Why do Products like the Google Nexus Q Launch?

At Google’s I/O developer conference in June, Google boldly announced the Nexus Q, a $299 streaming music sphere.  Last week, Google stopped selling the Nexus Q and cancelled all consumer pre-orders, saying buyers would get the unit for free.  It appeared obvious to just about everyone except Google that the Nexus Q value proposition was incredibly weak.  So how does one of the most powerful companies in the world allow a product so obviously not ready get to market?  It happens for many reasons and more often than you might think.  I’d like to characterize the many reasons products like this make it this far as I experienced it through my 20 years of product management and product marketing.

The Google Nexus Q Value Proposition

While I detail out the Nexus Q value proposition here, let me provide a small sample.  For $299, consumers get a cool looking black sphere for music and video streaming that can only pull content from the Google Play cloud.  To control it, you must have an Android phone or tablet, and if your friends want to add tracks to the music list they must have an Android device. The Q also came with a high quality, built-in amp and speaker jacks.  Net-net, it was $200 or 3X more than an Apple TV or Roku device if you are looking at it as a content streamer.  If you are audiophile, you will be comparing it to a Sonos, which while comparatively priced, can also stream from multiple cloud services, and be controlled by iOS and Android devices.

The press gave it the expected response.

The Press Reaction

The press reaction was brutal.   The best way to show just how bad it was is with the headlines:

Google I/O was a smashing success.  They launched a great Nexus 7 tablet with Project Butter and Google Now, some cool social and search features, and who will ever forget the Google Glass demo?  Google didn’t need to launch the Q to have what I would characterize as one of the more perfect developer conferences.

So why and how exactly do products like the nexus Q make all the way through the ideation, planning, execution, and launch phase without someone putting the brakes on?  There are many ways and reasons this happens that I outline below, and product managers need to pay heed to all of these potential pitfalls.  I am generically speaking about products, not specifically about the Nexus Q.

Don’t Solicit Outside Opinions

Some companies don’t solicit outside opinion by design.  Outside opinions can be via market research, consultants, tech analysts, etc.  The project is so secret that they put the team members in another building with limited access and have them sign NDAs.  This is done, obviously for security, and there are hundreds of examples of this that the industry finds out about after the fact.  This week in the Apple-Samsung trial, we all heard that the iPhone development was treated like this.  This secret method obviously works well for Apple and a handful of companies, but for other companies, not so great. Some other companies don’t solicit outside input because they just don’t see value in it.  Some say it’s too time consuming or too expensive.  That’s just code for “I don’t see the value”.  They figure they are the experts, have all the answers, and any outside inputs could lead to having the project derailed.

Living in an Alternate Universe

Sometimes, companies will solicit external input on a concept or product but don’t listen to the advice or heed it.  Many times you will hear the phrase, “well that’s only one piece of input we’ll incorporate.”  This usually means the outside input won’t be used or even heeded, because, quite frankly, the company “knows” more than the outsider giving the input.  Or so they think.  These kind of folks get outside input because the rule book says they needed to get it and once they did, it becomes a filled-in check box versus valued input.  The product planner may believe the input, but just not heed the outcome.  The end result is the same as not soliciting input.

Underestimating the Downstream Impact

Many times, a product will successfully make it down the gate process only for the PM to be surprised down the line by a cost over-run or an internal team missing a delivery date.  This could very well have happened to the Nexus Q.  I can imagine the Q had a very long list of required features and nice to have features.  Judging by what launched, the “must-have” features didn’t even ship.  I can see just a few features that could have been added to make the Q the must-have party device.  What happened next was where the damage was done.  So what is a product leader’s reaction if their product is hit with a significant cost overrun or schedule slip?  In the case of the Q, the impact was most likely minimized.  Look at many Google products that get sent out as “Beta” at Google.  Most of them do.  Google News and Shopping were betas for years and cost the consumer nothing but time to use.  The difference is that the Nexus Q was $299 and it was more like Alpha stage if you gauge on feature completeness.

The Emperor Has No Clothes

When I have been privy to post-mortems of train-wreck projects, many times it comes down to a lack of leadership.  The entire team had a decent vision, knew the customer and what they wanted, solicited external input, listened to it, and knew the downstream impacts of issues that existed if they trudged forward.  But the leader in charge felt they had to meet the date at all costs or didn’t listen to the team members.  The leader made a commitment to someone, whether it be to their VP, SVP or board of directors to deliver something by a certain date and they were going to do it come “hell or high water”.   Leaders are trained to listen, be decisive and stick to their guns, sometimes at big costs.

What’s Next for the Nexus Q?

I believe the team managing the Nexus Q had a deadline to hit with Google I/O , they got in over their heads on features and just couldn’t deliver.  And no one stopped the project.  The Nexus Q name and Google brand has been damaged, but I think it’s recoverable.  To maintain the Nexus Q price, Google will need to add a ton of features.  I am envisioning the “ultimate party device” where everyone who comes to the party can play videos, music and games from their own device and the cloud.  I can also see “party mode” where every picture, video clip, and social media post  taken at the party is shown on a large HDTV. If something like that is a bridge too far, then Google will need to pull the price lever.  The BOM cost cannot be over a $100 with the built-in 25W amp, so they have a lot to work with.   Whatever Google does, they need to make some decisive moves if they hope to be successful with living room devices.

Published by

Patrick Moorhead

Patrick Moorhead was ranked the #1 technology industry analyst by Apollo Research for the U.S. and EMEA in May, 2013.. He is President and Principal Analyst of Moor Insights & Strategy, a high tech analyst firm focused on the ecosystem intersections of the phone, tablet, PC, TV, datacenter and cloud. Moorhead departed AMD in 2011 where he served as Corporate Vice President and Corporate Fellow in the strategy group. There, he developed long-term strategies for mobile computing devices and personal computers. In his 11 years at AMD he also led product management, business planning, product marketing, regional marketing, channel marketing, and corporate marketing. Moorhead worked at Compaq Computer Corp. during their run to the #1 market share leader position in personal computers. Moorhead also served as an executive at AltaVista E-commerce during their peak and pioneered cost per click e-commerce models.

134 thoughts on “Why do Products like the Google Nexus Q Launch?”

  1. Nice article.

    The idea of institutional myopia was popularized in the sixties by several prominent business writers. Essentially, the theory explained how it was the norm for institutions to become ever more focused on what they already believed and ever more resistant to opposing points of view. Every institution needs to fight this tendency. That’s very easy for me to say and very hard for institutions to do.

    Google is not dumb or incompetent. They just followed human nature and fell into a trap. As understandable as making such a mistake may be, it’s is still wholly unacceptable. Google is huge and they are one of the most successful and influential companies on the planet. Then cannot afford to make such mistakes, no matter how understandable those mistakes might be. They need to change the way things are done otherwise, such mistakes are all but guaranteed to happen again and again.

    Reply

  3. Howdy! Someone in my Facebook group shared this site with us so I came to look it over. I’m definitely enjoying the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Superb blog and fantastic design and style.

    Reply

  5. Do you have a spam issue on this site; I also am a blogger, and I was wanting to know your situation; we have developed some nice practices and we are looking to swap techniques with other folks, please shoot me an email if interested.

    Reply

  7. All you need to do is just run the program, input your username, click few buttons, andthe tokens will be delivered to your account. Search no more, using ourlatest Chaturbate hack tool you can download in just a few moments, you will be ableto get your account upgraded for free. Highlights: I always appreciate a sitewhere user rating is available; it’s a way to find out which spring roll is easiest to bite into, if you get my drift.If you’re the type of person who needs to make sure your porn is totally in the clear sexism and ethics-wise,cartoons are they way to go. This would make the program being detected and taken down in matter of days afterits public release. We have even considered doing a chaturbate (think just talking about itturns us on) or something similar and constantly making private videos outin public ( I do landscape photography so in isolated places)and home videos. Lesbian chat and Gay’s chat is theplace where girls lesbians, gays and bisexuals can explore, communicate openly, find a soul mate via private liveporn cams, or make an appointment in reality.We favored the idea and after long debates we determined to create ourown private chaturbate hack to deliver forus free tokens.

    Reply

  14. Se preferisci giocare su casinò online regolamentati in Italia, ci sono anche numerose opzioni che accettano PayPal come metodo di pagamento. I casinò online con licenza AAMS sono soggetti a rigide norme e regolamenti, garantendo un ambiente di gioco sicuro e trasparente per i giocatori italiani. I casinò online AAMS pongono una maggiore attenzione nei confronti dei minori, per garantire che i giochi d’azzardo online siano offerti solo a persone maggiorenni. Ciò significa che il casinò richiederà sempre la verifica dell’età prima di consentire l’accesso ai giochi. Per utilizzare PayPal come metodo di pagamento nei casinò online, è necessario creare un conto PayPal. Questo processo consiste nel visitare il sito web di PayPal e seguire la procedura di registrazione, che comprende l’indicazione di un indirizzo e-mail e il collegamento di un conto bancario o di una carta di credito debito al conto PayPal.
    https://www.toro-bookmarks.win/bonus-poker
    GTD: 10x vstupenka do turnaje Double Chance MAXBuy-in: 700 Kč | Start: 15:00 | Casino Luka Late reg: 10x 10 min | multi re-entry | Starting Stack: 15.000 chips housedům , domek GTD: 10x vstupenka do turnaje MINI High RollerBuy-in: 700 Kč | Start: 15:00 | Casino International Brno Late reg: 10x 10 min | multi re-entry | Starting Stack: 15.000 chips Hrát kasino pro smartphone očekáváme, jakou najdete u jiných recenzovaných kasin. Pokud chcete hrát online kasinové hry na iPhone, a nezahrnuje žádná bezplatná otočení. 9-136-8 Honmachi, Higashiyama-Ku, Kjóto, Japonsko Čekejte prosím, ověřujeme pro vás volné pokoje. Není to nemožné, které podporují pay by phone casino.

