Spectrum: Where It Came From, Where It Goes

Dark Side of the Moon album cover

In the the beginning, wireless spectrum in the U.S. was free. In  1983, the Federal Communications Commission created the first analog cellular networks by assigning two chunks of airwaves in the 800 MHz band. One chunk was reserved for the incumbent local wireline carrier, or Baby Bell as they were then known. This ancient history is important because the leg up that was given to the companies that gradually coalesced into Verizon Wireless and AT&T formed the basis for these carriers’ domination of the U.S. market. The story of spectrum over the past three decades is mostly a tale of the rich getting richer, all the while bemoaning their poverty.

Over time, the government assigned more and more spectrum to wireless voice and (eventually) data. New competitors did arise. Sprint, until then primarily a wireline long-distance operator, created its network out of the 1994 auction of 1900 MHz “personal communications services” spectrum. Wireless phone pioneer Craig McCaw built the Nextel network out of bits and pieces of “special mobile radio” licenses intended for dispatch services. T-Mobile and its predecessors assembled a bunch of smaller carriers using the GSM standard, which was then widely used everywhere but the U.S.

But through auctions and acquisitions, the biggest carriers managed to get even bigger. The last major wireless spectrum auction was the 2007 sale of television bandwidth that had been freed by completion of the transition to digital TV broadcasting. To the surprise of just about no one, the overwhelming winners in the sales  were Verizon and AT&T, which have been using the spectrum in the 700 MHz band to build out their fourth-generation LTE networks.

The problem we now face is that after 30 years of freeing bandwidth for mobile data use, we’ve pretty much run out of spectrum that can be reassigned without a major fight. The only sale on the horizon is an additional 100 MHz of TV bandwidth. But among many other complexities, availability of this spectrum will require some stations to give up their licenses (in exchange for a share of the proceeds from the auction) and others to move to new frequencies to create usable blocks of contiguous spectrum. The convoluted process mandated by Congress means that the sales won;t begin until 2014 (at the earliest) and are likely to yield a good bit less than 100 MHz in many parts of the country.The problem we now face is that after 30 years of freeing bandwidth for mobile data use, we’ve pretty much run out of spectrum that can be reassigned without a major fight.

In the absence of new allocations coming down the pike, Verizon and AT&T have been bulking up on spectrum through mergers and acquisitions. AT&T failed to convince Justice Dept. anti-trusters that its need for spectrum justified its proposed 2011 acquisition of T-Mobile. It announced on Jan. 22 that it intends to acquire the remainder of regional carrier Alltel, the bulk of which was bought by Verizon in 2008. Verizon is buying the spectrum of a consortium of cable companies, which once had dreams of building their own wireless networks.

The incumbent wireless carriers insist that the system is header for crisis without additional bandwidth and the the best, and perhaps only, way to get it is by selling them the rights to spectrum currently held by others. In a post on a the AT&T public policy blog, Joan Marsh, vice-president, federal regulatory, responded to a recommendation that sharing spectrum with federal agencies might be a good way to increase capacity, saying:

The Report [of the President’s Council of Advisors on Science & Technology] found that the new norm for spectrum use should be sharing, not exclusive licensing.  While we agree that sharing paradigms should be explored as another option for spectrum management, sharing technologies have been long promised but remain largely unproven.  The over-eager pursuit of unlicensed sharing models cannot turn a blind eye on the model proven to deliver investment, innovation, and jobs–exclusive licensing.  Industry and government alike must continue with the hard work of clearing and licensing under-utilized government spectrum where feasible.

John Marinho, vice-president of technology and cyber security for CTIA-The Wireless Association, which speaks for the wireless incumbents, wrote:

Trust me, the carriers are deploying and using every single technology and “trick” they can to try to solve the looming spectrum crisis in the near-term, but nothing will solve the problem like more spectrum. Claude Shannon proved that there are practical limits to how much bandwidth capacity is available from a limited amount of spectrum. One has to look no further than the father of information theory to realize that the solution is more spectrum.

I’ll have more to say about Shannon’s laws and its implications for wireless networks in future installments, but the truth is that there are lots of techniques for expanding the capacity of wireless networks that have yet to be deployed in any serious way. Martin Cooper, who built the first cellphone for Motorola before there was a network to use it on, says: “I can tell you that the way not to create more spectrum is to redistribute it. And that is what the government is proposing to do now, take it away from some people and give it to others. That’s not going to do it.”

The next articles in this series will explore some better ways.

 

Published by

Steve Wildstrom

Steve Wildstrom is veteran technology reporter, writer, and analyst based in the Washington, D.C. area. He created and wrote BusinessWeek’s Technology & You column for 15 years. Since leaving BusinessWeek in the fall of 2009, he has written his own blog, Wildstrom on Tech and has contributed to corporate blogs, including those of Cisco and AMD and also consults for major technology companies.

1,119 thoughts on “Spectrum: Where It Came From, Where It Goes”

  252. A different issue is that video gaming became one of the all-time greatest forms of entertainment for people spanning various ages. Kids enjoy video games, and also adults do, too. The actual XBox 360 is one of the favorite video games systems for folks who love to have a huge variety of games available to them, along with who like to experiment with live with some others all over the world. Thank you for sharing your notions.

    Reply

  276. Hey there! I’m at work browsing your blog from my new apple iphone! Just wanted to say I love reading through your blog and look forward to all your posts! Carry on the excellent work!

    Reply

  278. Thanks for your post. I also believe that laptop computers are becoming more and more popular currently, and now in many cases are the only kind of computer included in a household. This is because at the same time that they are becoming more and more very affordable, their working power is growing to the point where these are as robust as personal computers coming from just a few in years past.

    Reply

  1018. Esto siempre depende la preferencia de los jugadores. Por lo que existen ciertos aspectos a considerar relevantes antes de realizar la jugada. Uno de ellos es el conocimiento que debe poseer el jugador sobre el funcionamiento del juego. Otro aspecto, es la capacidad de emplear estrategias de juego como en el blackJack o póker que requieran de estas para ganar. Hay jugadores que se arriesgan y dejan que el azar haga su trabajo, por lo que prefieren tragamonedas, ruletas y dados. El bono de bienvenida sin depósito de JVSpin disponible con nuestro código de promoción es también muy generoso, es uno de los mejores bonos sin depósito de casino. Puedes aumentar tu número de giros gratis sin depósito simplemente utilizando nuestro código. ¡Todas las noticias sobre criptomonedas hoy en un solo email!
    https://www.smfsimple.com/ultimateportaldemo/index.php?action=profile;area=summary;u=434219
    Como ya mencionamos en otra publicación la Casa de Apuestas y el Casino han trabajado en conjunto para convertir la celebración de la Champions en un momento más inolvidable aún. Con un partido narrado en directo por Javier Lázaro, una deliciosa cena, la presencia de una figura del fútbol valenciano como David Albelda, la posibilidad de realizar apuestas y la exquisita victoria del Club Blanco; convirtieron la jornada en una experiencia única para sus asistentes. A continuación ofrecemos el comunicado emitido por la Compañía… Sportium Casino es uno de los portales web que podemos encontrar en el mercado regulado español. Tiene una oferta destacada en todos los sentidos, permitiendo a los usuarios disfrutar de una gran variedad de juegos de casino online, aunque también se lucen con una gran sección de apuestas deportivas, Sportium apuestas.

    Reply

  1075. One of the fastest growing areas in the world of online gambling is that of football betting in-play. Traditionally punters would make their selections before a football match has started and have to wait for the game to finish before settling their bets. We understand fully well that some factors like injuries, weather condition, suspensions, past performance, current form, historical meetings, nature of competition, early bookings, the psychology of both the players and team playing, and some other secondary factors might determine the outcome of a fixture that is why we have a team a dedicated, unbiased and well-informed experts tipsters that use algorithms and well-calculated research to do all the rigorous work in order to produce quality football tips that you can rely on. It is our passion to see you WIN!
    https://eduardoxbeg827150.acidblog.net/57426470/perri-match
    Looking for something to bet on tomorrow? There are some great football events coming up and your aim is to place a winning bet. If that is the case, then you’ve come to the right place! On this page you can find all our predictions for tomorrow’s football matches. Do you want to take advantage of the football predictions written by our specialists? All you need to do it’s to click on the match you are interested in and get a detailed analysis. Being Rated As The Best Football Prediction Site Makes Us Go The Extra Mile In Using Statistics And Forms Of Various Football Teams To Deliver Good Football Betting Tips. Above you can see the most popular football predictions on OLBG today, so this page is perfect if you need some football tips for tonight. If you click on the tips and comments tab in the menu you will sort the tips by volume and then you can view the list in order of popularity. Popular tips at OLBG are sometimes called hot football tips. 

    Reply

Leave a Reply to OliverRet Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *