, Microsoft, and Palm all dismissed Apple’s entry in January 2007. This was partly understandable in 2007 when RIM was aimed at business users and the iPhone did not support corporate email. Google was the only player to see the iPhone for what it would become, and Google quickly changed Android’s UI from a variation on BlackBerry and Windows Phone to a touch-driven experience. RIM’s oversight was less forgivable in 2008 when RIM had launched the Pearl targeting consumers, and the iPhone got Exchange support, moved to a subsidized model, and announced the App Store. Verizon Wireless – iPhoneless at the time – handed RIM a prime opportunity to catch up in late 2008, but the BlackBerry Storm grafted a poor touch experience onto an OS designed for a scroll wheel. It was also a buggy mess. RIM only moved to create a modern, touch-first mobile OS in 2012, and phones finally shipped this year. By that time, it was too late – its high end users had moved to iOS, and its Curve sales were being decimated by cheap Android phones running WhatsApp.

What Went Wrong? There were three main factors:

  1. 1. NTP. When BlackBerry could have been designing breakthrough consumer-oriented BlackBerries just before the iPhone launched, RIM management was not focused on creating a browser and app-centric mobile experience – they were consumed with fighting a patent lawsuit from NTP. The fight was clearly personal to RIM management, and it took an enormous amount of time and attention away from running the business. The resulting line of consumer BlackBerries were just BlackBerries with a media player and a camera grafted on. They sold well, but did not position BlackBerry to succeed as the market shifted and expanded.
  2. 2. BBM. Once Apple started decimating RIM’s core prosumer user base in North America, BlackBerry sales and profits did not decline – they rose. RIM had lucked into a BBM frenzy in Europe and emerging markets, where consumers bought BlackBerries to save money on messaging. From 2009 – 2012, BBM’s success masked underlying problems in its business, and RIM further failed to realize that this windfall would soon be under severe margin constraints. Cheap Android phones running free messaging apps were more attractive than (relatively) pricey BlackBerries – and Android had a richer ecosystem of apps and services beyond messaging that BlackBerry couldn’t match.
  3. 3. Management. RIM’s senior management suffered from a truly epic case of founder’s syndrome. For years, people told RIM CEO Mike Lazaridis that what he was trying to do was impossible. RIM was successful anyway, and then financial analysts and the tech press switched to predicting that RIM would be crushed by Microsoft or Nokia. When the real wolf was at the door, Lazaridis and his co-CEO Jim Balsillie ignored it. As late as 2012, RIM actually diverted resources from BlackBerry 10 to push out a new, and not completely compatible, version of its old OS! BlackBerry management did not even prioritize phones for its new OS, launching BlackBerry 10 half-finished on the BlackBerry PlayBook. The PlayBook bombed, and BlackBerry 10 only appeared on a phone a year later (and without a critical mass of high quality apps). When Lazaridis and Balsillie stepped down, they did so unwillingly, and installed an insider to continue their strategy. New CEO Thorsten Heins genuinely did not believe that there was anything wrong at first, showing how out of touch and insular the management team was. Heins did eventually realize that things were dire, but under his watch, BlackBerry produced a horrific Z10 marketing and launch plan, and produced nearly a billion dollars of excess Z10 inventory.

Published by

Avi Greengart

Avi is the Research Director for Consumer Devices at Current Analysis. He is responsible for the Mobile Devices and Digital Home Devices groups, including CurrentCOMPETE (market, company, event, and device competitive analysis) and Wireless Tracking (pricing, promotions, availability, and device feature data and analysis) content.

1,034 thoughts on “BlackBerry Implosion: A Postmortem”

  1. I vaguely remember that because of the dire need for experienced managers due to its explosive growth, RIM took on a lot of people from the defunct (i.e. pre-SBC acquisition) AT&T. Admittedly, this is just conjecture now, but getting managers from an old line regulated utility with its bureaucratic mindset to run a start-up type tech company seems to be a grievous mistake. Can’t help thinking that way given how looooong it took RIM to recognize the threat and then move to address it. I mean from the outside looking in, everything they did after the iPhone came out was a day late and a mite slow.

  2. Clayton Christensen would be very happy with RIM’s demise and played right into his theory.

    I doubt the same theory works for Apple but let’s see what the future holds.

  3. This is going to turn into a great business case for MBA students ala the Kodak case. RIM will turn into a company sold into parts with their patents going to the highest bidder. In business school, my team analyzed RIM and we knew that QNX and the Playbook had to be a homerun otherwise the company would go under. They needed to license BBM and their enterprise servers and encryption technology to other companies. Well BBM is now downloadable for free. Too little, too late. BB should have created devices with Android. Yes it would have competed with their own QNX O/S but at least they would have remained relevant as a device manufacturer. The exec board was too short sighted to see the forest through the trees. Nice write up Avi.

    1. “BB should have created devices with Android.”