    Reply

  17. Hello there! I know this is kinda off topic however I’d figured I’d ask.
    Would you be interested in trading links or
    maybe guest writing a blog post or vice-versa? My website covers a lot of the same
    topics as yours and I believe we could greatly benefit from each other.

    If you might be interested feel free to shoot me an email.
    I look forward to hearing from you! Terrific blog by the
    way!

    Reply

  18. Have you ever considered about adding a little bit more than just your articles?

    I mean, what you say is fundamental and everything.

    However think of if you added some great graphics or video clips to give
    your posts more, “pop”! Your content is excellent but with pics
    and video clips, this blog could undeniably be one of the most beneficial in its niche.
    Very good blog!

    Reply

  25. Hi there! I know this is somewhat off topic but I was wondering
    which blog platform are you using for this website? I’m getting sick and tired of WordPress because I’ve had issues with
    hackers and I’m looking at options for another platform. I would
    be great if you could point me in the direction of
    a good platform.

    Reply

  39. CBD, or cannabidiol, has been a game changer due to the fact that me. delta 8 thc flowers I’ve struggled with anxiety into years and have tried diverse opposite medications, but nothing has worked as well as CBD. It helps me to feel undisturbed and at ease without any side effects. I also espy that it helps with take and pain management. I’ve tried several brands, but I’ve build that the ones that are lab tested and play a joke on a careful reputation are the most effective. Inclusive, I highly support CBD in behalf of anyone who struggles with anxiety, sleep issues, or chronic pain.

    Reply

  43. © 2023 NewsBTC. All Rights Reserved. In 2017, Bitcoin potential took the world by storm, as many became rich beyond their wildest dreams once Bitcoin reached its former all-time high of $20,000 per BTC coin. Mainstream media ran BTC news story after story, causing retail investors to rush into buying the asset. Other stories have been more mixed in terms of what they mean for cryptocurrencies. Among them has been the US Federal Reserve considering whether to launch its own “central bank digital currency” (CBDC). As we already discussed, halving events are programmed into the Bitcoin protocol to control the supply of bitcoins. However, these events have a significant impact on mining rewards. When a halving event occurs, the reward that miners receive is cut in half, which reduces their profitability. This can cause some miners to stop mining, especially those with outdated equipment that is not efficient enough to mine profitably.
    https://louiskwkw085299.qowap.com/81681486/article-under-review
    We could not find any results for: Make sure your spelling is correct or try broadening your search. PayPal has been operating an on-ramp service that allows customers to purchase cryptocurrencies. The company is now adding an off-ramp service, making it easier for users to convert their crypto assets into dollars.  Also, its trusted Blockchain technologies and money decentralization concepts make it an appropriate choice for many joining the ETC industry. Convert 27.2 Ethereum to US Dollar from World to United States. Whether you’re looking to spend your cryptocurrency as it is or convert Ethereum to cash, here are some of the top ways to go about it. Use your bank card, Apple Pay, or a bank transfer to purchase USD coin on our platform.

    Reply

  91. Du når den tjänsten på FASS.se genom att klicka här Mads Haaland-Paulsen, vd för DocMorris Apotek, lovar i ett pressmeddelande att kunderna ska få snabb service och inte behöva vänta längre än fem minuter på att få hjälp. – Vår ambition är att kunden snabbt ska få service och hjälp. Dröjer det längre än 5 minuter innan vi kan expediera dig, ger vi dig ett plåster på såret i form av en liten present, säger Mads Haaland-Paulsen i ett pressmeddelande. Vi vill att du ska känna trygghet inför att köpa potensmedel på nätet och är därför tillgängliga för att svara på alla dina frågor. Märket Viagra är ett namn för Sildenafil Citrat , ett kraftfullt läkemedel som kan hjälpa att behandla erektil dysfunktion hos män. Installera vår gratis app för Android. RX ASAP gör det enkelt för kunder att placera order direkt från app. Gratis Piller. Säkerhet. Enkelt och snabbt köp!
    https://johnathanphaq923578.articlesblogger.com/45738939/viagra-online-rauma
    Med utgångspunkt från data i den s.k. Jämtlandsundersökningen och med hjälp av Apoteket AB:s statistikansvariga har omfattande simuleringar genomförts för att bedöma effekterna av en förändring i förmånskonstruktionen och införande av en avgift även ovanför högkostnadsgränsen. De dynamiska effekterna av sådana åtgärder kan ej till fullo förutses och det skall också påpekas att Jämtland har jämförelsevis låga läkemedelskostnader. Bedömningarna är baserade på en omfördelning av de nuvarande utgifterna för läkemedel till föreslagen ny förmånskonstruktion. Nej. Ibland kan livsstilsförändringar göra att det försvinner. Om du dricker mycket alkohol, snusar, röker cigaretter eller tar partydroger, kan det hjälpa om du drar ner på dessa vanor för att få bättre erektioner.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *