News Corp. Chief Operating Officer Chase Carey’s threat to pull the Fox network from the airwaves if Aereo wins its legal battle to retransmit over-the-air TV signals without paying for them is probably nothing more than bluster. But the fact that he could make such a threat with a straight face, and in front of the National Association of Broadcasters, no less, is a clear indication that the end of TV as we have known it is approaching.
The broadcast networks, especially Fox and the old big three of ABC, CBS, and NBC–are still tremendously important players in the TV world. Far more people watch their content than any of the cable-only channels. They still dominate news and live sports (though ESPN and to a lesser extent Fox have made significant inroads in the latter).
But over-the-air is no longer how they reach most of their viewers. And while we still think of broadcast TV as ad-supported, the retransmission consent fees paid by cable carriers–and avoided by Aereo–have become a tremendously important source of revenue to local stations. In a sense, they already are pay TV stations from the point of view of most viewers, and that is why Carey’s threat is not an empty one.
What would it mean if over-the-air broadcast TV disappeared? For one thing, we could forget about the hideously complex incentive auction now being planned by the FCC to free a bit of the prime spectrum now occupied by TV stations for wireless data use and just turn the whole thing over to wireless.
Some of the more interesting consequences would be for politicians. Members of Congress depend on local stations to keep their names and faces in front of voters, especially as local newspapers fade away. Politicians are also the beneficiary of regulations that require local stations to sell advertising to candidates for federal office at the lowest rates they charge any customer. In fact, if stations stopped broadcasting over the air, the Federal Communications Commission would lose essentially all ability to regulate their content, rates, or much of anything else.
Even the most anti-regulation Republican doesn’t really want that to happen. That’s why Carey’s real audience may have been Congress. If Aereo wins in court, as seems increasingly likely, the broadcasters are likely to turn to Congress for relief. Carey’s statement was likely a shot across the bow in that fight.
But history has shown us that depending on favorable treatment from government to save you from the forces of change can work, but only for a little while. The times they are a-changing for television.
“If stations stopped broadcasting over the air, the Federal Communications Commission would lose essentially all ability to regulate their content, rates, or much of anything else.”
To whatever extent content creators put their content online exclusively, the FCC doesn’t regulate it now. And if the proliferation of online delivery continues (which presumably it will) we could eventually reach a point where *most* content is not regulated by the FCC. A new government regulating agency might then be required.
Other than the loss of being able to receive free TV by the percentage of the population that isn’t in a financial position to pay for cable, I’m not sure I’d be sorry if stations stopped broadcasting over the air, because the spectrum now occupied by TV stations could then be donated to wireless. I’d very much like to see that happen.
Looking at the situation with a long-term view, I see OTA TV broadcasting as a holdover from a past technology, and wireless (meaning cellphones, tablets and the like) as a major present and future social phenomenon that needs all the spectrum we can provide it. Maybe I’m missing something, but I don’t really see why we need OTA TV broadcasting ten years from now, except for the people who can’t afford cable.
We’re going to end up with some sort of lifeline broadband service for low-income people (this already exists for landline phones and is being extended to wireless phones) and since television is moving from conventional cable to over-the-top anyway, this can double as lifeline TV service.
The regulatory issues are harder. A whole regulatory structure is built on the elaborate legal fiction that the airwaves are merely lent to broadcasters who are required, in the words of the 1927 Radio Act, to use them for “the public convenience and necessity.” This gives the government power to regulate broadcast content that it does not have over any other media and limits the first amendment rights of broadcasters (Red Lion v. FCC). Because of this situation, if the government loses its regulatory hooks over broadcasters, it cannot simply reestablish them with new legislation.
In most contexts, broadcasters will argue that they really do own their licenses because almost no license holders are the same entities who originally received the free use of the spectrum. In fact, the fiction serves the interests of both broadcasters and government and I expect them to fight to preserve the status quo even as it becomes increasingly wasteful and irrelevant. (For a lesson in how this works, see the history of how broadcasters delayed the digital transition, hung on to the extra spectrum they were granted for far longer than necessary, and more recently have effectively gutted the incentive auctions.)
The Internet is such an inexorable force for change that I think eventually most content will be consumed online, independently of laws and contracts from the past. What happens then, with the situation you described?
As long as the content is broadcast over the air–even if no one watches it–the government retains its regulatory authority. As it is, probably less than 20% of the broadcast audience is watching over-the-air. If they give up their broadcast licenses, though, the control ends.
To put it another way, the broadcasters represent the past, and one thing I’ve observed is that no one can stop technological change. The most they can do is delay it.
The movement online has already started.
Excellent article! We will be linking to this particularly great article on our website. Keep up the good writing.
I do not even understand how I ended up here but I assumed this publish used to be great
Some really excellent info, Sword lily I detected this.
Fathes andd teen daughtersVintaye jonathan annd david nativity setGalactorrhnea breast discharge in heathy non preegnant womenWman havinjg anawl
seex with menBiig boob girls caught peeperComic strip orphan donniMature gay truckerrs
erfotic storiesAskjoliee milfVintag cadilpac adsFucking
hispaniic spanish xxx movies free dick ass titsCum in mouth deepthroatMega cock pussyFucck ganhg lesbianSaffrkn s nakedProstate surgery peenis shrinkageFeat
ljck many mp3 sisqoBeckyy loces blaxk cockSsbbw fuckedAsian thumbbs free moviesOh my goddess hentaiLas vegas aadult theaterOldd bloiw jobEritic stgory lost
wagerDailymotion nakwd pussy japaneseHot think cockTrue gaay
sex confessionsI watched him cum in mmy wiofe pussySluut
moms tubeClosed sexStriup toysBilli piper breastsWinniipeeg sexx servicesAmaeur slut gloiry hope wivesDo all womenn orgasmJeanie ppepper
bioo dvdd pornViddeo sexsy indianRussian ndist family’sFrree deess up sitees ffor teensXxxx cartuns videosLesbian bachelorette party orgyActor johhn mqrshall
ones nudeTeeen wett t shirt galleryBareback sex stroiescomStripp clu ceress caSamanhtha sunshine stripperKorea pornGiirl cauggt by dadd flashijg titsWhere can i podt nudeBeth egoi klingensmith sexSex sriies
bcl naked Cock puwsy junle
videosFrernch pussy youngCliit vieo instrucxtional freeVirgin tewens pussyHallf naaked
girrl picturesGaay fuun places inn indianaRaw viudeo nudeBlohde sex virginGay llesbian chrous festivazl
2008Shemale jjizz powered by vbulletinFemalee airy armpitGirl secrets cock crazy10 blopwjob mistakes evewry women makesDoess wearing a bbra stunt breat growthEsdorts en hidalgoStreet meat asiaa potn tgpVieddos of boys fucoing
young girlsPlasic wtap lwsbian bondgageBiggest ass iin theworldFreee ladie oold
sexGay bathhouses rverside san bernardinoBeauty parlr bondageCave adlt comicBrjtany pussyNude cceleb ppics fakesNudde sexx artBoob mkvie vidsNo titss asianMature clssy skut videoAnal sex downloadsBbw
lagina bootyBrittay pic seex spear tapeStepped bottomAcnee fwcial scxar productInterracial couples comparisonLondon escort danikaInddia masssage wokan xxxAss kiss photoBrewers yeast for breast milkWholesae
aduult dvdd xxxAsss cuum evbery fck herr hole inFreee innocent yong een picsFreee asiasn babe picsTinyy
teens nuse beachBeaar naksd black currantsJafes free nudeLosig virginmity oon yoou
tubeCan you desensitize thhe penisBruan houlihann femdomOsaka69 tgpBlonde escot natural breeast londonFreee porn thumvs oof bloody pussyWhere tto download black pornVitage
cadillac autoFantsiia seex tapeTeenn girls shower voyeurKarup tinny
teenCloyd breastsFemawil ofife asisetent youu pornBigg mmoms aass fuccked videoCarrie annn annd tewen riley masonErotic hermaphrrodite picturesFrst
lesbian sexSex scenes dvdBrast impant augmentation cosmetic plasyic suhrgeon directoryHockey player dick bainDeefiniton off cumYou pon slut wifeNudee wwomen giving birthChristmas acitivity for adultsPorrn vidreo
cookie jarBrunette modsl pussyStrrip searchmoviesNude carla ossaThumb sucking cessationAlygse creampie gangbangCoole sprouse dickBreast cncer coinsMarvelous boobsPornhujb tits teacherLesbo on guysJunios nude coeaning serviceMature over 40 auntTonyy tqtum sexx offenderHeatger annd tommy leee nudeTopleess amaateurs videosChord overstreet
naked fakeJikmy nneutron toon sexFuck ddem other hoes mp3Sexy
funn christmas letters fom santaBuuffalo breast screeningNudde
famous british modelsYouthbuild u s vigin islands programChols andd cholzs fuckingBarian annd
thee geishaFibfo menikngioma breastNatalie ortman seex clipsHardcor hormy housewivesBlack spot oon vaginaRain adultArianbna jjollie blackcock gangbangPornn exkimo100 tranvestite galleriesFacialks in canton ohioRooms tto ggo teenLeesbo harcore sexAfraid oof tthe dark teenLaana lillpy sonya stripper sydneyJessida simpson’s
breats picsGay and lesbian ageingList of foteign porn sitesSpanked
tears 2010 jelsft enterprises ltdShemazle pic which have captionsBlck tits
long nipplesHusbaznd annd wife mawturbate eawch otherSluts blackRon moaned as shego sucked hisProboems wuh brreast implantsSex wandaVeryy young girls doing pornCallaham enhanced vintageSouthamerican mexican penis precum foreskinNyc area
esort servicesBest nsked girls picturesNaomi porfman nudeMature
women hving sex wit shemaleDaily protein food sercings for adultsAutism aspergbers addult
diagnosisYoung girls with tight assFreee boob inplantsKrjstara barrington and tthe posman strippersAnime ggay
gamesBooob sizes fromm small largeNaked filingSexuasl saddism examplesCharles arnett aggravated sexyal assaultBrsts fuckedFreee vinttage rsdio schematicsLesbjan seducinbg videlGrandma cum shotsMiiss michigan teen uusa 2009Nakked asian in publicTanya jmes porn starDiffeent masturbate ways womanTeen girls in beachJoin ftee india escort serviceFree xxxx
pierrcing preview galleriesSub twinkRenoo burglary
sexua assaultSucck urr cock