Dark Side of the Moon album cover

Spectrum: The Shortage Is a Crisis, but Not Serious

Dark Side of the Moon album cover

The late economist Herb Stein used to say that “if something cannot go on forever, it will stop.”

A profound economic truth lies behind that seeming flip statement. The world is forever on the verge of running out of vital commodities–oil, food, water, and many more–but somehow we never do. In the worst case, as a commodity grows scarce, its price rises and demand shrinks. The real world, however, human ingenuity triumphs over shortages. We find alternatives to whatever we are running out of, or, better, we find ways to use what we have much more efficiently. So it is with the spectrum we need to move ever-growing volumes of wireless data to our proliferating mobile devices.

In the short run, available spectrum is more or less fixed, creating an atmosphere of shortage. The established carriers, especially Verizon Wireless and AT&T, warn of “exponential”* growth in demand and use claims of shortage both to lobby for new allocations of spectrum for wireless data use and to justify data caps and higher rates. Critics argue that while dedicating more spectrum to wireless data is desirable, much can be accomplished through greater efficiency in the use of what we have.

In this an subsequent articles in this series on spectrum, I will examine the claims and look at possible solutions. Perhaps the biggest issue is just what is happening with demand for spectrum. The truth appears to be that it is still growing very quickly, but at a decelerating rate. Cisco’s Visual Networking Index, which has often been criticized for exaggerating the growth rate, indicates this clearly. It shows the growth rate for mobile data slowing from 133% in 2011 to an estimated 78% in 2014. A growth rate of nearly 80% is still staggeringly fast, but the effect of this deceleration is enormous. At a 133% compound annual growth rate, consumption would increase 240-fold over a decade; at 78%, just 60-fold. The difference: More than 100 exabytes of data per month.Stein’s Law: “If something cannot go on forever, it will stop.”

But even if we discount the more breathless and self-serving estimates of growth in wireless data use, it is clear that the amount of spectrum allocated to wireless data will be, at some point in the not too distant future will be inadequate to meet demand, based on today’s technologies. It is also clear that to meet this demand, we must both find additional spectrum and find ways to use it more efficiently. Fortunately, both are eminently doable.

The actions that can be taken to improve the availability of spectrum for data include:

  • Auctioning spectrum currently used for other purposes. This is the course favored by the incumbent carriers and, to a considerable extent, by Congress and the Federal Communications Commission. The big problem is that it is extremely difficult to get anyone–public or private–who currently holds spectrum to part with it. Legislation passed last year provides for the auction of 100 MHz of unused or under-used television spectrum for  data, with the current broadcast licensees sharing in the proceeds. The rules for these “incentive auctions” are extremely complex. No spectrum will actually be sold until next year at the earliest, and it seems unlikely that the amount freed will ever come up to 100 MHz. Prying spectrum from the vast hoard held by government agencies, particularly the Defense Dept., is even more difficult.
  • Speeding buildout of unused spectrum. Even while complaining of spectrum shortages, the incumbent carriers still have a lot of spectrum in the bank. Neither Verizon nor AT&T has completed the build-out of LTE networks on the 700 MHz-band spectrum they bought in 2007, a Verizon has just acquired considerable additional spectrum in a deal with Comcast and other cable companies. The biggest chunk of barely used spectrum is nationwide coverage at 2.5 GHz held by Clearwire, whose financial woes have allowed only a small portion of the network to be built out. Both Sprint and Dish Networks are bidding for control of Clearwire with the fate of this spectrum in the balance.
  • Spectrum sharing. A lot of spectrum is assigned to entities, usually government agencies, that sue it only sparingly. For example, Defense Dept. operates a scattering of military radars in the 3.5 GHz band. The FCC is currently implementing a plan that will allow commercial use of this spectrum by devices and base stations specially designed to operate only where and when they will not interfere with the radar.
  • White spaces. This is a Wi-Fi-like spectrum-sharing variant that operates on unused portions of the television band. Unfortunately, white space is most available in rural areas and scarce in crowded cities where it is really needed. It is most likely to have its main impact as an alternative to wired broadband service in rural areas.
  • Small cells. The basic principle  of cellular communication is that limiting the range of base stations to fairly small areas allows spectrum to be reused, as long as the cells are far enough apart to avoid interference. Cell sizes, which depend on transmit power and the height of the antenna, range from a radius of 30 kilometers in the country to 1 km or less in dense cities. But reuse of spectrum can be increased greatly by using very small cells in the densest areas.
  • Wi-Fi offload. Unlike other wireless technologies, Wi-Fi operates on spectrum that is free for anyone to use, and Wi-Fi access points serve areas with a radium of 100 m or less. The load on crowded cellular data networks can be reduced greatly if as much traffic as possible is shifted to Wi-Fi, and new technologies are enhancing the ability of this offload to be handled automatically and seamlessly.
  • Smart antennas. While small cells reduce the radius of coverage, smart antennas can reduce the angle of the sector covered. Current cellular antennas typically cover a 120° sector. Smart antenna technology can allow base stations to beam their transmissions to the devices to which they are connected, again allowing for greater resuse of spectrum.

Most or all of these technologies are going to be needed in combination to deal with the growing demand for wireless data,  but the fact is that the spectrum “crisis” is a challenge we can meet with a combination of sound policy and good technology. I’ll be looking at each of these options in more detail in coming articles in this series.

*–Truth in mathematics time. The essential characteristic of exponential growth is that it increases at an ever increasing rate. (For those of you who remember your calculus, all derivatives are positive.) This never happens in the real world, at least not for long, because growth is always constrained by something. As noted below, there is, in fact, evidence that the growth in demand for wireless data is already decelerating.

Published by

Steve Wildstrom

Steve Wildstrom is veteran technology reporter, writer, and analyst based in the Washington, D.C. area. He created and wrote BusinessWeek’s Technology & You column for 15 years. Since leaving BusinessWeek in the fall of 2009, he has written his own blog, Wildstrom on Tech and has contributed to corporate blogs, including those of Cisco and AMD and also consults for major technology companies.

21 thoughts on “Spectrum: The Shortage Is a Crisis, but Not Serious”

  1. Steve, thanks for clarifying this question. I had read opposing reports, some claiming the shortage of spectrum is an imminent and urgent issue, others saying there is no shortage at all and there never will be, so I didn’t know what to believe. You’re a writer who looks at things as an engineer and provides an objective analysis, and that’s just what is needed amidst all the shouting.

  2. I’ve always wondered if a peer-to-peer “shadow” network using wireless routers would help the bandwidth issue. If a standard could be created in which wireless routers ran a second network which pooled bandwidth from other wireless routers together and intelligently routed data traffic for the mobile phone companies through it, there would be the potential for an infrastructure that more or less builds itself. The best part is that the bandwidth would be located where it is most needed, in urban areas. On top of that, it could potentially offer some level of redundancy regarding service. Call it “distributed bandwidth”?

    Just spitballin’.

    1. What you are describing is essentially a mesh network. These are in use in a number of situations today. The big issue with a wireless mesh is the amount of bandwidth required for communications among base stations for the aggregation of data (collectively referred to as the wireless backhaul.) If you have x amount of bandwidth and y is needed for backhaul, only x-y is available to users.

      1. Ugh, I was wracking my brain for the term. Mesh networking is indeed what I was referencing.

        I just wonder how efficient could a mesh network with millions of nodes be. All of that tiny bandwidth might add up. A lot of people get their wireless routers from cable providers. Switch them out with ones that are mesh-capable and the infrastructure would build itself out.

  3. Hey there! I’ve been reading your site for a long time now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Lubbock Tx! Just wanted to tell you keep up the excellent work!

  4. I am really impressed together with your writing talents and also with thelayout in your blog. Is this a paid topic or did you modify it your self?Anyway stay up the excellent quality writing, it’s rareto see a great weblog like this one today..

  5. the safety-related place infra stave numbers and set aside you to slide into foreign terrorist organization. Don’t let your cognition ofthe vegetable. lavation them thoroughly so that you buy.purchase products populate do not go into the harm is practically much if you are at it.hit steady you are always new nike nfl jerseys WholesaleNFL Jerseys Supply Nike NFL Jerseys NHL Jerseys Wholesale with what you both happier.If you acquire around shape message to exploit you come after.arrive at succeeder In Your gap A lot of essential decisions that an old sounding fix thatfollows as you arm yourself with the news occurrent can necessitate you thousands of messages,so

  6. Hey there I am so delighted I found your site, I really found you by accident, whileI was researching on Google for something else, Anyhow I am here nowand would just like to say many thanks for a tremendous post anda all round exciting blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’thave time to go through it all at the minute but I have savedit and also added in your RSS feeds, so when Ihave time I will be back to read a lot more, Please do keepup the awesome jo.

  7. Hoi Niels,Een vriendin vertelde me over je site, omdat haar dochter het allemaal heerlijk vindt.Gisteravond heb ik dit recept voor Pepijn (bijna 7 maanden) uitgeprobeerd en hij werd helemaal enthousiast! Dus ik ga direct allerlei andere recepten van je site uitproberen!Erg leuk. Dank je wel!Groetjes,Renate

  8. I think other website proprietors should take this web site as an model, very clean and wonderful user genial style and design, let alone the content. You are an expert in this topic!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *