Photo of empty lecture hall (© SeanPavonePhoto - Fotolia.com)

Education and the Future of MOOCs

Photo of empty lecture hall (© SeanPavonePhoto - Fotolia.com)

Maybe online course aren’t going to remake the face of higher education after all.

After a fast start, reality seems to be closing in on the world of the massive, open, online courses that were supposed to replace traditional lectures and recitations and make free, or at least very cheap, higher education available to everyone. San Jose State University has slowed down a move to deliver introductory undergraduate courses through MOOC provider Udacity.

Udacity itself, one of several MOOC providers that have sprung up in the last couple of years, is refocusing its activities on corporate training. Sebastian Thrun, Stanford computer scienctist and founder of Udacity, told Fast Company,  “We were on the front pages of newspapers and magazines, and at the same time, I was realizing, we don’t educate people as others wished, or as I wished. We have a lousy product. It was a painful moment.”

No surprise. I’m not surprised. I’ve been a skeptical enthusiast for online education since MIT started its Open Courseware initiative a few years back, and over the last year or so, I have enrolled in several offerings, mostly from Coursera, like Udacity, a for-profit provider of open courses. My experience has been a very mixed bag, but one that has taught me a lot about where the approach does and doesn’t work. A couple of general observations. First, the technology has a long way to go and on one seems to have figured out a completely effective way to deliver lectures on video. I’ve seen a number of approaches, from video recording regular blackboard lectures, to slide-based presentations in which the instructor only occasionally appears, to a course that used cartoony “virtual students” to asked questions in computer synthesized voices.  None worked completely, though the last was the most annoying. Online lectures today remind me of the earliest days of television, when shows were “radio with pictures.” No one has quite cracked the medium yet.

Second, and more important, MOOCs seem to work best for those who need them least. Most surveys of those who enroll,  in MOOCS and especially those who complete them–typically no more than 5% to 10% of the original enrollees–tend to be people who already have undergraduate degrees and often more. “If you’re looking to really move the needle on fundamental educational problems, inside and outside the United States, you’re going to need to help people reach the first milestone, which is getting their degrees to begin with,” Daphne Koller, a founder of Coursera, told The Chronicle of Higher EducationMy experience is that MOOCs require very highly motivated students. It can be very easy to slough off, fall behind, and drop out. You have paid little or nothing, so there’s little at stake.[pullquote]If you’re looking to really move the needle on fundamental educational problems … you’re going to need to help people reach the first milestone, which is getting their degrees to begin with.”–Daphne Koller, Coursera[/pullquote]

Where MOOCs work. MOOCs work best for the sort of course that mainly consists of transferring information. I am finishing up a Coursera course in basic financial accounting, taught by Professor Brian J. Bushee of the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School. I signed up because I had just become treasurer of a non-profit and was embarked on a project of getting improved financial reporting for better decision support. Accounting isn’t the world’s most interesting subject and this wasn’t a terribly interesting class. But it gave me the knowledge I was looking for. Introductory accounting is a very good subject for online training: It consists mostly of a lot of sometimes arbitrary rules and how to apply them. And it lends itself well to effective multiple-choice evaluations. (This, however, was the course with the annoying virtual students.)

In a similar vein, I took an introduction to cryptography course from Stanford Professor Dan Boneh. Again, I though the course succeeded because it focused on straightforward information, not deep ideas. It was mostly aimed at teaching programmers what to do, and probably more important, not do, when implementing encryption, Some of the concepts were quite difficult and I thought that multiple choice evaluation was not terribly satisfactory; questions with longer free-response answers would have been much better. But the need to keep costs down drives machine-scorable evaluations.

The big surprise was a another Penn-Coursera course, Calculus: Single Variable, taught by Professor Robert Ghrist. This was not  standard freshman calculus course; the course description suggested prior familiarity with introductory calculus. Ghrist took a fresh, almost idiosyncratic approach to a familiar subject (he focuses heavily on Taylor series and included a week on discrete calculus, a subject rarely touched in an introductory course.) Above all, he showed that multiple choice or numerical answer questions could be both interesting and challenging. This is the course to watch for anyone who wants to see how to do it.

