Article Disclaimer: This is all theory and purely speculative. This is simply a thought exercise.
Motorola has been an interesting company to watch over the past 10 years. They have been a driving force in bringing the cellular industry into fruition and recently Motorola spun out their mobile business and created Motorola Mobility. I find an intruiguing scenario to play out to be one where Google buys Motorola Mobility.
One particular reason this is interetsing is because Motorola Mobility is deeply committed to Android. In fact as of now it appears that the company is solely basing its future on Android. Recent reports indicate an interest in Windows Phone 7 and possibly 8 by Motorola but it doesn’t appear actual product plans exist.
Motorola’s challenge is that they are attempting something that is becoming increasingly difficult in the industry today, namely to make money on hardware alone. To make matters even more challenging they have decided to bet their future on a company who is less interested in helping companies make money on hardware and more interested in free.
In fact I am convinced that Google and the Android team in particular would prefer that Android handsets cost less rather than more.
All of that leads to the first major reason I think Google would benefit greatly from buying Motorola Mobility.
Google Could Practically Give The Hardware Away
Google has already demonstrated an interesting model regarding Chrome that basically presents a hardware as a service model. In this model Google is offering Chrome OS hardware to the business and IT community for $28 a month and to educational institutions for $20 a month. There we have it, a hardware as a service model and Google is already going down this path.
So why not consider this same approach with Android handsets? This is not feasible currently because a company like Motorola needs to make money on the hardware since they don’t get to participate on the services financial upside like a carrier and Google. However if Google bought Motorola they could sell the hardware at a loss and make it up with their backend services.
A strategy very similar to what we think Amazon intends to do with their tablet.
Google needs as many Android devices on the market as possible. And yes they aren’t faring to poorly currently but if they subsidized the cost of the handset with their own longer term services revenue, which Google could do, I believe the market would accelerate even faster. Making the point again, Google cares about the services revenue not the hardware revenue. It behooves them to seed as much of the market with Android devices as possible.
Imagine if you could get one of the latest Android smart phones fully featured for less than $99. The price barrier to high end smart phones would be gone and Google would have even more demand for Android.
The second major reason is patents.
Google Needs Patents
Patent lawsuit frenzy is sweeping the technology industry. The media, analysts, pundits and more have now made it glaringly clear that Google is on the weaker end of the spectrum when it comes to patents.
It is for this reason they attempted to purchase the Nortel patents. Based on recent actions it can be concluded that Google knows they need to secure a more robust patent portfolio. More specifically they need a patent portfolio around mobile devices to help protect Android.
Motorola has an incredibly robust patent portfolio. In fact they have nearly three times as many patents as Nortel. Some have alluded that Motorola’s patent portfolio is possibly the strongest in the mobile field. It could be debated but its possible that Motorola has the best patent defense against Apple’s in this field.
One interesting point from Morgan Stanley analyst Ehud Gelblum who wrote in a research note last month:
“It is interesting to note that Motorola asserted 18 patents against Apple, and sued Apple first, whereas Apple has asserted just six patents against Motorola.”
Scott Moritz from the street remarks:
“Not only does Motorola have far more patents than its nearest competitors, it appears to have more of the key patents that may help the Android camp in a battle against Apple.”
The Big Picture
Although this is interesting to think about I doubt it will happen. A result of Google buying Motorola would be that their other partners like HTC, Samsung, LG and more would become competitors. I doubt Google’s partners would appreciate that and could potentially dump Android in the process. Also as far as I know Motorola Mobility is not for sale.
This patent issue however is a real one and one that if not dealt with tactfully by Google and the Android partners could prove fatal.
What’s more likely to happen, which The Street article points out, is that those in the Android camp band more closely together and leverage each others patent portfolios to protect Android.
Motorola however needs to continue to post solid financial results as they did for the most part last quarter. As I stated earlier making money on hardware alone is going to prove very difficult but Moto can and should continue to invest in innovations that differentiate their hardware allowing them a chance to profit from hardware. It would be wise of them to get more into the services game but not much is being shown there yet.
Not sure that it makes sense for a number of reasons:
First, as a core software supplier of Android, does Google really want to get into the position of competing against most of its customers? What would the reaction be from HTC and Samsung, who are moving a lot of Android should their strategic software supplier now be selling (or giving away) hardware that competes with them? I’ve been through this kind of discussion and it’s not easy.
Second, Motorola isn’t the group who is leading the charge in the handset business, much less the smartphone business. At this point they are an also-ran. The patents may be valuable, which brings an interesting point out that maybe what Motorola should do is sell the patent portfolio to Google. (ala Kodak’s move on its patent portfolio) A great influx of cash that could be used to try to turn the ship around.
Third, I’m not convinced that Google really wants a high-velocity hardware business. It clearly doesn’t have the margin profile that their software businesses have right now and that’s going to look like a drag on the financials. Sure the hardware as a service is interesting and they have the cash to dig the financial hole that it’s going to take, but there is another player in the handset game (the carriers) who are already trying to build a service business based on giving away hardware. Google’s last attempt to change that power balance was a failure (Nexus One sales by Google) and was abandoned. Do they and their investors have the stomach for this? Don’t know.
Google clearly needs a very large hammer to hit Apple with in the patent department so buying this portfolio (or Kodak’s which already has an in-flight patent spat with Apple) makes a lot of sense. But I can’t see owning the company as anything but bad for Google.
But it’s an interesting thought experiment.
Wow, what insight from you last week.
I’m still not convinced that Google *wants* to be in the handset business but they now have a large defensive patent portfolio that they can potentially use to protect Android from the onslaught of patent lawsuits. It’s going to be interesting to watch this one!
I think at this point they may have no choice but to start influencing handset design and tighter integration of Android on hardware they control. Especially if others start abandoning Android which is a good possibility.
This has been a crazy week!
Why they should: patent arsonel
Why they shouldn’t: MMI sucks
Total solution: Buy MMI, sunset the entire line of handsets, giving 18 months of support to currently deployed handsets, after 18 months fire everyone (except the lawyers because Google needs to replace that little girl they have for Chief Counsel, david drummond) and put the patents in the drawer.
Done
I bow to your impressive foresight. Any thoughts on next week’s lottery numbers?
Ha. I really didn’t think they would do it but as I stated I think it makes sense. I will have another updated analysis soon on the news.
Your predictions come true. :O
+1!
This looks like deja vu.
Actually i beat you Ben, i called for this two weeks ago, when Google bought 1000 patents from IBM. 😛
http://renne.ro/it/google-cumpara-munitie-de-la-ibm-pentru-a-apara-android/234
I hope Google Translate will do.
Meanwhile i would like to point to two potentially blow hits that Android could take.
1- HP buy handset division from Nokia an put webOS on them. This will disrupt everything in the industry, even Apple. HP have enough cash (12 B) and could offer some stock in the new behemoth too. Either they will take it, or Microsoft will be forced to bail out the Finnish company. Nokia on its own cannot survive, it losses 7 points of marketshare in a quarter and now they only have 15p on smartphones. In februaary-march 2012 they will be cheaper than ever. Nokia already wants to sell its network JV with Siemens and they’ll probably be forced by market to sell their Maps division to some like Garmin in order to survive. For Nokia it’s do or die.
2- Dell should buy RIM. For now they are the only big player that has no vertical integration. Dispite their efforts, they couldn’t get a solid ground in smartphones and tablets. And these two fit, they are selling anyway most of their products to businesses. But here Dell would have to compete with Oracle. (14 B in cash vs 20 B in cash). They are on collision course, since Oracle bought Sun Microsystems and become a hardware company. Since the future is mobile, Oracle can’t miss that. And this giant is even more on high end business needs than Google. Either way, both new owners will ask some private equity hawks to chew some of the RIM’s parts. Also, in 2009 Ballmer talked several times he wanted to buy BlackBerry’s maker, not Palm.
If these two don’t act now, it will be much more expensive down the road, the way Google could have had Palm for 1/10th of Moto’s acquisition if they acted last year. Why do you think Apple never brought a patent war to Palm if they were first to “clone” iOS?
PS: Speaking about Palm, i guessed last year that HP will buy them, too :))
http://renne.ro/it/viitorul-suna-groaznic-pentru-palm/234
I am having trouble accessing your links. How do I translate your site? Good points also.
We were having some problems with our site, we moved to other hosting firm. The problem is the site is in Romanian, i hope Google translate is better than at his begginings.
Anyway, the part with HP and webOS is now history, HP is quiting the game after loosing the start :)))
Yes interesting news. I agree with you about Dell but I feel Dell’s path will be similar to HP to get out of hardware.
I agree. After last comments Michael Dell made regardin HP decision to spin off/sell the PC division, Dell seems to get out to services too. But this doesn’t mean an RIM acquisition isn’t verry cheap.
Also, HTC should take the helm for webOS=> since HP seeks to license/sell it and webOS works for now only on Qualcomm chips.
Wow just great to see such a prediction, although being read after the acquisition.
Awesome, I love that you predicted this. Great job!
My developer is trying to persuade me to move to .net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the costs. But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using WordPress on numerous websites for about a year and am worried about switching to another platform. I have heard great things about blogengine.net. Is there a way I can transfer all my wordpress posts into it? Any help would be greatly appreciated!
I am curious to find out what blog system you’re utilizing?I’m having some minor security issues with my latest website and I’d like to find something more risk-free.Do you have any recommendations?
golden nugget online casino – best casino slot games casino slots
Terrific work! This is the type of information that are supposed to be shared across the internet. Shame on the search engines for no longer positioning this post higher! Come on over and talk over with my website . Thanks =)
Thanks for the marvelous posting! I really enjoyed reading it, you might be a great author.I will remember to bookmark your blog and will often come back down the road. I want to encourage you continue your great job, have a nice afternoon!
delta 8 420 sales
Thank you for sharing your knowledge and expertise through this article.
This business lender marketplace has been a literal life saver, we needed more inventory so I applied yesterday morning for a loan and got the funds today! You can find it here: https://www.nationalbusinesscapital.com/apply-now/?ref=6786432
Thanks for your content. One other thing is that if you are disposing your property on your own, one of the concerns you need to be cognizant of upfront is just how to deal with property inspection records. As a FSBO owner, the key to successfully transferring your property and also saving money in real estate agent commission rates is awareness. The more you realize, the smoother your property sales effort will likely be. One area where this is particularly significant is information about home inspections.
Great information shared.. really enjoyed reading this post thank you author for sharing this post .. appreciated
cbd pros delta 8 gummies
Thanks for this insightful information. It really helped me understand the topic better. Nice!
This blog is a fresh look at an old problem. TY! I will be sharing this!
I don抰 even know how I finished up right here, but I thought this submit used to be great. I don’t recognise who you’re however certainly you are going to a famous blogger in the event you are not already 😉 Cheers!
I really enjoyed reading this blog. It’s brief, yet loaded with important details. Thanks!
this is a convoluted explanation you have there!
This article is so insightful! Thanks for sharing your knowledge.
You sound like I do! Spooky!
I’m in bent with the https://organicbodyessentials.com/collections/organic-body-creams ! The serum gave my fleece a youthful encouragement, and the lip balm kept my lips hydrated all day. Knowledgable I’m using clean, straight products makes me desire great. These are second my must-haves payment a inexperienced and nourished look!
I gave https://www.cornbreadhemp.com/products/cbd-sleep-gummies a whack at payment the cardinal habits, and I’m amazed! They tasted distinguished and provided a intelligibility of calmness and relaxation. My stress melted away, and I slept less ill too. These gummies are a game-changer for me, and I highly recommend them to anyone seeking spontaneous pain relief and better sleep.
http://withoutprescription.guru/# non prescription ed pills
I’m gone to convey my little brother, that he
should also visit this webpage on regular basis to get updated from most recent reports.
Attractive section of content. I just stumbled upon your site and in accession capital
to assert that I acquire actually enjoyed account your blog posts.
Any way I’ll be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.
Attractive component of content. I simply stumbled upon your web site and in accession capital
to assert that I acquire in fact loved account your weblog posts.
Anyway I will be subscribing for your augment or even I fulfillment
you get right of entry to consistently fast.
Magnificent beat ! I wish to apprentice while
you amend your website, how could i subscribe
for a blog site? The account helped me a acceptable
deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright clear concept
best online pharmacy india: buy medicines online in india – indian pharmacy paypal
http://withoutprescription.guru/# best non prescription ed pills
I am sure this article has touched all the internet users,
its really really pleasant piece of writing on building
up new webpage.
men’s ed pills: ed medications online – buying ed pills online
http://canadapharm.top/# reddit canadian pharmacy
prescription drugs without doctor approval: non prescription erection pills – non prescription ed drugs
buy prescription drugs without doctor: levitra without a doctor prescription – prescription drugs canada buy online
Tremendous issues here. I am very glad to see your article.
Thank you a lot and I am taking a look forward to contact you.
Will you kindly drop me a mail?
sildenafil citrate medication: best price sildenafil uk – sildenafil 20 mg mexico
non prescription ed drugs best ed pill best ed drugs
No matter if some one searches for his required thing, therefore
he/she wants to be available that in detail, thus that thing is
maintained over here.
http://kamagra.team/# Kamagra tablets
sildenafil in canada: sildenafil 100mg price – sildenafil discount coupon
compare ed drugs natural ed remedies ed drug prices
Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to say that I’ve truly enjoyed surfing around your blog posts.
After all I will be subscribing to your feed and
I hope you write again very soon!
how much is sildenafil from canada: sildenafil 6mg – buy sildenafil no rx
CBD, or cannabidiol, has been a feign changer because me. Delta 8 Pre Roll I’ve struggled with longing in return years and force tried assorted various medications, but nothing has worked as well as CBD. It helps me to feel undisturbed and easygoing without any side effects. I also obtain that it helps with take and trial management. I’ve tried various brands, but I’ve inaugurate that the ones that are lab tested and play a joke on a good position are the most effective. Complete, I importantly recommend CBD in behalf of anyone who struggles with foreboding, be in the land of nod issues, or lasting pain.
https://tadalafil.trade/# generic tadalafil from canada
I’ve been browsing on-line greater than 3 hours today, but I by no means discovered
any attention-grabbing article like yours. It is lovely
price sufficient for me. In my view, if all website
owners and bloggers made excellent content material
as you did, the web shall be much more useful than ever before.
Buy Vardenafil online: Generic Levitra 20mg – Levitra 10 mg buy online
cheap kamagra Kamagra tablets п»їkamagra
ed pills gnc erection pills that work new ed treatments
Generic Levitra 20mg: Buy Vardenafil online – Vardenafil price
https://kamagra.team/# cheap kamagra
buy sildenafil 100mg online in usa sildenafil 20 mg discount coupon generic viagra sildenafil 100mg
best ed pills online: men’s ed pills – erectile dysfunction medications
https://edpills.monster/# top ed pills
https://ciprofloxacin.men/# ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online
zestril brand name: buy lisinopril – lisinopril 3
buying lisinopril online prescription for lisinopril zestril 10 mg in india
https://azithromycin.bar/# zithromax capsules price
doxycycline cap 40mg: Buy Doxycycline for acne – doxycycline singapore
buy lisinopril 40 mg online Over the counter lisinopril purchase lisinopril 10 mg
https://amoxicillin.best/# buy amoxicillin 500mg online
zithromax for sale us: zithromax z-pak – zithromax for sale 500 mg
can i buy lisinopril in mexico Buy Lisinopril 20 mg online lisinopril 2019
http://lisinopril.auction/# lisinopril 10mg tablets
generic amoxicillin online: amoxicillin 500mg capsules antibiotic – amoxicillin 500 mg without prescription
doxycycline 300 mg cost doxycycline buy online doxycycline 100 mg cap over the counter
https://doxycycline.forum/# doxycycline tablets where to buy
doxycycline 100 mg price uk: buy doxycycline over the counter – rx doxycycline 100mg
http://amoxicillin.best/# amoxil pharmacy
where can i get zithromax: zithromax antibiotic – zithromax z-pak
https://mexicopharmacy.store/# buying from online mexican pharmacy
online shopping pharmacy india: world pharmacy india – india pharmacy mail order
onlinecanadianpharmacy: canadian drugs – canadian pharmacy 24h com safe
http://buydrugsonline.top/# canadian pharmaceuticals
indian pharmacy paypal: best online pharmacy india – india pharmacy mail order
canada rx pharmacy world: canada pharmacy online – canadian neighbor pharmacy
http://indiapharmacy.site/# best online pharmacy india
mail order pharmacy india: cheapest online pharmacy india – best online pharmacy india
Hi there! I know this is kind of off topic but I was
wondering if you knew where I could get a captcha plugin for my comment form?
I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having trouble finding
one? Thanks a lot!
http://paxlovid.club/# buy paxlovid online
ventolin 6.7g: ventolin 4 mg tabs – ventolin free shipping
http://claritin.icu/# how much is ventolin
neurontin capsule 600mg: cheap gabapentin – neurontin 204
https://paxlovid.club/# Paxlovid over the counter
paxlovid covid https://paxlovid.club/# paxlovid
http://gabapentin.life/# brand name neurontin price
cost of clomid no prescription: Buy Clomid Online Without Prescription – buying generic clomid prices
neurontin 100 mg: cheap gabapentin – neurontin price india
https://wellbutrin.rest/# wellbutrin sr 150
Aw, this was a really good post. Finding the time and actual effort to create a good
article… but what can I say… I put things off a whole
lot and don’t seem to get nearly anything done.
how much is generic neurontin: gabapentin best price – neurontin
https://clomid.club/# order clomid
acquistare farmaci senza ricetta avanafil generico prezzo farmacie on line spedizione gratuita
siti sicuri per comprare viagra online: viagra prezzo – alternativa al viagra senza ricetta in farmacia
farmacie online sicure: farmacia online miglior prezzo – farmacia online
farmacie online autorizzate elenco: avanafil prezzo – migliori farmacie online 2023
farmacia online piГ№ conveniente: dove acquistare cialis online sicuro – farmacia online miglior prezzo
viagra online spedizione gratuita: sildenafil prezzo – viagra generico in farmacia costo
farmacia online migliore kamagra gel farmacie online autorizzate elenco
comprare farmaci online all’estero: kamagra gel prezzo – farmacie on line spedizione gratuita
comprare farmaci online con ricetta: farmacia online – farmacie on line spedizione gratuita
https://farmaciait.pro/# acquisto farmaci con ricetta
top farmacia online: farmacia online spedizione gratuita – farmacie online affidabili
farmacia online: kamagra oral jelly consegna 24 ore – top farmacia online
farmacia online piГ№ conveniente Farmacie che vendono Cialis senza ricetta farmacia online
comprare farmaci online con ricetta: kamagra gel prezzo – farmaci senza ricetta elenco
farmaci senza ricetta elenco: farmacia online miglior prezzo – acquistare farmaci senza ricetta
https://sildenafilit.bid/# viagra online spedizione gratuita
farmacia online migliore: farmacia online più conveniente – farmaci senza ricetta elenco
acquisto farmaci con ricetta: avanafil prezzo in farmacia – farmacia online migliore
viagra pfizer 25mg prezzo: viagra prezzo farmacia – viagra online spedizione gratuita
farmacia online migliore kamagra gel prezzo farmacia online piГ№ conveniente
п»їviagra prezzo farmacia 2023: viagra online siti sicuri – viagra ordine telefonico
top farmacia online: farmacia online – farmacie online affidabili
comprare farmaci online all’estero: avanafil – migliori farmacie online 2023