Why Robot Umpires are Inevitable in Baseball’s Future

I have been a baseball fan since I was eight years old. Being born in the San Francisco Bay Area, the SF Giants were my team growing up, and I became a fan during the era of Willie Mays, Willie McCovey, and Orlando Cepeda.

I also got a chance to play baseball in Jr High and High school and was a catcher with a pretty good hitting average. I was too thin and short then to even consider playing baseball beyond high school and instead became an ardent baseball fan as well as a student of the game instead.

As a fan, I have watched games and viewed plays hundreds of times that I thought the umpire got wrong. For most of my life, we did not have instant replays where an umpire could review a play if one of the managers challenged their decision. But this process takes time and slows down the game.

As a technologist, I have watched baseball games more closely with an eye on how technology could be used to call balls and strikes, which is one of the most subjective actions done by an umpire during a game. It appears that each umpire has their own version of a strike zone, and as they say, “call it as they see it.” But with TV broadcasts superimposing a true strike zone graphic based on a batter’s stance, a TV viewer can actually see if the pitch is a strike or a ball.

While umpires traditionally have an accuracy rate of between 90-95% with their calls, the calls they do miss could clearly impact everything from a batter’s statistics to the final outcome of the game. Instant replay does help with field calls, but cannot be used today to change a ball or strike decision.

Knowing technology as I do, and the power and accuracy of things like sensors, radar, laser guidance systems, and imaging, it has been clear to me for some time that the technology is already here that could enable robot umpires to assist real umpires in calling truly accurate balls and strikes.

Earlier this month, the Independent Atlantic League became the first American professional baseball league to let a computer call balls and strikes at their All-Star game.

ESPN was there and wrote about how the plate umpire used technology to help him call balls and strikes:

“Plate umpire Brian deBrauwere wore an earpiece connected to an iPhone in his pocket and relayed the call upon receiving it from a TrackMan computer system that uses Doppler radar.

He crouched in his normal position behind the catcher and signaled balls and strikes.

“Until we can trust this system 100 percent, I still have to go back there with the intention of getting a pitch correct, because if the system fails, it doesn’t pick a pitch up, or if it registers a pitch that’s a foot-and-a-half off the plate as a strike, I have to be prepared to correct that,” deBrauwere said before the game.

It didn’t appear that deBrauwere had any delay receiving the calls at first, but players noticed a big difference.
“One time I already had caught the ball back from the catcher, and he signaled strike,” said pitcher Daryl Thompson, who didn’t realize the technology was being used until he disagreed with the call.

Infielder L.J. Mazzilli said a few times that hitters who struck out lingered an extra second or so in the batter’s box waiting on a called third strike.

“The future is crazy, but it’s cool to see the direction of baseball,” Mazzilli said.”

Up to now, Major League Baseball and especially the umpires have been opposed to using technology to call balls and strikes. From the Umpires view, they see this as eventually taking away the need for them altogether. But the way technology was used in The Atlantic League All-Star game fully engaged the umpire and really just gave him a new tool besides his eyes and subjective reasoning to make sure his calls were more accurate.

I believe there are two solid reasons why we will eventually have robot umpires call balls and strikes to make the game more accurate in terms of calling pitches correctly.

The first is one that technology can help keep baseball interesting and relevant to a younger generation who, at the moment, are not embracing baseball as wholeheartedly as their parents have in the past. And attendance at games has been down for the last three years.

“Of the league’s 30 teams, 18 are experiencing an attendance drop. And this is after a 2018 season in which attendance was down more than 3 million fans, an average of 1,237 per game.”

Millennials and Gen Zer’s are technology savvy and have many ways to entertain themselves these days. Their interests are spread thin, and baseball is just one of the things they may have an interest in. And given the tech-savviness of this younger generation, they most likely see how technology could enhance a game and make its outcome more accurate, which could increase their interest in baseball games and draw them to viewing them on TV or the Internet or going to a ballpark itself.

But the most important reason that I believe robot umpires are inevitable is legalized sports gambling. I personally am not a gambler but have watched this “industry” with great interest over the last three decades. I have become even more interested in sports gambling now that it has started to infiltrate eSports.

The Supreme Court recently ruled that a federal ban on sports wagering is unconstitutional.

Here is the conclusion of the majority opinion:

The legalization of sports gambling requires an important policy choice, but the choice is not ours to make. Congress can regulate sports gambling directly, but if it elects not to do so, each State is free to act on its own. Our job is to interpret the law Congress has enacted and decided whether it is consistent with the Constitution. PASPA is not. PASPA “regulate[s] state governments’ regulation” of their citizens. …. The Constitution gives Congress no such power. The judgment of the Third Circuit is reversed.

With this ruling, the courts have been given the choice of allowing sports gambling up to the states themselves. Here is a link to the States that already allow sports gambling and the current bills in the works from the States that do not allow sports betting yet, but proposed laws are working its way through their legislators.

Right after the Supreme Court ruling was announced, MLB released this statement.

Major League Baseball:

“Today’s decision by the Supreme Court will have profound effects on Major League Baseball. As each state considers whether to allow sports betting, we will continue to seek the proper protections for our sport, in partnership with other professional sports. Our most important priority is protecting the integrity of our games. We will continue to support legislation that promotes air-tight coordination and partnerships between the State, the casino operators, and the governing bodies in sports toward that goal.”

Once sports gambling becomes legal throughout most of the US, the pressure will be on MLB executives to integrate technology to call balls and strikes in both leagues. One thing that gamblers hate is subjective opinions that impact the potential outcome of a game. They want every call to be as accurate as possible so that their bets can be made based on quality data.

Of course, old-timers and baseball traditionalists will fight bringing robot umpires into the game. I have talked to quite a few of these folks, and their attitude is that without technology, the game is played as it has for over 100 years and robot umpires to them would be blasphemy.

However, Major League Baseball is not only a game but also a $10 billion industry and has to be willing to change with the times. They know that without some serious changes and adjustments, they could lose the next generation of younger fans. If that happens, their growth in the future will decline.

Sports gambling will also put pressure on MLB leadership as it expands throughout the US and professional and weekend sports gamblers want more ways to make the game more accurate to assist in their own analysis on their betting decisions.

I don’t know how long it will be before we get robot umpires calling balls and strikes, but the technology is here to do it today. Robot umpires are inevitable, and it will only be a matter of time before it happens.

Published by

Tim Bajarin

Tim Bajarin is the President of Creative Strategies, Inc. He is recognized as one of the leading industry consultants, analysts and futurists covering the field of personal computers and consumer technology. Mr. Bajarin has been with Creative Strategies since 1981 and has served as a consultant to most of the leading hardware and software vendors in the industry including IBM, Apple, Xerox, Compaq, Dell, AT&T, Microsoft, Polaroid, Lotus, Epson, Toshiba and numerous others.

4,592 thoughts on “Why Robot Umpires are Inevitable in Baseball’s Future”

    1. Недавно мне понадобилось 19 000 рублей на оплату курсов. В Twitter я нашел ссылку на yelbox.ru. Там представлены советы о том, как взять займы на карту онлайн , и список надежных МФО. И даже организации, предоставляющие займы без процентов!

    2. В ночное время сложно найти финансовую помощь, но портал wikzaim всегда к вашим услугам. Я лично убедился в этом, когда срочно нуждался в деньгах и мгновенно получил их от двух микрофинансовых организаций, найденных на сайте.

    3. В поиске казино на деньги в Яндексе я обнаружил сайт caso-slots.com. Здесь мне предложили широкий выбор казино с игровыми автоматами, бонусы на депозит и статьи о том, как правильно играть, чтобы выиграть. Теперь я готов к победам!

    4. Решил устроить романтический вечер для жены. Заказал на “Цветов.ру” букет роз и украсил им наш ужин. Рекомендация: добавьте свежести в вашу жизнь с помощью цветов, и “Цветов.ру” в этом ваш надежный союзник. Советую! Вот ссылка https://nep08.ru/oskol/ – букеты

    5. После решения вести здоровый образ жизни, я осознал необходимость в соковыжималке механической. ‘Все соки’ предоставили мне именно то, что мне нужно. Их механическая соковыжималка проста в использовании и очень эффективна. https://h-100.ru/collection/ruchnye-shnekovye-sokovyzhimalki – Соковыжималка механическая стала моим незаменимым помощником.

    6. Переход на здоровое питание подтолкнул меня к покупке маслопресса. ‘Все соки’ предложили именно то, что мне было нужно. Теперь я делаю своё собственное масло, что невероятно удобно и полезно. https://blender-bs5.ru/collection/maslopressy – Маслопресс купить – это было лучшее решение для моего здоровья!

    1. Откройте для себя волшебный мир отдыха в Туапсе. Мы предлагаем уникальное сочетание качественного сервиса, комфорта и домашнего уюта. Ваши впечатления и эмоции – наш главный приоритет!

      Позвольте себе роскошь наслаждаться каждым моментом, проведенным в наших отелях, где современные удобства встречаются с традиционным гостеприимством. Насладитесь магией Туапсе в 2023 году!

    2. Сегодня я наткнулся на сайт caso-slots.com и был приятно удивлен. Здесь собраны все популярные казино и даже есть список тех, где можно получить бонус на первый депозит. Ожидание игры наполняет меня азартом!

    1. Хотя далеко от родителей, я не забыл о Дне Матери. Заказал на “Цветов.ру” букет для мамы. Она была в восторге от красоты цветов и волнующего сюрприза. Рекомендую всем, кто ценит прекрасные моменты в жизни. Советую! Вот ссылка https://covideducation.ru/astr/ – букеты

    2. Решил устроить романтический вечер для жены. Заказал на “Цветов.ру” букет роз и украсил им наш ужин. Рекомендация: добавьте свежести в вашу жизнь с помощью цветов, и “Цветов.ру” в этом ваш надежный союзник. Советую! Вот ссылка https://%D0%B0%D0%B2%D0%B8%D1%82%D0%BE-%D0%BC%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B2%D0%B0.%D1%80%D1%84/ekb/ – цветы букеты

  1. Привет всем! Я всегда мечтал испытать азарт онлайн-казино, и наконец решился. После небольшого поиска я нашел сайт caso-slots.com, где представлены все популярные казино и даже список тех, где можно получить бонус на первый депозит. Это точно то, что я искал!

  2. После долгих поисков я нашел отличный ресурс caso-slots.com, где собраны все популярные казино и представлен список тех, где можно получить бонус на первый депозит. Мое приключение в мир азарта начинается именно здесь!

  3. Захотелось азарта, и я решил найти казино на деньги через Яндекс. На первом месте был сайт caso-slots.com, где представлены различные казино с игровыми автоматами, бонусы на депозит и статьи с советами по игре. Все, что нужно для успешной игры!

  4. Захотелось новых ощущений и я решил попробовать поиграть в онлайн казино. Сайт caso-slots.com стал моим проводником в этот мир. Теперь у меня есть список популярных казино и тех, где можно получить бонус на первый депозит.

  5. Всегда хотел попробовать свои силы в онлайн казино, и вот я нашел caso-slots.com. Здесь собраны все популярные казино и даже есть список тех, где можно получить бонус на первый депозит. Это просто супер!

  6. Решив испытать удачу в казино на деньги, я обратился к Яндексу и нашел сайт caso-slots.com на первом месте. Сайт предлагает множество казино с игровыми автоматами, бонусы на депозит и статьи, которые помогут мне играть правильно и выиграть.

  7. После долгих поисков я нашел отличный ресурс caso-slots.com, где собраны все популярные казино и представлен список тех, где можно получить бонус на первый депозит. Мое приключение в мир азарта начинается именно здесь!

  8. Искал в Яндексе казино на деньги и сразу же наткнулся на caso-slots.com. Сайт предлагает обширный выбор казино с игровыми автоматами, бонусы на депозит и статьи с советами по игре, что помогает мне разобраться, как увеличить свои шансы на выигрыш.

  9. Я ввел в Яндекс запрос “казино на деньги” и первым в списке был сайт caso-slots.com. Здесь я нашел множество казино с игровыми автоматами, а также бонусы на депозит и статьи с полезными советами по игре, что сделало мой выбор в пользу этого сайта еще увереннее.

  10. Всегда хотел попробовать свои силы в онлайн казино, и вот я нашел caso-slots.com. Здесь собраны все популярные казино и даже есть список тех, где можно получить бонус на первый депозит. Это просто супер!

  11. онлайн казино brillx сайт
    Играя на Brillx Казино, вы можете быть уверены в честности и безопасности своих данных. Мы используем передовые технологии для защиты информации наших игроков, так что вы можете сосредоточиться исключительно на игре и наслаждаться процессом без каких-либо сомнений или опасений.Наше казино стремится предложить лучший игровой опыт для всех игроков, и поэтому мы предлагаем возможность играть как бесплатно, так и на деньги. Если вы новичок и хотите потренироваться перед серьезной игрой, то вас приятно удивят бесплатные режимы игр. Они помогут вам разработать стратегии и привыкнуть к особенностям каждого игрового автомата.

  12. An impressive share! I’ve just forwarded this onto a
    coworker who has been conducting a little homework on this.
    And he actually ordered me lunch simply because I discovered it for
    him… lol. So let me reword this…. Thanks for the meal!!

    But yeah, thanx for spending some time to talk about
    this matter here on your site.

  13. At this time it sounds like Expression Engine is the best blogging platform out there
    right now. (from what I’ve read) Is that
    what you’re using on your blog?

  14. Now email rewards are something you get from email inbox. All you need to do is to submit your email address to coin master for daily free spins. Now you wonder how to submit email to coin master? Its an automatic system by coin master. The game it self give you an opportunity to sign up for email rewards. Submit your email and coin master will surprise you with number of free coin master spins link and coins. It is incredibly easy to redeem the links in this idle game. First, you need Coin Master installed and an active internet connection on your device. This website is found not only in the English language but also in a lot of different languages. So, you can search in you own language. A few examples:– Polish: darmowe spiny Coin Master 2020– Spanish: tiradas gratis enlace Coin Master– Romanian: spinuri gratis– Hindi: कॉइन मास्टर फ्री स्पिन– Italian: giri gratuiti Coin Master– Dutch: Coin Master gratis spins– Indonesian: berputar bebasAnd Google sends them to our website for free spins. Really like how Google knows what you all need!
    Copyright 2000-2023. All rights reserved. Rockstar Games recently announced GTA Plus for GTA Online, which promises exclusive player benefits for a monthly fee. It’s likely to be of interest to the more dedicated players, who invest tens of hours into the game each month. However, are those on PS4 and Xbox One able to get the GTA+ subscription? Or is it limited to next-gen PS5 and Xbox Series X|S players only? Here’s the need-to-know info about the GTA Plus last-gen subscription. New and improved versions of GTA V and GTA Online released for the latest consoles, the PS5 and Xbox Series X|S, last year. This new hardware gives the developers far more resources to work with whilst the next entry in the Grand Theft Auto series is in the works. Performance of these new versions have been very good allowing for 60FPS, ray tracing, 4K and more fidelity. Creating content for the Xbox One, One S, One X, PS4, PS4 Pro and the PC is a lot; adding three more consoles into the pool even more work for the teams.