One of the things I am excited to do with our Tech.pinions Insider content, is dive into subjects that may be more controversial than things we want floating around in the public sphere. So that is what I hope to do with this topic and the question at large in which I raise.
A balanced opinion of anything these days is generally hard to find. So many topics are extremely polarizing, for lack of a better word. Politics are perhaps one of the most universally polarizing topics for the general public. However in tech circles few topics are more currently polarizing than Apple. I recently lobbed the question of why Apple is so polarizing on a new discussion platform called Branch. Thanks for the many who added to the thread with many smart comments as they further helped me flesh out my thoughts on the subject.
We have to acknowledge that the general public does not seem to fall into the crowd with highly polarized opinions of Apple the company and its products. Rather it is centered more around the tech elite (early adopters) and many mainstream technology media and pundits. I see this on a daily basis as I write quite a bit about Apple for Tech.pinions and for TIME. The comments I get from the anti-Apple crowd are simply astonishing. I also follow a great many of pro and anti-Apple folks on Twitter. You can tell who these people are because they either regularly write or tweet extremely negative, Apple is doomed, hooray their reign is over articles, or they write or tweet extremely positive articles point out why Apple is not doomed and their reign is not over. It seems that generally speaking there is very little grey area around the topic of Apple in these circles.
In either case I am fascinated by how this came to be and why it still exists today. I have several theories to share.
Loyalty to my Tribe
There is simply no question humans routinely exhibit tribal behavior. There are elements of this mentality in the polarization of politics but there is no better example than in sports. Extreme loyalty for ones sports team and utter disdain for rival teams is prevalent in many sports fans. Some of this can be engrained by upbringing but it is also learned by time spent in the tribe. I have seen first hand the evolution of fans of local sports who start as a casual fan then evolve into a fanatic. It seems as though it is tradition as a part of that tribe to largely hate for no good reason rival tribes.
This tribal behavior is what I am certain is at the root of most polarizing issues and in particular the on about Apple. But a deeper issue still exists. Why do we end up in certain tribes.
Personal Preference
This is where personal preference comes into play. Those who are the most vocal and either attack or defend (or both) the decisions of others, are doing so because of the highly specific personal reasons they choose one product or another. Mature consumers know what they want and why they want it. Often when you come to make a purchase with such a level of personal preference as something like a personal computer, you don’t make the decision lightly. Each platform whether it be Windows, Android, or Apple’s, appeal to different audiences for very different reasons; all of them extremely personal in nature. When we make decisions at such a deeply personal level we often believe those decisions to be superior to the decisions of others.
This is why we see such heated debate, in my opinion, by the most fervent of consumers. If you followed or chimed in on many of the comments on John Kirks recent series you noted some of this, largely from the Android camp. I’ve seen this as well from the Apple camp but you, our regular readers and commenters, are much more balanced and sane no matter which camp you are in. However, I notice that those most passionate work very hard to justify their decisions and rationalize that others should be making the same decisions as them. Again, I am generalizing, but I think it is a worth while point in the discussion.
A while ago I opened up this topic as a branch. I’ll share a few summaries of key points that folks chimed in on below.
From Jan Dawson:
It taps into lots of larger themes – elitism, gargantuan profits, the power of brand, marketing, design, style etc. vs. substance, closed vs. open. So much of what’s ostensibly about Apple specifically is really about these larger themes and people’s strong feelings about which side of each of those tensions is right. And once you have strong feelings on both side, that just escalates beyond all reason and it’s no longer a rational argument (see also American politics).
From Shawn King:
A certain portion, the majority, of Apple’s customers just used the machines. But a vocal minority felt the need to stand up and defend their platform. Thus began the PC vs Mac Wars. It was the form of that defense – strident, unyielding, dickish at times, that helped to cause the polarization.
The internet “helped” and exacerbated the polarization.
From Walt French:
Apple has always been on a gee-whiz crusade and of course, the infidels hate that. Since 1984, the infidels have been the entire IT establishment, a confederation that needed and still needs benefits of network effects under Microsoft’s hegemony. So each $1 of Apple’s successes might threaten $2 of Establishment. Lots at stake.
From Ryan Buckwalter:
It’s all because of attitude; the attitude of the company, their leaders, their PR, and their overzealous fans. Any Apple product is generally a fine product, usually with good parts in a fairly well design package, but the attitude is that these products some how magically transcend their parts into being something far more, something without flaw and beyond the reach of any other product; thus worth the high asking price. These Apple products aren’t shown “as they are” but instead in a form of “perfection” and “simplicity” as if they really were made of “magic”. This would be great and all… if it were true, but it’s not. Apple products are often flawed, poorly designed, etc. The attitude is to ignore those flaws as they never existed.
Lastly, here is a link to Marco Arment’s post on the subject.
I’d love to open this up to a discussion with our members. So feel free to add and chime in.
Is the choice between Mac or PC really that personal? Is it really even a decision?
My first personal computer was a PC with DOS, because that was what my dad used. My dad in turn had a PC with DOS because that was what he needed for his job. Currently I’m very much enjoying my Mac, but only because a few years back I had the opportunity to finally become independent enough from the windows environment I was working in.
I did make a personal decision by switching to Mac, but those years that I used Windows really was not my decision at all. On the one hand I do not expect that the lack of a personal decision is conductive to fanatic support. On the other hand, I expect that in such cases the mindset of superiority could still be established due to the high value we award to the opinions of those close to us.
buying from online mexican pharmacy mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
mexican drugstore online medication from mexico pharmacy medicine in mexico pharmacies
https://mexicanph.com/# reputable mexican pharmacies online
best online pharmacies in mexico
mexican pharmacy buying from online mexican pharmacy purple pharmacy mexico price list
purple pharmacy mexico price list mexico pharmacies prescription drugs pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
mexican pharmaceuticals online purple pharmacy mexico price list purple pharmacy mexico price list
mexican rx online mexico drug stores pharmacies buying prescription drugs in mexico online
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa mexican mail order pharmacies mexico drug stores pharmacies
lisinopril 20 mg generic: generic zestril – price of lisinopril 20 mg
medicine amoxicillin 500mg: where to buy amoxicillin 500mg – amoxicillin pills 500 mg
200 mg prednisone daily: buy cheap prednisone – buy prednisone tablets uk
lasix 100mg: Over The Counter Lasix – lasix
prednisone 50 mg canada: prednisone buying – purchase prednisone 10mg
buy furosemide online: Over The Counter Lasix – lasix for sale
amoxil generic: amoxicillin tablet 500mg – amoxicillin generic
generic for amoxicillin: amoxicillin order online – amoxicillin without prescription
lasix furosemide: Buy Furosemide – buy lasix online
zestril 10mg: buy cheap lisinopril 40 mg no prescription – cost of generic lisinopril 10 mg
furosemida: Buy Lasix – lasix 20 mg
stromectol prices: stromectol ivermectin buy – how to buy stromectol
lasix pills: Buy Furosemide – lasix generic
how much is ivermectin: ivermectin 1%cream – ivermectin 3
buy lisinopril 20 mg without prescription: lisinopril 5 mg pill – lisinopril 2.5
25 mg lisinopril: lisinopril 20 – where to buy lisinopril online
50 mg prednisone tablet prednisone 60 mg tablet purchase prednisone from india
buy lisinopril 20 mg without prescription: lisinopril 200 mg – lisinopril 10 mg online
amoxicillin 500 mg tablet: buying amoxicillin in mexico – where to buy amoxicillin pharmacy
buy amoxicillin online mexico: medicine amoxicillin 500mg – amoxicillin cephalexin
furosemide 100mg: Over The Counter Lasix – lasix 100mg
https://indianph.com/# Online medicine order
Abortion pills online: order cytotec online – buy cytotec pills
cipro: buy cipro cheap – cipro 500mg best prices
tamoxifen premenopausal: nolvadex side effects – pct nolvadex
doxycycline hyc: doxy 200 – doxycycline 500mg
tamoxifen rash pictures: nolvadex for sale – how to prevent hair loss while on tamoxifen
Angela White video: abella danger filmleri – Abella Danger
?????? ????: abella danger izle – abella danger video
Sweetie Fox filmleri: Sweetie Fox video – Sweetie Fox video
Sweetie Fox: Sweetie Fox modeli – Sweetie Fox
Angela White filmleri: Abella Danger – Abella Danger
lana rhoades video: lana rhoades video – lana rhoades
eva elfie video: eva elfie izle – eva elfie izle
The latest fake watch is reminiscent of the very first Heuer Monza watch, which was launched in 1976 to celebrate Niki Lauda’s Formula 1 World Championship victory in 1975.
Angela White filmleri: abella danger izle – Abella Danger
http://angelawhite.pro/# Angela White
Angela White izle: abella danger video – Abella Danger
Sweetie Fox izle: sweeti fox – Sweetie Fox filmleri
http://lanarhoades.fun/# lana rhoades video
lana rhoades filmleri: lana rhoades modeli – lana rhoades video
lana rhoades modeli: lana rhoades modeli – lana rhoades
online dating women: http://sweetiefox.pro/# sweetie fox
http://evaelfie.site/# eva elfie hot
https://miamalkova.life/# mia malkova new video
http://miamalkova.life/# mia malkova videos
internet dating site: https://miamalkova.life/# mia malkova full video
http://evaelfie.site/# eva elfie photo
dating sites for mature singles adults: https://evaelfie.site/# eva elfie new video
http://evaelfie.site/# eva elfie full videos
https://miamalkova.life/# mia malkova only fans
https://lanarhoades.pro/# lana rhoades unleashed
eva elfie hd: eva elfie new video – eva elfie full video
http://evaelfie.site/# eva elfie full video
searchingforsingles: http://sweetiefox.pro/# sweetie fox video
https://sweetiefox.pro/# sweetie fox full video
https://lanarhoades.pro/# lana rhoades videos
http://evaelfie.site/# eva elfie full video
eva elfie hot: eva elfie videos – eva elfie full videos
dating awareness women’s network: https://miamalkova.life/# mia malkova full video
http://evaelfie.site/# eva elfie videos
aviator pin up casino: pin-up casino login – cassino pin up
https://jogodeaposta.fun/# aviator jogo de aposta
https://aviatormalawi.online/# aviator game
https://aviatoroyunu.pro/# aviator sinyal hilesi
http://jogodeaposta.fun/# deposito minimo 1 real
play aviator: aviator bet malawi login – aviator game online
aviator hilesi: aviator bahis – aviator oyna slot
mexican pharmaceuticals online: Mexico pharmacy online – mexico drug stores pharmacies mexicanpharm.shop
best online pharmacies in mexico: Mexico pharmacy price list – purple pharmacy mexico price list mexicanpharm.shop
п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india: cheapest online pharmacy – indian pharmacy paypal indianpharm.store
п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india: Online India pharmacy – top online pharmacy india indianpharm.store
generic amoxicillin over the counter buy amoxicillin 500mg usa amoxicillin 500 mg tablets
can you buy generic clomid buy clomid get generic clomid without dr prescription
how can i order prednisone prednisone tabs 20 mg can you buy prednisone over the counter uk
no prescription pharmacy paypal: Online pharmacy USA – no prescription needed pharmacy
legal online pharmacy coupon code: pharmacy online – overseas pharmacy no prescription
canadian mail order prescriptions: canadian pharmacy online no prescription needed – canada prescriptions by mail
best online ed medication: ed pills – cheap ed
edmeds online ed pharmacy erectile dysfunction medication online
canadian mail order prescriptions: buying prescription drugs online from canada – buying prescription drugs online canada
indian pharmacy online indian pharmacies safe п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
canadian discount pharmacy pharmacy canadian superstore canadian pharmacy 24h com safe
https://indianpharm.shop/# п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
indian pharmacy online best india pharmacy п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
http://indianpharm.shop/# mail order pharmacy india
medication from mexico pharmacy reputable mexican pharmacies online mexico drug stores pharmacies
ordering drugs from canada: canadian drugstore online – certified canadian pharmacy
https://canadianpharm.guru/# canada pharmacy online legit
pharmacy rx world canada best canadian online pharmacy is canadian pharmacy legit
aviator casino oyunu: aviator oyunu 100 tl – aviator sinyal hilesi ucretsiz
aviator oyunu: aviator oyna 20 tl – aviator hilesi
pin-up giris: pin up casino giris – pin-up casino giris
http://aviatoroyna.bid/# aviator oyna slot
pin up bet: pin-up giris – pin-up bonanza
gates of olympus 1000 demo: gates of olympus demo turkce – gates of olympus max win
aviator nas?l oynan?r: aviator oyunu 10 tl – aviator sinyal hilesi ucretsiz
http://mexicanpharmacy.shop/# mexican rx online
https://mexicanpharmacy.shop/# mexican drugstore online
india pharmacy: Cheapest online pharmacy – world pharmacy india
https://canadianpharmacy24.store/# cross border pharmacy canada
http://mexicanpharmacy.shop/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
mexico drug stores pharmacies mexican pharmacy buying prescription drugs in mexico online
otc prednisone cream: buy prednisone online without a script – buy prednisone online no prescription
clomid price: order generic clomid online – cost of cheap clomid tablets
cheap kamagra: Kamagra Oral Jelly Price – Kamagra 100mg price
п»їkamagra: Kamagra Oral Jelly Price – cheap kamagra
http://kamagraiq.shop/# cheap kamagra
п»їkamagra: kamagra best price – super kamagra
order viagra cheapest viagra Cheap generic Viagra
viagra canada: Buy generic 100mg Viagra online – order viagra
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacy: legitimate canadian pharmacies – legit canadian pharmacy online
canadian pharmacy meds review: CIPA approved pharmacies – reliable canadian pharmacy
top 10 online pharmacy in india: online pharmacy india – buy medicines online in india
india pharmacy indian pharmacy delivery buy medicines online in india
purple pharmacy mexico price list: online pharmacy in Mexico – п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
https://ciprofloxacin.guru/# buy cipro online canada
http://nolvadex.icu/# tamoxifen adverse effects
ciprofloxacin mail online: buy cipro online without prescription – ciprofloxacin mail online
https://ciprofloxacin.guru/# buy cipro without rx
cytotec online: Misoprostol 200 mg buy online – buy cytotec online
http://ciprofloxacin.guru/# cipro for sale
tamoxifen therapy: tamoxifen premenopausal – nolvadex pct
cost of amoxicillin: order amoxicillin online no prescription – amoxicillin 500 mg for sale
zithromax prescription: zithromax capsules price – buy zithromax 1000mg online
cheap ed meds online: cheap boner pills – ed prescriptions online
best ed medication online: how to get ed pills – cheapest erectile dysfunction pills
https://medicationnoprescription.pro/# can i buy prescription drugs in canada
cheapest pharmacy to get prescriptions filled pharmacy discount coupons canada drugs coupon code
choi casino tr?c tuy?n tren di?n tho?i [url=https://casinvietnam.shop/#]casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam[/url] danh bai tr?c tuy?n
web c? b?c online uy tin casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam casino online uy tin
casino online uy tin casino tr?c tuy?n game c? b?c online uy tin
https://casinvietnam.com/# casino tr?c tuy?n uy tin
https://casinvietnam.shop/# casino tr?c tuy?n vi?t nam
http://indiaph24.store/# top 10 pharmacies in india
п»їbest mexican online pharmacies buying prescription drugs in mexico online purple pharmacy mexico price list
mexico drug stores pharmacies buying prescription drugs in mexico online best online pharmacies in mexico
http://canadaph24.pro/# reliable canadian pharmacy
buy prescription drugs from india indian pharmacy indian pharmacy online
indianpharmacy com http://indiaph24.store/# indian pharmacy paypal
Online medicine home delivery
buy prescription drugs from india indian pharmacy indianpharmacy com
india online pharmacy Generic Medicine India to USA indian pharmacy paypal
http://canadaph24.pro/# reputable canadian pharmacy
buying prescription drugs in mexico online Mexican Pharmacy Online mexico drug stores pharmacies
https://canadaph24.pro/# reddit canadian pharmacy
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa mexican mail order pharmacies
indian pharmacy online buy medicines from India top 10 pharmacies in india
buy medicines online in india Cheapest online pharmacy world pharmacy india
top 10 online pharmacy in india indian pharmacy fast delivery top 10 pharmacies in india
https://indiaph24.store/# Online medicine home delivery
canadian pharmacy online reviews Licensed Canadian Pharmacy canadian pharmacy king reviews
mexican pharmacy Mexican Pharmacy Online purple pharmacy mexico price list
https://indiaph24.store/# india pharmacy mail order
mexican rx online mexican pharmacy mexico drug stores pharmacies
canada pharmacy online Prescription Drugs from Canada canadian mail order pharmacy
online canadian drugstore Large Selection of Medications from Canada canadian pharmacy ratings
https://canadaph24.pro/# canada drugs
п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india india pharmacy mail order indian pharmacy paypal
http://mexicoph24.life/# medicine in mexico pharmacies
best canadian online pharmacy Prescription Drugs from Canada canadapharmacyonline com
canada cloud pharmacy Large Selection of Medications from Canada canadian pharmacy world
https://canadaph24.pro/# my canadian pharmacy rx
http://nolvadex.life/# does tamoxifen cause menopause
https://cytotec.club/# Abortion pills online