      Knowing RIM, I don’t think BlackBerry ever really considered that. Guaranteeing security at the OS level was too ingrained, whether customers valued it or not.

  4. Fantastic blog! Do you have any tips and hints for aspiring writers? I’m planning to start my own site soon but I’m a little lost on everything. Would you propose starting with a free platform like WordPress or go for a paid option? There are so many choices out there that I’m completely overwhelmed .. Any suggestions? Cheers!

  5. Thanks for your article. I would like to say that the health insurance broker also works well with the benefit of the actual coordinators of your group insurance policy. The health insurance broker is given an index of benefits sought by someone or a group coordinator. What any broker may is find individuals or even coordinators which best fit those requirements. Then he provides his ideas and if both sides agree, the particular broker formulates binding agreement between the 2 parties.

  6. If you’re new to no deposit bonuses, then you might need more info on them before claiming one. Luckily, a no deposit bonus is exactly what it sounds like. It’s free credits or free bonus money given to you by an online casino. Unlike other casino offers, you don’t need to deposit your own cash to claim a no deposit bonus. Sounds pretty sweet, right? Unibet Online Casino provides a diverse selection of games, a seamless mobile experience, top-notch security, and 24 7 customer support. Remember to review the terms and conditions and take advantage of the various resources available to promote responsible gaming. Don’t miss out on this incredible opportunity to elevate your online casino adventure with Unibet Casino. Sign up today by clicking ➡️ here ⬅️ and let the games begin!
    We talked about the early slot games released in the 2000s. These games were little more than digital replicas of the popular fruit machines that dominate the casinos. Still, they were a smash hit and led to the popularization of the iGaming market. Soon, blackjack, baccarat, and roulette games were all available at most online casinos’ libraries. Copyright © 2022 Evolution AB (publ). All rights reserved. DOWNLOAD THE MY LIVE! REWARDS® APP Live online casinos have various games that are good for players. Real casino dealers run these games and stream them live to players so they can play live dealer games and enjoy a real gambling experience without leaving their homes. Here are some of the most famous online live casino games: Read on to find out more about live dealer games and discover five of the most popular types of live dealer games you can play, how they work and tips on how to play. We also offer some general tips on etiquette when playing live dealer games.

  7. Thank you for another magnificent article.

    The place else may anybody get that kind of info in such an ideal
    means of writing? I’ve a presentation subsequent week, and
    I am on the search for such info.

  8. Definitely imagine that which you said. Your favourite justification seemed
    to be at the web the simplest thing to bear in mind of.
    I say to you, I certainly get irked whilst people consider issues that they just don’t understand about.
    You managed to hit the nail upon the highest and also defined out the entire
    thing with no need side-effects , other folks can take a signal.

    Will likely be back to get more. Thank you

  9. Hi would you mind letting me know which hosting company
    you’re using? I’ve loaded your blog in 3 completely different browsers and I must say this blog
    loads a lot faster then most. Can you suggest a good hosting provider at a reasonable price?
    Thanks a lot, I appreciate it!

  10. You can read another review of the available Ruby Slots no deposit codes at bonuspromocode ruby-slots-no-deposit-bonus-codes . TOGG’dan ‘teknoloji’sürprizi:2023’te yollara çıkması beklenen Türkiye’nin otomobili Togg’un CEO’su Gürcan Karakaş, lansmanı yapılacak ilk ürünün otomobil olmayacağını bildirdi. Karakaş, ‘Şu ana kadar… Trabzon’da ‘şampiyonluk’ biletleri karaborsaya düştü: En ucuzu 30 bin TL! 11 SpinLogic Gaming Casinos are giving away 288% Deposit … Trabzon’da ‘şampiyonluk’ biletleri karaborsaya düştü: En ucuzu 30 bin TL! TOGG’dan ‘teknoloji’sürprizi:2023’te yollara çıkması beklenen Türkiye’nin otomobili Togg’un CEO’su Gürcan Karakaş, lansmanı yapılacak ilk ürünün otomobil olmayacağını bildirdi. Karakaş, ‘Şu ana kadar…
    Any information provided is subject to our Privacy Policy *Excludes all alcohol and tobacco sales. Excludes consignment items in gift shops. Does not apply when using the Wind Creek Promo Gift Card. Not available through all third-party outlets. Discount does apply at Wind Creek Atmore Spa and Entertainment Center. As mentioned earlier, BetRivers casino’s game lobby features hundreds of games. It is powered by some of the biggest studios including Pragmatic Play, NetEnt, Habanero, and more. You’ll find no slot BetRivers casino online slots game types missing in this lobby. All of them come for free and of course, you can also play them for real money and with a BetRivers slots bonus. Casino4Fun is a play-for-fun, entertainment only. The games do not offer “real money gambling” or an opportunity to win real money or prizes. Practice or success at social casino gaming does not imply future success at “real money gambling.”The games are intended for an adult audience. Must be 21+. Gambling problem?