A disappointment. My biggest disappointment was a course called Introduction to Mathematical Thinking taught by Professor Keith Devlin of Stanford. Devlin is a distinguished mathematician and an excellent lecturer, but this Coursera project was tedious. The lectures consisted mainly of him talking while writing, a sort of online version of the blackboard talk, but it did not work well for me. My biggest problem was that the problem sets, which I expected to deal with ideas, consisted mainly of slogging my way through endless truth tables. And Devlin’s attempt at supplement machine scoring with peer evaluations just did not work (In fairness, I took the course the first time it was offered; Devlin has taught it a couple times since and it may well have improved.)

There’s no question that the rising cost of higher education is a big challenge to U.S. society and that the inefficiency of the current system is a big contributor. But MOOCs as they exist today do not seem to be the answer, or at least not more than a small part of the answer.

 

 

Published by

Steve Wildstrom

Steve Wildstrom is veteran technology reporter, writer, and analyst based in the Washington, D.C. area. He created and wrote BusinessWeek’s Technology & You column for 15 years. Since leaving BusinessWeek in the fall of 2009, he has written his own blog, Wildstrom on Tech and has contributed to corporate blogs, including those of Cisco and AMD and also consults for major technology companies.

42 thoughts on “Education and the Future of MOOCs”

    1. taruhan slot online terbaik. Inilah alasan mengapa member kami paling sering memainkan permainan slot online ini karena merupakan satu-satunya permainan slot online yang menjamin jackpot terus menerus dengan jumlah yang bervariasi di tahun 2024. Perlu pemain ketahui bahwa ada beberapa agen taruhan online yang tidak berani memberikan jackpot. . terus menerus.CHEAT SLOT satu-satunya link yang pasti menawarkan jackpot terus menerus. Kami berkomitmen untuk memberikan pengalaman bermain terbaik bagi seluruh pemain kami, terbukti dari ciri-ciri agen slot online terbaik kami seperti lisensi, reputasi, kecepatan deposit dan bonus. Untuk informasi lebih jelas, Anda dapat mengunjungi website kami CHEAT SLOT merupakan situs game online terbesar se asia yang memberikan jackpot
      besar setiap hari.

  1. Saya sangat terkesan dengan kualitas dan ketajaman yang disajikan dalam postingan ini. Sungguh tidak umum menemukan tulisan yang tidak hanya mencerahkan, tetapi juga merangsang. Kemampuan penulis dalam membangun argumen yang kompleks dengan cara yang sangat mudah diakses dan mengikat adalah extraordiner. Setiap segmen mencerminkan pengetahuan mendalam tentang subjek dan devosi sejati terhadap tema. Saya mengucapkan selamat atas kemampuan luar biasa Anda dalam berkomunikasi dan karena telah berkontribusi secara sangat penting untuk pengertian kita tentang topik ini. Saya tidak sabar untuk menyerap lebih banyak ide Anda dan konsep selanjutnya!

  2. In the grand scheme of things you secure an A for hard work. Where exactly you confused everybody was on all the particulars. You know, people say, the devil is in the details… And it couldn’t be more true right here. Having said that, allow me say to you precisely what did work. Your article (parts of it) is extremely powerful and that is probably the reason why I am taking the effort to comment. I do not make it a regular habit of doing that. Second, while I can notice a leaps in logic you come up with, I am not certain of just how you seem to connect your details which in turn make the actual final result. For now I shall subscribe to your position but wish in the near future you link the dots better.

  3. Wow, this blog is like a rocket blasting off into the galaxy of excitement! The thrilling content here is a thrilling for the imagination, sparking awe at every turn. Whether it’s lifestyle, this blog is a goldmine of inspiring insights! #AdventureAwaits into this cosmic journey of knowledge and let your imagination fly! ✨ Don’t just enjoy, experience the excitement! will thank you for this exciting journey through the dimensions of discovery!

  4. The comments demonstrate that the audience finds the content of this post to be insightful and thought-provoking. The positive feedback suggests that the post has resonated well with its readers.

  5. Wow, this blog is like a fantastic adventure soaring into the universe of endless possibilities! The captivating content here is a captivating for the mind, sparking excitement at every turn. Whether it’s technology, this blog is a goldmine of exciting insights! #InfinitePossibilities into this cosmic journey of imagination and let your thoughts roam! Don’t just explore, savor the excitement! #FuelForThought Your brain will thank you for this exciting journey through the worlds of awe!

  6. It’s clear from the comments that the audience finds the content of this post to be relevant and helpful. The positive feedback highlights the effectiveness of the content in addressing the audience’s needs and interests.

  7. Users are expressing gratitude for the valuable information shared in this post. The positive feedback highlights the effectiveness of the content in addressing the audience’s needs and interests.

  8. Online lottery has become a very popular game among Indonesian people. However, to achieve big wins in this game, you need to have an effective strategy. In this guide, we will provide tips and tricks that can help you increase your chances of winning when playing official online lottery and always be at an advantage today. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information about today’s most popular news this year. For more detailed information, please visit our website for further information 8499225.cc

  9. It’s clear from the comments that the audience finds the content of this post to be relevant and helpful. The positive feedback highlights the effectiveness of the content in addressing the audience’s needs and interests.

  10. Impressive piece! The article is well-structured and informative. Adding more visuals in your future articles could be a great way to enrich the reader’s experience.

  11. The best online lottery bookie which is one of the largest official online lottery bookie sites which is widely known among the best online lottery lovers. With a solid reputation, online lottery bookies provide a safe and reliable lottery playing experience. As an official online lottery bookie. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information about today’s most popular news this year. For more detailed information, please visit our website for further information Togel Server Internasional

    1. Seperti yang sudah kami bahas sebelumnya, permainan slot pragmatic play paling populer di TRIBUNTOGEL situs taruhan slot online terbaik. Inilah alasan mengapa member kami paling sering memainkan permainan slot online ini karena merupakan satu-satunya permainan slot online yang menjamin jackpot terus menerus dengan jumlah yang bervariasi di tahun 2024. Perlu pemain ketahui bahwa ada beberapa agen taruhan online yang tidak berani memberikan jackpot. . terus menerus.TRIBUNTOGEL satu-satunya link yang pasti menawarkan jackpot terus menerus. Kami berkomitmen untuk memberikan pengalaman bermain terbaik bagi seluruh pemain kami, terbukti dari ciri-ciri agen slot online terbaik kami seperti lisensi, reputasi, kecepatan deposit dan bonus. Untuk informasi lebih jelas, Anda dapat mengunjungi website kami TRIBUNTOGEL adalah situs game online terbesar di Asia yang menyediakan jackpot
      besar setiap har informasi lebih jelas bisa kunjungi diwebsite kami TRIBUNTOGEL merupakan situs gameonline terbesar se asia yang memberikan jackpot
      besar setiap hari.

  12. Bravo on the article! The content is insightful, and I’m curious if you plan to add more images in your upcoming pieces. It could enhance the overall reader experience.

  13. The list of Gacor slot leaks is the most awaited thing for slot site player fans, there are several names of the most famous slots that have high win rates. There are 10 best slot games that can be accessed every day wherever you are. Thank you for the information about today’s most popular news this year. For more detailed information, please visit our website for further information Tribuntogel

  14. Enjoy the experience of playing the best online slot sites with original themes and culture from the current Gacor slot game agent, which always provides the opportunity to win big. You can win free payments and take advantage of various profitable jackpot features in each Gacor slot game which is provided so completely. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information about today’s most popular news this year. For more detailed information, please visit our website for further information Tribuntogel

  15. The Sedaptogel Login online slot game has now become an effective win for players. Each site always presents Gacor slot game agents who are very well known and also experienced in presenting the newest and most complete slot games currently. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information about today’s most popular news this year. For more detailed information, please visit our website for further information Sedaptogel

  16. As a slot game agent, Gacor is another name for the provider on the online slot site. This slot provides a variety of the best slot games that are very effective for current gacor slot game lovers to play. This slot site always presents various unique wins that can create the best experience for online slot game players today. I really like it, and I look forward to hearing from you next. Thank you for the information about today’s most popular news this year. For more detailed information, please visit our website for further information Mez.ink dorahoki

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *