The Danger of Narratives in Tech

Gerald Ford was clumsy, Jimmy Carter was out of touch, Mitt Romney was a flip-flopper. All these characterizations (and many more) were the result of what have been called political “narratives” – stories the media tell about politicians and candidates to make sense of isolated incidents and create stories they can sell to voters. Like one person stereotypes, these narratives are rarely fair, but often vaguely grounded in some sort of truth. They dominate coverage of politics in the US and elsewhere, to the point where a candidate’s every action starts to be seen through the lens of this narrative. Designed to be helpful – to assist voters to make sense of the news – these narratives more often distort the truth and have sunk the campaigns of many an aspiring politician. But much the same may be said of the narratives we’re beginning to see told in the world of technology.

Like political narratives, the stories the tech media likes to tell are intended to put events in context and to help readers make sense of them, while also making for good copy and lots of clicks. But like political narratives, they’re often misleading and, like most political narratives, these stories are typically negative in nature. Here are some examples:

  • Apple can’t innovate anymore
  • Google is evil
  • Facebook wants to end your privacy
  • Microsoft is irrelevant
  • Amazon isn’t interested in making money
  • Samsung just copies everything Apple does

The problem for companies seeking to dispel these narratives is the same as the problem faced by campaign managers in the political sphere: you can’t simply kill a narrative – you have to replace it with one of your own. People like story lines that provide a golden thread for the disparate events that happen in the life of a company – which helps explain the popularity of the misguided narratives the media provides. So, in order to get people to let go of the narratives they’ve embraced, you have to give them a new story to latch onto.

Perhaps this explains why Microsoft has recently promoted Mark Penn, a former political operative who’s been working his way up the ranks inside the company’s marketing department. He was apparently responsible for the strategy behind Microsoft’s Super Bowl ad this year, which was definitely more about a narrative than a product. When you’re on the receiving end of so many negative narratives, you have to go on the offensive and start telling your own story. That’s what Microsoft now appears to be doing.

Apple of course, is the master of telling its own story. But even with Apple, we’ve seen a real uptick in narrative rather than product-focused advertising over the past year or so. There was the Designed by Apple in California video that debuted at WWDC 2013 and was followed by an ad along similar lines, the 30 years of Mac video and the 1.24.14 film that went with it. People have wondered why Apple was doing this and even criticized them for doing it, but I don’t think Apple has a choice – when the media’s narratives start to trump your own, you have to go out and tell your story more aggressively to regain control.

Google is one of the few companies on my short list which seems to have been able to get the media to adopt its narrative, even without appearing to try to do so explicitly. Its Google[X] organization, and more specifically its self-driving cars, Google Glass and acquisition of various robotics companies all appear designed to create the impression of a company shooting for the moon in pursuit of new and wonderful inventions. If you’re trying to shrug off the dominant narrative of an evil corporation intent on selling you as its product to advertisers, what better way than to wax quixotic and aspirational, and talk about making the world a better place?

Amazon and Facebook have their own stories to tell, too. Interestingly, Amazon both suffers and benefits from the dominant narrative, among different communities. Among investors, of course, its consistent failure to make profits may be seen as a drawback, while of course to ordinary consumers that’s the appeal of Amazon. Jeff Bezos has also used his own personal investments to bolster Amazon’s image, investing in literal moon shots with Blue Origin and saving the newspapers with his purchase of the Washington Post. Facebook, meanwhile, seeks to demonstrate its altruistic side through Internet.org, connecting the world’s unconnected and only incidentally increasing the addressable market for Facebook.

As an analyst, my job is to see through the narratives and to separate the facts from the spin – both the narratives spun by the media and the stories the companies themselves tell. The challenge is the answers are often far less black and white than the narratives – it’s not possible to conclusively quantify Apple’s innovativeness or calculate Google’s evil quotient. But it is possible to understand and describe what’s really going on at these companies, in their financials and in the markets in which they operate. There are still stories to tell my clients, but they’re often more nuanced and less sensational than the narratives fed to us by these companies and the media.

Published by

Jan Dawson

Jan Dawson is Founder and Chief Analyst at Jackdaw Research, a technology research and consulting firm focused on consumer technology. During his sixteen years as a technology analyst, Jan has covered everything from DSL to LTE, and from policy and regulation to smartphones and tablets. As such, he brings a unique perspective to the consumer technology space, pulling together insights on communications and content services, device hardware and software, and online services to provide big-picture market analysis and strategic advice to his clients. Jan has worked with many of the world’s largest operators, device and infrastructure vendors, online service providers and others to shape their strategies and help them understand the market. Prior to founding Jackdaw, Jan worked at Ovum for a number of years, most recently as Chief Telecoms Analyst, responsible for Ovum’s telecoms research agenda globally.

1,042 thoughts on “The Danger of Narratives in Tech”

  1. “Evil is never intended as evil. Indeed, the contradiction inherent in all evil is that it originates in the desire to eliminate evil.” James Carse

    “A fellow who is always declaring he’s no fool usually has his suspicions.” James Mizner. Replace no fool with not evil.

  2. Narrative reminds me a lot of stereotype. There is a grain of truth to it, but it doesn’t show any nuance at all. For most of us, who are not professionals in the industry, and just purchase consumer devices, narratives are extremely important. Many people don’t have the time or desire to sit down and understand company A, B, or C and their strategy, and how that will affect them as a consumer. But they do want to know something about the companies they are dealing with.

  3. The behind-the-curtain, overbearing, techno-political agenda, around which competitive media articulate their pay-dirt story lines:

    Google, springs eternal;
    Amazon, summers eternal;
    Apple, fall-guy perpetual;
    Microsoft, winters eternal…

    …the ‘beau jest’s carpe diem annuity, so-called: ‘the four-legged can-can canned plan’.

  4. tadalafil soft gel capsule 20mg [url=https://tadalafil.trade/#]tadalafil online cost[/url] tadalafil tablets canada

  5. sildenafil 100mg price canadian pharmacy [url=http://sildenafil.win/#]sildenafil 100mg mexico[/url] sildenafil price 20mg

  6. how to get doxycycline without prescription [url=http://doxycycline.forum/#]doxycycline buy online[/url] drug doxycycline

  7. doxycycline hyclate capsules [url=https://doxycycline.forum/#]doxycycline buy online[/url] doxycycline 50 mg buy uk

  8. purple pharmacy mexico price list [url=http://mexicopharmacy.store/#]top mail order pharmacy from Mexico[/url] buying prescription drugs in mexico

  9. gel per erezione in farmacia [url=http://sildenafilit.bid/#]viagra prezzo farmacia[/url] viagra 50 mg prezzo in farmacia

  10. farmacia online miglior prezzo [url=https://farmaciait.pro/#]farmacia online[/url] acquisto farmaci con ricetta

  11. comprare farmaci online con ricetta [url=http://avanafilit.icu/#]avanafil prezzo in farmacia[/url] farmacie on line spedizione gratuita

  12. viagra consegna in 24 ore pagamento alla consegna [url=https://sildenafilit.bid/#]farmacia senza ricetta recensioni[/url] viagra pfizer 25mg prezzo

  13. viagra para mujeres [url=https://sildenafilo.store/#]sildenafilo cinfa sin receta[/url] comprar viagra online en andorra

  14. farmacia envГ­os internacionales [url=https://tadalafilo.pro/#]comprar cialis online seguro opiniones[/url] farmacia online 24 horas

  15. comprar viagra en espaГ±a envio urgente [url=https://sildenafilo.store/#]comprar viagra[/url] viagra online cerca de bilbao

  16. farmacia online envГ­o gratis [url=https://kamagraes.site/#]se puede comprar kamagra en farmacias[/url] farmacias baratas online envГ­o gratis

  17. sildenafilo 100mg precio espaГ±a [url=http://sildenafilo.store/#]viagra precio[/url] п»їViagra online cerca de Madrid

  18. acheter mГ©dicaments Г  l’Г©tranger [url=https://kamagrafr.icu/#]kamagra pas cher[/url] pharmacie ouverte 24/24

  19. pharmacie ouverte [url=http://levitrafr.life/#]Levitra pharmacie en ligne[/url] Pharmacie en ligne livraison gratuite

  20. Pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance [url=https://pharmacieenligne.guru/#]pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance[/url] Pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es

  21. Viagra 100 mg ohne Rezept [url=https://viagrakaufen.store/#]viagra generika[/url] Billig Viagra bestellen ohne Rezept

  22. Viagra Tabletten für Männer [url=http://viagrakaufen.store/#]viagra ohne rezept[/url] In welchen europäischen Ländern ist Viagra frei verkäuflich

  23. medication from mexico pharmacy [url=http://mexicanpharmacy.cheap/#]medicine in mexico pharmacies[/url] mexico pharmacies prescription drugs

  24. pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa [url=https://mexicanpharmacy.cheap/#]п»їbest mexican online pharmacies[/url] medication from mexico pharmacy

  25. mexican mail order pharmacies [url=http://mexicanpharmacy.cheap/#]п»їbest mexican online pharmacies[/url] mexican rx online

  26. cheap canadian pharmacy online [url=https://canadiandrugs.tech/#]canadapharmacyonline legit[/url] canadian pharmacies online canadiandrugs.tech

  27. best pills for ed [url=https://edpills.tech/#]erectile dysfunction medications[/url] treatments for ed edpills.tech

  28. canadian mail order pharmacy [url=http://canadiandrugs.tech/#]canadian discount pharmacy[/url] canada pharmacy 24h canadiandrugs.tech

  29. canadian pharmacy 24 com [url=https://canadiandrugs.tech/#]canadian pharmacy prices[/url] canadian drugs online canadiandrugs.tech

  30. canadian drug [url=https://canadiandrugs.tech/#]canadian online pharmacy reviews[/url] canadian pharmacy no scripts canadiandrugs.tech

  31. where to get cheap clomid price [url=http://clomid.site/#]cheap clomid pill[/url] where to buy clomid without insurance

  32. buy ciprofloxacin over the counter [url=http://ciprofloxacin.life/#]ciprofloxacin over the counter[/url] buy cipro

  33. ampicillin amoxicillin [url=http://amoxil.icu/#]amoxicillin 500 mg without a prescription[/url] can you buy amoxicillin over the counter in canada

  34. doxycycline 100mg online [url=http://doxycyclinebestprice.pro/#]doxycycline hyclate[/url] order doxycycline online

  35. buy cytotec over the counter [url=http://cytotec.icu/#]Abortion pills online[/url] buy cytotec over the counter

  36. does tamoxifen cause weight loss [url=https://nolvadex.fun/#]lexapro and tamoxifen[/url] tamoxifen hormone therapy

  37. mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa [url=http://mexicopharm.com/#]Best pharmacy in Mexico[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies mexicopharm.com

  38. reputable mexican pharmacies online [url=https://mexicopharm.com/#]Mexico pharmacy online[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies mexicopharm.com

  39. canadian pharmacy [url=http://canadapharm.life/#]Canada Drugs Direct[/url] reputable canadian online pharmacy canadapharm.life

  40. Levitra 10 mg buy online [url=https://levitradelivery.pro/#]Buy Vardenafil 20mg[/url] Buy Vardenafil online

  41. sildenafil tablets from india 100mg tablets [url=http://sildenafildelivery.pro/#]sildenafil without a doctor prescription Canada[/url] sildenafil generic india

  42. cost of propecia pill [url=https://finasteride.men/#]cost cheap propecia without insurance[/url] buying cheap propecia without prescription

  43. order cheap propecia without prescription [url=https://finasteride.men/#]Best place to buy propecia[/url] cost of cheap propecia tablets

  44. farmacia online piГ№ conveniente [url=https://farmaciaitalia.store/#]farmaci senza ricetta elenco[/url] migliori farmacie online 2023

  45. п»їfarmacia online migliore [url=http://tadalafilitalia.pro/#]dove acquistare cialis online sicuro[/url] farmaci senza ricetta elenco

  46. farmacie online affidabili [url=http://farmaciaitalia.store/#]farmacia online[/url] farmacia online senza ricetta

  47. farmacia online miglior prezzo [url=http://farmaciaitalia.store/#]comprare farmaci online all’estero[/url] acquisto farmaci con ricetta

  48. canadianpharmacymeds com [url=https://canadapharm.shop/#]legit canadian pharmacy online[/url] canadian pharmacy online reviews

  49. buy cytotec online [url=https://cytotec.directory/#]buy cytotec online fast delivery[/url] п»їcytotec pills online

  50. tadalafil without a doctor’s prescription [url=http://edwithoutdoctorprescription.store/#]ed meds online without doctor prescription[/url] buy prescription drugs without doctor

  51. canadian pharmaceutical companies that ship to usa [url=https://reputablepharmacies.online/#]canadian prescription drug prices[/url] legal online pharmacies

  52. male erection pills [url=https://edpills.bid/#]ed medications[/url] cheap erectile dysfunction pills online

  53. canada pharmacy world [url=http://reputablepharmacies.online/#]cheap drugs online[/url] online pharmacy usa

  54. no prior prescription required pharmacy [url=http://reputablepharmacies.online/#]highest rated canadian pharmacy[/url] reliable online pharmacies

  55. no prescription pharmacies [url=http://reputablepharmacies.online/#]canada pharmacies prescription drugs[/url] pharmacies online

  56. cialis without a doctor’s prescription [url=http://edwithoutdoctorprescription.store/#]legal to buy prescription drugs without prescription[/url] non prescription erection pills

  57. mexico pharmacy [url=https://mexicanpharmacy.win/#]Medicines Mexico[/url] medicine in mexico pharmacies mexicanpharmacy.win

  58. india pharmacy [url=http://indianpharmacy.shop/#]Order medicine from India to USA[/url] world pharmacy india indianpharmacy.shop

  59. mexican rx online [url=https://mexicanpharmacy.win/#]Mexico pharmacy[/url] mexican mail order pharmacies mexicanpharmacy.win

  60. legitimate canadian pharmacies [url=http://canadianpharmacy.pro/#]Canada Pharmacy[/url] canadian 24 hour pharmacy canadianpharmacy.pro

  61. indian pharmacy paypal [url=http://indianpharmacy.shop/#]Best Indian pharmacy[/url] buy medicines online in india indianpharmacy.shop

  62. pharmacy website india [url=http://indianpharmacy.shop/#]best online pharmacy india[/url] indian pharmacy online indianpharmacy.shop

  63. buying prescription drugs in mexico online [url=https://mexicanpharmacy.win/#]Mexico pharmacy[/url] п»їbest mexican online pharmacies mexicanpharmacy.win

  64. п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india [url=http://indianpharmacy.shop/#]Order medicine from India to USA[/url] mail order pharmacy india indianpharmacy.shop

  65. reputable mexican pharmacies online [url=http://mexicanpharmacy.win/#]Mexico pharmacy[/url] medicine in mexico pharmacies mexicanpharmacy.win

  66. mexico drug stores pharmacies [url=https://mexicanpharmacy.win/#]Medicines Mexico[/url] mexican pharmacy mexicanpharmacy.win

  67. top 10 pharmacies in india [url=https://indianpharmacy.shop/#]indian pharmacy to usa[/url] top online pharmacy india indianpharmacy.shop

  68. п»їpharmacie en ligne [url=http://pharmadoc.pro/#]PharmaDoc.pro[/url] Pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance

  69. Pharmacie en ligne France [url=https://acheterkamagra.pro/#]pharmacie ouverte[/url] Pharmacie en ligne pas cher

  70. Pharmacie en ligne livraison gratuite [url=https://cialissansordonnance.shop/#]Acheter Cialis[/url] Pharmacie en ligne livraison rapide

  71. Viagra sans ordonnance 24h suisse [url=http://viagrasansordonnance.pro/#]Viagra femme ou trouver[/url] Viagra homme prix en pharmacie

  72. Pharmacie en ligne livraison gratuite [url=https://levitrasansordonnance.pro/#]levitra generique[/url] п»їpharmacie en ligne

  73. generic over the counter prednisone [url=https://prednisonetablets.shop/#]prednisone 2.5 mg price[/url] prednisone without rx

  74. how to get amoxicillin over the counter [url=https://amoxicillin.bid/#]amoxicillin for sale online[/url] amoxicillin canada price

  75. amoxicillin generic [url=http://amoxicillin.bid/#]amoxicillin 500 mg without a prescription[/url] buy amoxicillin 500mg usa

  76. canadian pharmacies online [url=https://canadianpharm.store/#]canadian pharmacy drugs online[/url] legitimate canadian mail order pharmacy canadianpharm.store

  77. medication from mexico pharmacy [url=https://mexicanpharm.shop/#]Online Mexican pharmacy[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies mexicanpharm.shop

  78. mexico pharmacy [url=http://mexicanpharm.shop/#]Online Pharmacies in Mexico[/url] buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexicanpharm.shop

  79. canadian pharmacy ltd [url=http://canadianpharm.store/#]Canada Pharmacy online[/url] canadian online pharmacy reviews canadianpharm.store

  80. india pharmacy [url=http://indianpharm.store/#]order medicine from india to usa[/url] indian pharmacy indianpharm.store

  81. top 10 pharmacies in india [url=http://indianpharm.store/#]Indian pharmacy to USA[/url] india online pharmacy indianpharm.store

  82. mexican pharmaceuticals online [url=http://mexicanpharm.shop/#]Online Pharmacies in Mexico[/url] medication from mexico pharmacy mexicanpharm.shop

  83. cheapest online pharmacy india [url=https://indianpharm.store/#]order medicine from india to usa[/url] buy prescription drugs from india indianpharm.store

  84. indianpharmacy com [url=http://indianpharm.store/#]indian pharmacy[/url] cheapest online pharmacy india indianpharm.store

  85. certified mexican pharmacy [url=https://canadadrugs.pro/#]canada pharmacies online[/url] online pharmacy medications

  86. canadian pharmacies review [url=https://canadadrugs.pro/#]prescription drugs without doctor approval[/url] medicine prices

  87. best online canadian pharmacy [url=https://canadadrugs.pro/#]safe canadian internet pharmacies[/url] canadian overnight pharmacy

  88. canadian medicine [url=https://canadadrugs.pro/#]canadian pharmacy testosterone[/url] no 1 canadian pharmacy

  89. family pharmacy online [url=https://canadadrugs.pro/#]usa pharmacy online[/url] on line pharmacy with no perscriptions